# Reentry Casualty Risk (< 1:10,000 / 15 J): Design-for-Demise vs. Controlled Ocean Reentry

*Thresholds (< 1:10,000 Ec, > 15 J kinetic energy) verified against NASA-STD-8719.14C and NASA ODPO guidance as of 2026-11-16.*

- **Section:** Orbital Sustainability (Disposal Regime)
- **Evidence Basis:** NASA-STD-8719.14C / FCC Part 25 / ODMSP
- **Primary Authority / Source:** NASA ODPO / FCC
- **As-Of / Horizon:** Active Nov 2026 (15 J Kinetic Energy Gate)
- **Reference PDF:** [Download 2-Page PDF](https://bcesg.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/wa-space-orbital-casualty-risk-demisability.pdf)
- **Infographic:** [View Infographic](https://bcesg.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/wa-space-orbital-casualty-risk-demisability-infographic.png)

> Uncontrolled atmospheric reentry is permitted only if predicted human casualty expectation (Ec) across all surviving fragments exceeding 15 joules remains below 1 in 10,000 (0.0001); otherwise, operators must execute a controlled reentry over uninhabited ocean.

## Documented Instrument & Engineering Record

- The 15-joule threshold: Under NASA-STD-8719.14C and U.S. Government ODMSP, any surviving piece striking Earth with kinetic energy > 15 joules contributes to the human casualty area.
- Why aluminum demises and titanium survives: Aluminum alloys melt around ~660 °C during peak aerothermal heating, whereas titanium (~1,668 °C), stainless steel (~1,400–1,500 °C), and tungsten balance weights frequently survive to ground impact.
- Two compliance paths: Designers either substitute demisable materials (Design-for-Demise) or budget enough delta-v for a targeted deorbit burn into the South Pacific Ocean Uninhabited Area (SPOUA).
- Constellation multiplier: When a single constellation deploys thousands of satellites, regulators scrutinize both per-satellite Ec and aggregate fleet casualty risk.

## Design-for-Demise vs. Controlled Reentry Tradeoffs

| Compliance Strategy | Engineering Mechanism | Primary Tradeoff |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Design-for-Demise | Replace Ti/SS with Al/composite; thin walls | Higher material/thermal engineering cost |
| Controlled Ocean Reentry | Targeted perigee burn into SPOUA | Requires high-thrust prop + large EOL delta-v |
| ORSAT High-Fidelity Run | 3D thermal-structural ablation modeling | Replaces conservative DAS sphere assumptions |

## Mission Designer, Compliance Lead & Founder Takeaways

- Never assume a small CubeSat or SmallSat automatically passes 1:10,000; a single dense titanium star-tracker baffle or steel flywheel can fail DAS.
- WA satellite manufacturers (SpaceX Redmond, Amazon Leo, BlackSky) publish demisability commitments in FCC ODMP filings.
- Running ORSAT early in preliminary design avoids last-minute ballast or propellant penalties before launch licensing.

## Connected Census Profiles, Segments & Rules

- [SpaceX Redmond Census Profile](https://bcesg.org/spacex-redmond-washington-space-cluster-profile/)
- [Amazon Leo (Redmond) Census Profile](https://bcesg.org/amazon-leo-washington-space-cluster-profile/)
- [NASA ODAR Contract Deliverable Guide](https://bcesg.org/wa-space-orbital-nasa-odar-contract-deliverable/)

## Primary Sources & Official Records

- [NASA Standards: NASA-STD-8719.14](https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/nasa/nasa-std-871914)
- [NASA ODPO: Orbital Debris Mitigation](https://orbitaldebris.jsc.nasa.gov/mitigation/)
- [eCFR: 47 CFR § 25.283](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-25/subpart-D/section-25.283)
