Net Zero in the United States vs. Globally

Introduction

Net zero has become a central objective in the global effort to combat climate change. Countries and companies around the world are setting ambitious targets to achieve a balance between the greenhouse gas emissions they produce and the amount they remove from the atmosphere. This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the net zero landscape, comparing the progress and challenges in the United States with the global scenario. It focuses on the countries and investors that are leading the way in implementing net zero strategies and offering incentives for companies that prioritize sustainability.

Defining Net Zero and its Implications

Net zero is a state where the amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) released into the atmosphere is balanced by an equivalent amount removed. This balance is achieved through a combination of reducing emissions and actively removing GHGs from the atmosphere¹. Reaching net zero is crucial because it effectively halts the increase of GHG concentrations in the atmosphere, which is the primary driver of climate change².

While the terms "net zero" and "carbon neutral" are often used interchangeably, there is a key distinction. Carbon neutrality focuses on offsetting emissions without necessarily reducing the overall amount produced. In contrast, net zero emphasizes reducing emissions as much as possible and using offsets only for unavoidable residual emissions³.

The implications of transitioning to a net-zero economy vary significantly across different sectors. Carbon-intensive industries, such as fossil fuels, transportation, agriculture, and heavy industry, face the most substantial challenges. These sectors will need to undergo significant transformations, which could lead to job losses in some areas⁴. However, the net-zero transition also presents significant opportunities for growth in new markets for low-emission products and services⁵.

Countries Mandating or Incentivizing Net Zero

A growing number of countries are demonstrating their commitment to net zero through legally mandated targets and incentives. Leading the way are Sweden, the United Kingdom, France, Denmark, New Zealand, and Hungary, all of which have adopted legally binding net-zero targets⁶. The European Union is also considering a proposal to legally mandate a net-zero target by 2050⁶.

Beyond legal mandates, various countries are implementing incentives to encourage businesses and individuals to contribute to the net-zero goal. The United States, for example, launched the Net-Zero Government Initiative, which calls on governments to achieve net-zero emissions from their operations by 2050⁸. This initiative has garnered support from numerous countries, including Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, and others⁸.

While the increasing number of countries with net-zero targets is encouraging, it's important to note that only a small percentage of these targets are legally binding⁹. This lack of enforceability raises concerns about the effectiveness of voluntary pledges in driving the necessary emissions reductions to achieve the global net-zero goal.

Key Insight: The limited enforceability of net-zero targets highlights the need for stronger mechanisms to hold countries accountable for their commitments. International agreements and cooperation will be crucial in ensuring that net-zero pledges translate into concrete actions and measurable progress.

Investors Prioritizing Net Zero

Investors are increasingly recognizing the importance of net zero and incorporating it into their investment decisions. A significant portion of the investor community views climate change as a top priority for businesses¹⁰. They expect businesses to implement net-zero transformations to enhance profitability, build trust, and attract capital¹⁰. This focus on climate action is driven by both a sense of responsibility and commercial motivations, with many investors seeing it as a way to increase investment returns¹¹.

Several global investors and investment firms are at the forefront of prioritizing net zero in their portfolios. The UN-convened Net-Zero Asset Owner Alliance, for example, requires signatories to commit to transitioning their portfolios to net-zero emissions by 2050¹². This alliance includes major investors with trillions of dollars in assets¹². The Net Zero Asset Managers initiative further demonstrates the growing momentum in the investment sector towards net zero, with a significant number of asset managers committing to support the transition¹³.

Some investment firms are going beyond simply prioritizing net-zero companies and are offering premium investment products specifically for those companies that are actively pursuing net-zero strategies. AXA Investment Managers, for instance, launched a global bond strategy focused on the carbon transition, investing in companies on the path to net zero¹⁴. This strategy aims to finance decarbonization while providing financial returns¹⁴.

However, it's important to acknowledge the concerns regarding greenwashing in corporate reporting. Investors are increasingly aware of the potential for companies to overstate their environmental credentials¹¹. This highlights the need for greater transparency and assurance in sustainability reporting to ensure that investor decisions are based on accurate and reliable information.

Impact of Net Zero on US Companies

Net-zero regulations and investor preferences are having a significant impact on US companies and industries. Companies are increasingly driven to adopt sustainable practices, leading to cost savings, enhanced brand reputation, and increased customer loyalty¹⁵. Apple Inc., for example, achieved carbon neutrality across its corporate operations in 2020 by implementing a comprehensive strategy that includes transitioning to renewable energy, improving energy efficiency, and investing in carbon removal projects¹⁵.

Investor preferences for net-zero aligned companies are pushing businesses to decarbonize their operations and supply chains¹⁶. This shift in investor priorities is creating new opportunities for companies that can demonstrate their commitment to net zero and attract capital from investors seeking sustainable investments¹⁷.

Despite this positive momentum, challenges remain in scaling the necessary climate investments across the US industrial sector. Corporate commitments and spending often fall short of the country's net-zero targets¹⁸. Furthermore, consumers often lack awareness and tend to opt for lower-cost, higher-carbon products, which hinders the transition to a net-zero economy¹⁸. Another significant barrier is the lack of a strong investment case and the slow scale-up of essential infrastructure, such as charging stations for electric vehicles and grid upgrades to support renewable energy integration¹⁹.

Key Insight: The private sector plays a crucial role in driving the net-zero transition. Companies like Apple are demonstrating that net zero can be achieved while enhancing profitability and brand reputation. However, addressing market barriers and consumer awareness will be essential to accelerate progress.

Comparing Net Zero Landscapes

The net-zero landscape in the US presents a mixed picture compared to other countries and regions. While the US has set a national goal of reaching net-zero emissions by 2050, progress and implementation vary significantly across different regions and sectors²⁰.

US vs. Other Leading Countries/Regions:

Regional Variations within the US:

Analysis of regional benchmarks in the US and Europe has indicated the US is closer to reaching net zero emissions, defying expectations the eurozone has been ahead in terms of carbon reduction²¹. However, this overall picture masks significant regional variations within the US²². The Northeast, for example, has achieved a more substantial reduction in emissions compared to the Midwest, which still relies heavily on fossil fuels²². This difference highlights the need for tailored policies and initiatives that address the specific challenges and opportunities in each region.

US Cities Leading the Way:

Several US cities are demonstrating leadership in the transition to net zero. San Francisco, Austin, and Boston, despite being located in different geographic regions, are all making significant progress towards their climate goals²³. These cities have implemented various strategies, including promoting renewable energy, improving energy efficiency in buildings, and investing in sustainable transportation. They offer valuable lessons for other cities looking to accelerate their net-zero transitions.

Challenges in the Net-Zero Transition:

Several challenges could hinder the progress towards net zero in the US and globally.

• Securing Critical Minerals: The transition to a net-zero economy requires a significant increase in the production of technologies that rely on critical minerals and rare earth elements, such as batteries for electric vehicles and solar panels²⁴. Securing access to these minerals, which are often concentrated in a few countries, will be crucial for ensuring a smooth and equitable transition.
• Declining Net-Zero Targets: In some regions, particularly Europe, there is a concerning trend of declining net-zero targets due to factors like high energy prices, economic slowdown, and concerns about energy security²⁴. This highlights the need for policies that address the economic and social challenges of the transition and ensure a just and equitable outcome for all.
• Impact of Higher Interest Rates: Rising interest rates pose a challenge to financing the net-zero transition, particularly for capital-intensive projects like renewable energy installations²⁴. This underscores the need for innovative financing mechanisms and government support to ensure that the transition remains economically viable.
• Coal Consumption in China: Despite its net-zero pledge, China's coal consumption continues to rise, driven by increasing energy demand and economic growth²⁴. This highlights the challenges of achieving net zero even in countries with ambitious targets and the need for continued efforts to phase out coal and transition to cleaner energy sources.
• The UN Emissions Gap Report 2020: This report highlights the significant gap between current emissions reduction pledges and the actions needed to achieve the Paris Agreement goals⁷. It emphasizes the urgency of increasing ambition and accelerating action to avoid the worst impacts of climate change.

Key Insight: Achieving net zero requires a systems approach that considers the interconnectedness of different sectors and regions. Addressing regional variations, ensuring access to critical minerals, and overcoming challenges like rising interest rates will be crucial for a successful transition.

International Agreements and Initiatives

The US is actively involved in several international agreements and initiatives aimed at accelerating the global transition to net zero.

The Paris Agreement: This landmark agreement provides a framework for global climate action, with countries committing to submit updated national climate action plans (Nationally Determined Contributions, or NDCs) every five years²⁵. The Paris Agreement marks a significant shift towards a net-zero emissions world and is essential for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals²⁵.

Net-Zero Government Initiative: Launched by the US at COP27, this initiative invites governments to lead by example and achieve net-zero emissions from their operations by no later than 2050⁸. The initiative involves collaboration with various countries and aims to demonstrate leadership in reducing emissions from government activities⁸.

Net Zero World Initiative: This initiative is a partnership between countries working to implement their climate ambition pledges and accelerate transitions to net-zero, resilient, and inclusive energy systems²⁶. It leverages expertise across US government agencies and national laboratories to support global decarbonization efforts²⁷.

US Federal Sustainability Plan: This plan outlines the US government's commitment to achieving net-zero emissions across its operations²⁸. It includes specific objectives, such as:

• 100% zero-emission vehicle acquisitions by 2035, including 100% light-duty acquisitions by 2027.
• 100% carbon pollution-free electricity by 2030.
• A net-zero emissions building portfolio by 2045.

These initiatives demonstrate the US government's commitment to leading by example and supporting global efforts to achieve net zero.

Economic Benefits and Drawbacks

Achieving net zero in the US and globally presents both economic benefits and drawbacks.

Economic Benefits:

• Economic Growth and Job Creation: The transition to a net-zero economy can stimulate economic growth and create new jobs in emerging industries like renewable energy, green infrastructure, and carbon capture and storage²⁹. More broadly, net zero implies the move to decarbonized buildings and a circular economy, which could create hundreds of thousands of jobs³¹.
• Increased Energy Security and Resilience: Diversifying energy sources and reducing reliance on fossil fuels can enhance energy security and resilience²⁹.
• Cost Savings: Energy efficiency measures and the use of renewable energy can lead to significant cost savings for businesses and households³². For example, US households could save up to 25% on utility bills by replacing fossil fuel appliances with electric alternatives and upgrading building insulation³³.
• Improved Public Health: Reduced air pollution from fossil fuels can lead to improved public health outcomes³³.
• Innovation and Technological Development: The net-zero transition can drive innovation and technological development in clean energy and other sectors³⁴.
• Investment Opportunities: To reach net zero emissions by 2050, annual clean energy investment worldwide will need to more than triple by 2030 to around $4 trillion³⁵. This presents a significant investment opportunity in the clean energy sector.

Economic Drawbacks:

• Job Losses in Carbon-Intensive Sectors: The transition away from fossil fuels can lead to job losses in industries like coal, oil, and gas⁴.
• Higher Energy Costs in the Short Term: The transition to renewable energy sources may lead to higher energy costs in the short term³⁶.
• Economic Disruption: Rapid policy shifts and technological changes can cause economic disruption and uncertainty⁴. A disorderly transition could lead to energy price instability and geopolitical risks⁴.
• Investment Risks: Investments in new technologies and infrastructure carry inherent risks⁵.
• Potential for Inequitable Outcomes: The transition to net zero needs to be managed carefully to ensure that it does not disproportionately impact vulnerable communities or exacerbate existing inequalities³⁷. For example, there is a risk that net-zero initiatives could inadvertently restrain economic development in poorer nations by diverting resources for offsets³⁷.

Conclusion

The transition to a net-zero economy is a complex and multifaceted challenge with significant implications for the US and the world. While the US has made progress in setting targets and implementing policies, such as the Inflation Reduction Act and the Net-Zero Government Initiative, substantial efforts are still needed to achieve its net-zero goals and mitigate the risks of climate change.

The US faces a unique set of challenges and opportunities in this transition. While it is closer to achieving net zero than some other regions, it also faces significant regional variations in progress and the influence of powerful fossil fuel industries. The success of the US in achieving its net-zero goals will depend on a combination of factors, including:

• Stronger Policy Frameworks: Implementing clear and enforceable policies that incentivize emissions reductions and support the development and deployment of clean technologies.
• Technological Advancements: Continued innovation and investment in clean energy technologies, energy efficiency, and carbon removal solutions.
• Private Sector Engagement: Active participation and leadership from businesses and investors in decarbonizing their operations and supply chains.
• Public Awareness and Engagement: Educating the public about the importance of net zero and engaging communities in the transition.
• International Cooperation: Collaborating with other countries to share best practices, accelerate technological development, and ensure a just and equitable transition for all.

The potential economic and social impacts of net zero on the US are significant. While there are potential drawbacks, such as job losses in certain sectors and short-term increases in energy costs, the long-term benefits, including economic growth, job creation, improved public health, and increased energy security, outweigh the risks.

A key takeaway from this analysis is the need for a comprehensive and coordinated approach to net zero. This approach should involve clear and enforceable targets, supportive policies, investment in clean technologies, and engagement with all stakeholders, including businesses, investors, and communities. By addressing the challenges and capitalizing on the opportunities, the US can position itself as a leader in the global transition to a net-zero future and contribute to a more sustainable and prosperous world.

Works cited

1. What is net zero? | National Grid Group, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/energy-explained/what-is-net-zero
2. What is Net Zero? - Net Zero Climate, accessed January 19, 2025, https://netzeroclimate.org/what-is-net-zero-2/
3. What Is Net Zero? - IBM, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/net-zero
4. The risks of net-zero transition – and why we should embrace them | Zurich Insurance, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.zurich.com/knowledge/topics/global-risks/the-risk-of-net-zero-transition
5. The economic transformation: What would change in the net-zero transition - McKinsey & Company, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/sustainability/our-insights/the-economic-transformation-what-would-change-in-the-net-zero-transition
6. Law - Net Zero Climate, accessed January 19, 2025, https://netzeroclimate.org/sectors/law/
7. Top Countries in the Race to Net Zero Emissions - Net0, accessed January 19, 2025, https://net0.com/blog/net-zero-countries
8. CEQ Launches Global Net-Zero Government Initiative, Announces 18 Countries Joining U.S. to Slash Emissions from Government Operations - The White House, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.whitehouse.gov/ceq/news-updates/2022/11/17/ceq-launches-global-net-zero-government-initiative-announces-18-countries-joining-u-s-to-slash-emissions-from-government-operations/
9. Net Zero Pledges: Can They Get Us Where We Need to Go? - State of the Planet, accessed January 19, 2025, https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2021/12/16/net-zero-pledges-can-they-get-us-where-we-need-to-go/
10. Investors continue to prioritise climate action despite lacking trusted information - PwC, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/news-room/press-releases/2022/investors-continue-to-prioritise-climate-action-despite-lacking-trusted-information.html
11. Investors continue to prioritise climate action despite lacking trusted information - PwC, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.pwc.com/id/en/media-centre/press-release/2023/english/investors-continue-to-prioritise-climate-action-despite-lacking-trusted-information.html
12. The investor guide to climate collaboration - UN PRI, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.unpri.org/download?ac=12724
13. Net Zero Asset Managers initiative announces 41 new signatories, with sector seeing 'net zero tipping point' | Ceres, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.ceres.org/resources/news/net-zero-asset-managers-initiative-announces-41-new-signatories-with-sector-seeing-net-zero-tipping-point
14. Three key net zero investment opportunities | AXA IM Core, accessed January 19, 2025, https://core.axa-im.com/responsible-investing/insights/three-key-net-zero-investment-opportunities
15. The Financial Opportunities Of Going Net-Zero For US SMEs - Carbon Credit Capital, accessed January 19, 2025, https://carboncreditcapital.com/financial-benefits-going-net-zero-us-smes/
16. Investor's guide to decarbonization: part 1 - setting a net zero plan - Schroders, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.schroders.com/en-us/us/institutional/insights/investors-guide-to-decarbonization-part-1-setting-a-net-zero-plan/
17. The role of investment funds in the net zero transition - Greenly, accessed January 19, 2025, https://greenly.earth/en-us/blog/ecology-news/investment-funds-do-they-impact-carbon-footprint
18. Financing a more equitable climate future across U.S. industries - Brookings Institution, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/financing-a-more-equitable-climate-future-across-u-s-industries/
19. Businesses sound the alarm: Market barriers prevent critical net zero investments, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.wbcsd.org/news/businesses-sound-the-alarm-market-barriers-prevent-critical-net-zero-investments/
20. These 8 countries have already achieved net-zero emissions - The World Economic Forum, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/12/these-countries-achieved-net-zero-emissions/
21. Is the US closer to net zero than Europe? - PA Future, accessed January 19, 2025, https://future.portfolio-adviser.com/is-the-us-closer-to-net-zero-than-europe/
22. The Significant Regional Differences in U.S. Emissions Reduction - Responsible Alpha, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.responsiblealpha.com/emissions-and-investment-map
23. U.S. Cities Leading the Way Toward Net Zero - Climate Advisers, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.climateadvisers.org/insightsfeed/u-s-cities-leading-the-way-toward-net-zero/
24. The end of net-zero targets - InvestorNews, accessed January 19, 2025, https://investornews.com/critical-minerals-rare-earths/the-end-of-net-zero-targets/
25. The Paris Agreement | United Nations, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/paris-agreement
26. U.S. Launches Net-Zero World Initiative to Accelerate Global Energy System Decarbonization, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.energy.gov/articles/us-launches-net-zero-world-initiative-accelerate-global-energy-system-decarbonization
27. Net Zero World Initiative | International Activities | NREL, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nrel.gov/international/net-zero-world.html
28. CEQ Announces New Net-Zero Government Initiative Countries Joining U.S. to Cut Climate Emissions from Government Operations - The White House, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.whitehouse.gov/ceq/news-updates/2023/12/08/ceq-announces-new-net-zero-government-initiative-countries-joining-u-s-to-cut-climate-emissions-from-government-operations/
29. Net zero: benefits, challenges, strategies, and the power of nature-based solutions, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.green.earth/blog/net-zero-benefits-challenges-strategies-and-the-power-of-nature-based-solutions
30. Renewable energy – powering a safer future | United Nations, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/raising-ambition/renewable-energy
31. Net zero: economy and jobs - Energy & Climate Intelligence Unit, accessed January 19, 2025, https://eciu.net/analysis/briefings/net-zero/net-zero-economy-and-jobs
32. Net-Zero Economy | Department of Energy, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.energy.gov/topics/net-zero-economy
33. The Health, Economic and Community Benefits of Zero-carbon Buildings, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.wri.org/insights/health-economic-and-community-benefits-zero-carbon-buildings
34. The Economic Benefits of Reaching for a Net-Zero World - OneH2, accessed January 19, 2025, https://oneh2.com/the-economic-benefits-of-reaching-for-a-net-zero-world/
35. Net Zero by 2050 – Analysis - IEA, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.iea.org/reports/net-zero-by-2050
36. Whitepaper: The Economic Impact of Net Zero | Alpin Limited, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.alpinme.com/the-economic-impact-of-net-zero/
37. The risks and benefits for companies going net zero - The World Economic Forum, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/02/net-zero-risks-benefits-climate/