Natural Disasters & CRE: Business Continuity

Natural disasters, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, floods, and wildfires, can cause significant damage to commercial real estate (CRE) properties and disrupt business operations. This report aims to provide a comprehensive overview of business continuity planning in the context of natural disasters, focusing on preparedness, mitigation, recovery, and relevant insurance and government assistance programs.

Understanding Business Continuity

Business continuity involves organizations proactively planning and preparing to ensure they can maintain essential operations during and after disruptive events, such as natural disasters¹. This process includes identifying potential risks, developing strategies to mitigate their impact, and implementing recovery plans to restore normal operations. In the CRE context, business continuity extends beyond safeguarding physical structures to encompass tenant safety and operational resilience².

A critical aspect of business continuity management (BCM) is understanding the distinction between a Business Continuity Management Plan (BCMP) and a Disaster Recovery (DR) plan. While often used interchangeably, these terms have distinct meanings. A BCMP outlines the steps needed to ensure the continued delivery of key products and services in a disaster. In contrast, a DR plan focuses on the specific actions required to recover individual technology components and third-party dependencies to restore normal operations³.

Key Players in Business Continuity

Several companies specialize in providing business continuity planning and services to help CRE owners navigate the complexities of disaster preparedness. Here's an overview of some leading providers:

These companies offer a range of services tailored to different needs and risk profiles within the CRE industry. Selecting the right provider depends on the specific requirements of the property and its tenants.

Preparing a Business Continuity Plan

A robust business continuity plan is crucial for mitigating the impact of natural disasters on CRE properties. The following steps outline the key elements of developing an effective plan:

1. Risk Assessment and Business Impact Analysis: Identify potential natural disaster risks relevant to the property's location, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, floods, or wildfires. Evaluate the likelihood and potential impact of each risk on the property, its tenants, and overall business operations. Prioritize risks based on their severity and potential consequences⁹. A business impact analysis (BIA) helps assess the financial and operational consequences of disruptions, including lost revenue, increased expenses, and potential regulatory penalties¹⁰.
2. Essential Functions and Dependencies: Identify the critical business functions necessary for the property to operate effectively and maintain tenant satisfaction. Document the dependencies of these functions, such as key personnel, communication channels, IT systems, and vital records. This includes identifying dependencies on suppliers, clients, and other stakeholders⁹.
3. Recovery Strategies: Develop and document specific recovery strategies for each critical function. This may include securing alternate locations for temporary operations, establishing effective communication protocols to keep tenants and stakeholders informed, implementing data backup and recovery plans to safeguard critical information, and training employees on emergency procedures¹³.
4. Continuity Team: Assemble a dedicated team responsible for developing, implementing, and managing the business continuity plan. This team should include representatives from all critical business areas and have the authority to make decisions and take action during a disaster⁹.
5. Communication Plan: Establish clear communication channels for internal and external stakeholders. Ensure that all employees, tenants, customers, and partners have access to timely and accurate information during a disruption. This may involve using multiple communication methods, such as email, phone calls, text messages, and social media⁹.
6. Training and Testing: Conduct regular training sessions and drills to familiarize employees with the plan and assess its effectiveness. This includes testing response times, evaluating communication protocols, and identifying areas for improvement⁹. Incorporate cross-training plans to ensure that critical functions can be performed even if key personnel are unavailable¹². Establish alert levels to categorize the severity of different events and trigger appropriate responses¹².

It's crucial to remember that business continuity plans should be dynamic and adaptable, evolving to account for changing business needs and potential threats¹⁴. Regularly review and update the plan to ensure it remains relevant and effective.

Mitigating the Impact of Natural Disasters

While a business continuity plan focuses on operational resilience, proactive mitigation measures can significantly reduce the physical and financial impact of natural disasters on CRE properties. These measures include:

• Structural Enhancements: Implementing flood barriers, reinforcing roofs and windows, and elevating critical equipment can protect properties from damage caused by floods, windstorms, and other hazards¹⁶. Modern building codes play a crucial role in mitigating hurricane impacts by requiring properties to withstand certain wind speeds and storm conditions¹⁷.
• Sustainable Design: Incorporating resilient materials, green spaces, and energy-efficient systems can enhance a property's ability to withstand extreme weather events and reduce its environmental impact¹⁸.
• Insurance and Risk Management: Obtaining comprehensive insurance coverage, including flood and earthquake insurance, is crucial for protecting CRE assets from financial losses¹⁹. Working with insurance advisors and conducting regular risk assessments can help identify potential vulnerabilities and implement appropriate mitigation measures¹⁹. Brokers and advisors can play a key role in helping CRE owners anticipate and reduce insurance costs by discussing policy renewal options in advance and providing guidance on risk mitigation strategies²⁰.
• Early Warning Systems: Utilizing technology and data modeling to understand loss projection models and identify potential risks can help property owners take preemptive action to protect their assets¹⁶.

Recovering from a Natural Disaster

The recovery phase after a natural disaster involves a series of steps to restore normalcy and ensure the long-term viability of the CRE property. Key recovery actions include:

• Safety First: The immediate priority after a natural disaster is to ensure the safety and well-being of tenants and employees. Check for injuries, provide first aid if necessary, and secure the property to prevent further damage or harm. Address immediate health and safety concerns, such as contaminated water, gas leaks, or damaged electrical wiring²¹.
• Contact Authorities and Report Claims: Contact local authorities and emergency services to report the situation and request assistance if needed. Report the incident to your insurance company as soon as possible to initiate the claims process²².
• Damage Assessment: Conduct a thorough assessment of the damage to the property and its contents. Document the damage with photos and videos for insurance claims²².
• Communication and Support: Maintain open communication with tenants, employees, and stakeholders throughout the recovery process. Provide support and resources to those affected by the disaster, such as temporary housing, financial assistance, or counseling services²³.
• Restoration and Repairs: Begin the process of cleaning up, repairing, and restoring the property. Work with licensed contractors and follow insurance guidelines to ensure that repairs are done correctly and meet safety standards²².
• Physical and Emotional Well-being: Take steps to promote physical and emotional healing for yourself and those affected by the disaster. This may include ensuring access to healthy food, clean water, and adequate rest. Encourage relaxation techniques and stress management strategies. Seek professional help if needed to address emotional distress or trauma²¹.

Remember that disaster recovery and prevention go hand-in-hand¹¹. While focusing on recovery, take proactive steps to protect yourself and your property from future events. This may include reviewing and updating your business continuity plan, implementing mitigation measures, and staying informed about potential hazards.

Case Study: Hurricane Katrina's Impact on Businesses

Hurricane Katrina in 2005 provides a significant case study in business continuity and disaster recovery. The hurricane caused widespread damage and disruption to businesses in the Gulf Coast region, particularly in New Orleans. A DID (Difference-in-Differences) analysis of business exits in coastal counties after Hurricane Katrina revealed a stark difference between businesses in affected areas and those in unaffected areas. The analysis showed that the exit rate of businesses in coastal counties was similar to that of non-coastal counties before the hurricane. However, after the hurricane, there was a significant increase in business exits in the coastal counties of Louisiana. Statistical regression showed that the destruction caused by the hurricane led to a 1% increase in business exits in coastal counties, resulting in a 10-year recovery period²⁴.

Several federal programs were utilized to promote the recovery of homeowners and business owners in New Orleans, including:

• The Individual Assistance and Other Needs Assistance Programs administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
• The Small Business Administration (SBA) Disaster Loan Program.
• The Go Zone tax credits established by the Gulf Opportunity Zone Act of 2005.
• Road Home housing assistance provided through Federal Community Development Block Grant funding²⁵.

Examples of Business Continuity in Action

While Hurricane Katrina provides a large-scale example of disaster recovery, there are many other instances where businesses have successfully implemented business continuity plans to maintain operations during disruptions. Here are a few examples:

• Responding to a Facility Outage: A corporation implemented a plan that allowed employees to work remotely during a facility outage caused by a disaster. This ensured that critical business functions could continue without interruption²⁶.
• Maintaining Customer Support During a Cyberattack: A customer support department maintained service levels during a cyberattack by utilizing alternative communication methods, such as secondary email systems or emergency hotlines. This allowed them to continue addressing client inquiries and resolving issues despite the disruption to their primary communication channels¹³.
• Ensuring Service Continuity for an Electric Company: An electric company in Georgia experienced a failure with one of its data lines. To prevent future service interruptions, they implemented a FatPipe WARP at their main site, bonding two connections to achieve redundancy. They also readied plans for a third data line and replicated their mission-critical servers off-site, incorporating their own site-failover WARP. This multi-layered approach ensured that their critical systems could remain operational even in the event of a data line failure or a site-wide disaster²⁷.

These examples highlight the importance of proactive planning, adaptability, and effective communication in maintaining business operations during and after disruptive events.

Insurance for CRE Properties

Adequate insurance coverage is essential for protecting CRE properties from the financial impact of natural disasters. Key types of insurance to consider include:

• Building Insurance: Covers the physical structure of the property against damage from fire, windstorms, vandalism, and other perils²⁸.
• Liability Insurance: Protects against legal claims arising from accidents or injuries that occur on the property. This coverage is crucial for property owners as it can help cover legal expenses and potential settlements²⁸.
• Contents Insurance: Covers the contents of the property, such as furniture, equipment, and inventory. This is important for both property owners and tenants, as it can help replace damaged or lost items²⁸.
• Business Interruption Insurance: Replaces lost rental income if the property is damaged and tenants are forced to close their businesses temporarily. This coverage can help property owners maintain their income stream during the recovery period²⁸.
• Flood Insurance: Provides coverage for flood damage, which is often excluded from standard property insurance policies. If your property is located in a flood-prone area, this coverage is essential²⁸.
• Earthquake Insurance: Covers damage caused by earthquakes. This coverage is particularly important for properties located in earthquake-prone regions²⁸.

In addition to these core coverages, CRE owners should consider other specialized insurance options, such as crime insurance, debris removal insurance, and ordinance or law insurance²⁹. When selecting property insurance, it's important to understand the different levels of coverage available: Basic, Broad, and Special forms. Each form offers a different level of protection, and choosing the right one depends on the specific needs and risk profile of the property³⁰.

Government Assistance Programs

Various government assistance programs are available to support businesses affected by natural disasters. These programs can provide financial aid, resources, and guidance to help businesses recover and rebuild. Here are some key programs to consider:

• Small Business Administration (SBA) Disaster Loans: The SBA offers low-interest disaster loans to businesses of all sizes, non-profit organizations, and households to cover physical damage, personal property loss, and economic injury. These loans can be used to repair or replace damaged property, cover operating expenses, and provide working capital³¹.
• Community Development Block Grant - Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR): This program provides grants to states and local governments to support disaster recovery efforts, including housing, economic revitalization, and infrastructure repair. These funds can be used to help businesses rebuild, provide temporary housing for displaced residents, and support community development initiatives³³.
• Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Assistance: FEMA offers various programs to individuals and businesses affected by disasters, including temporary housing, financial assistance, and crisis counseling. These programs can provide immediate relief and support during the initial recovery phase²¹.
• State-Level Programs: Many states offer their own disaster assistance programs to support businesses and residents. For example, in Texas, Workforce Solutions Offices provide resources to both employers and job seekers, while the Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts offers information on filing taxes in the aftermath of a disaster³⁵.

Conclusion

Natural disasters present a significant challenge to the CRE industry, potentially causing substantial physical damage, disrupting business operations, and leading to financial losses. However, through proactive planning, mitigation measures, and effective recovery strategies, property owners can minimize the impact of these events and ensure business continuity.

Developing a comprehensive business continuity plan is crucial for CRE owners and managers. This plan should include a thorough risk assessment, identification of critical business functions and dependencies, development of recovery strategies, establishment of a dedicated continuity team, and a clear communication plan. Regular training and testing are essential to ensure the plan's effectiveness and adaptability.

In addition to operational resilience, proactive mitigation measures can significantly reduce the physical and financial impact of natural disasters on CRE properties. Structural enhancements, sustainable design principles, comprehensive insurance coverage, and early warning systems are all essential components of a robust mitigation strategy.

The recovery phase after a natural disaster requires a coordinated effort to restore normalcy and ensure the long-term viability of the CRE property. Prioritizing safety, conducting damage assessments, maintaining open communication, filing insurance claims promptly, and focusing on both physical and emotional well-being are crucial steps in the recovery process.

Looking ahead, the CRE industry faces increasing challenges due to the long-term implications of climate change. More frequent and severe natural disasters are likely to occur, requiring proactive adaptation strategies. Collaboration between property owners, tenants, government agencies, and insurance providers is essential to build resilience and ensure the continued success of the CRE sector in the face of these evolving risks.

Works cited

1. What is business continuity? Business continuity planning - SailPoint, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.sailpoint.com/identity-library/business-continuity
2. Business Continuity: How Resilient is Your Portfolio? - CBIZ, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.cbiz.com/insights/articles/article-details/how-resilient-is-your-portfolio-building-a-business-continuity-plan-in-commercial-real-estate
3. Issues with Business Continuity Management and Disaster Recover - Safe Systems, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.safesystems.com/blog/2022/12/your-guide-to-business-continuity-management-and-disaster-recovery-planning/
4. 20 Business Continuity Planning & Service Companies in 2024 | Metoree, accessed December 17, 2024, https://us.metoree.com/categories/7923/
5. 8 Business Continuity Providers You Should Know - Invenio IT, accessed December 17, 2024, https://invenioit.com/continuity/business-continuity-providers/
6. Business Continuity Management Solutions - Everbridge, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.everbridge.com/use-cases/business-continuity/
7. Business Continuity Planning | Protiviti US, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.protiviti.com/us-en/business-continuity-and-resilience
8. Business Continuity Services | Zurich Resilience Solutions, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.zurichna.com/risk/business-continuity-services
9. Business Continuity Plan (BCP): A Step-by-Step Guide - Object First, accessed December 17, 2024, https://objectfirst.com/guides/data-security/business-continuity-plan/
10. Planning and Testing Are Key to Being Able to Recover from a Disruption | NCUA, accessed December 17, 2024, https://ncua.gov/newsroom/ncua-report/2016/planning-and-testing-are-key-being-able-recover-disruption
11. 10 Steps for a Disaster Recovery Plan - School of Public Health - Tulane University, accessed December 17, 2024, https://publichealth.tulane.edu/blog/disaster-recovery-plan/
12. Business continuity plan (BCP) in 8 steps, with templates | BDC.ca, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.bdc.ca/en/articles-tools/business-strategy-planning/manage-business/business-continuity-8-steps-building-plan
13. Building resilience: A comprehensive business continuity plan sample and guide, accessed December 17, 2024, https://thoropass.com/blog/compliance/business-continuity-plan-sample/
14. 5 steps for creating a business continuity plan | Chubb, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.chubb.com/us-en/businesses/resources/is-your-business-prepared-to-recover-from-a-disaster.html
15. 10 Key Steps for Crafting a Robust Business Continuity Plan | Preparis, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.preparis.com/article/10-key-steps-crafting-robust-business-continuity-plan
16. www.moodys.com, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.moodys.com/web/en/us/insights/resources/hurricane-milton-three-lessons.pdf
17. The impact of hurricanes on CRE and the long road to recovery, accessed December 17, 2024, https://suncoastsvn.com/the-impact-of-hurricanes-on-cre-and-the-long-road-to-recovery/
18. Climate Risk and Resilience 101 - Education for CRE developers: Sustainable Building Design, Construction, and Operations, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.gaiadevelopment.com/education-posts/climate-risk-and-resilience
19. What Can CRE Owners Do to Mitigate Natural Disaster Risks - Voit Real Estate Services, accessed December 17, 2024, https://voitco.com/as-natural-disasters-drive-commercial-property-insurance-higher-what-can-commercial-property-owners-do-to-mitigate-risk/
20. Climate change impacts elevate US commercial real estate insurance costs - Deloitte, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/industry/financial-services/financial-services-industry-predictions/2024/impact-of-climate-change-on-commercial-real-estate-insurance-costs.html
21. www.fema.gov, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.fema.gov/pdf/areyouready/recovering_from_disaster.pdf
22. Natural Disaster Recovery Plan | Travelers Insurance, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.travelers.com/resources/weather/emergency-preparedness/natural-disaster-recovery-plan
23. Emotional Recovery | Disaster Relief - Red Cross, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.redcross.org/get-help/disaster-relief-and-recovery-services/recovering-emotionally.html
24. Understanding the Effects of Hurricane Katrina on Businesses in Louisiana, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.christiansiauwijaya.com/hurricane-katrina-project
25. Hurricane Katrina: A Study of the Awareness, Participation and Satisfaction of Federally Funded Programs - Bush School, accessed December 17, 2024, https://bush.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/2007FederalFundingHurricaneKatrina.pdf
26. Example Business Continuity Plan - Drata Help Center, accessed December 17, 2024, https://help.drata.com/en/articles/6232796-example-business-continuity-plan
27. 7 Real-Life Business Continuity Plan Examples You'll Want to Read - Invenio IT, accessed December 17, 2024, https://invenioit.com/continuity/4-real-life-business-continuity-examples/
28. Your Comprehensive Commercial Property Insurance Guide for 2024, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.commercialrealestate.loans/blog/commercial-property-insurance-guide/
29. What Types of Insurance Does a Commercial Real Estate Property Require?, accessed December 17, 2024, https://fnrpusa.com/blog/what-types-of-insurance-does-a-commercial-real-estate-property-require/
30. What Is Property Insurance in CRE? | Jones Insurance Guide - GetJones, accessed December 17, 2024, https://getjones.com/guide/property-insurance/
31. How to apply for an SBA disaster loan | USAGov, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.usa.gov/disaster-small-business
32. Assistance to Help Businesses | FEMA.gov, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.fema.gov/assistance/businesses/local-businesses
33. Disaster Recovery | NC Commerce, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.commerce.nc.gov/grants-incentives/disaster-recovery
34. Disaster Recovery Small Business Loan and Grant Program - HUD Exchange, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.hudexchange.info/programs/cdbg-dr/disaster-recovery-small-business-loan-and-grant-program/
35. Business & Community Emergency Recovery Resources - Texas.gov, accessed December 17, 2024, https://gov.texas.gov/business/page/recover