The EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD): Ushering in a New Era of ESG Transparency

The European Union (EU) is setting a new global standard for corporate accountability with the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). This groundbreaking legislation mandates comprehensive environmental, social, and governance (ESG) disclosures from a vast network of companies, marking a significant leap forward in the realm of sustainable business practices¹. The CSRD's impact is poised to reshape not only corporate reporting but also investment decisions and the broader sustainability landscape².

Expanding the Scope of Sustainability Reporting

Replacing the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD), the CSRD, which came into force in January 2024, significantly broadens the scope of companies required to report on their sustainability performance³. While the NFRD applied to roughly 12,000 companies, the CSRD expands this to over 60,000 companies, encompassing a wider range of businesses operating within the EU⁴. This includes all large companies, both listed and non-listed, as well as listed SMEs (excluding micro-enterprises)³.

To provide clarity on which companies fall under this expanded scope, the CSRD defines "large companies" as those meeting at least two of the following criteria: ³

• More than 250 employees
• A total balance sheet of more than €20 million
• A net turnover of more than €40 million

Furthermore, the CSRD extends its reach beyond EU borders to include non-EU companies with significant EU activity. This applies to subsidiaries of non-EU companies, such as US-based businesses, that meet the criteria for large companies⁵. It also includes non-EU companies with a net turnover of over €150 million in the EU market⁴. This extraterritorial reach underscores the EU's commitment to driving global sustainability standards.

This expansion reflects the growing recognition that ESG factors are integral to evaluating a company's long-term value and its impact on the environment and society⁶. By requiring a broader spectrum of companies to disclose their ESG performance, the CSRD aims to level the playing field and empower investors and stakeholders with the information necessary to make informed decisions.

Key Provisions of the CSRD

The CSRD introduces several key provisions that elevate the quality and comprehensiveness of sustainability reporting:

• Double Materiality: A cornerstone of the CSRD is the concept of "double materiality." This requires companies to report not only on how sustainability matters impact their business (financial materiality) but also on how their business activities affect sustainability matters (impact materiality)⁷. This approach ensures that companies consider both the financial risks and opportunities associated with ESG factors and their broader impact on society and the environment.
• Detailed Reporting Requirements: The CSRD mandates detailed disclosures across a wide range of ESG topics, encompassing environmental factors like climate change, pollution, water resources, and biodiversity, as well as social issues and governance practices⁸. These disclosures must adhere to the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), providing a standardized and comprehensive framework for sustainability reporting.

• Specific ESG Disclosures: To illustrate the practical implications of the CSRD, consider some of the specific disclosures required: ⁹

• Environmental: Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, energy consumption, waste management, and the use of natural resources.
• Social: Employment practices, working conditions, diversity, health and safety, supply chain management, and community engagement.
• Governance: Business ethics, anti-corruption measures, board diversity, and executive compensation.

• Assurance and Verification: To ensure the reliability of reported information, the CSRD mandates that companies obtain "limited assurance" from an independent auditor¹⁰. This means the auditor gathers sufficient evidence to validate the sustainability report, ensuring no material modifications are required for the ESG information. This requirement enhances the credibility of the reported data and instills greater confidence among stakeholders.
• Digital Tagging: The CSRD requires companies to digitally tag reported information using the European Single Electronic Format (ESEF)¹¹. This facilitates the comparability and analysis of sustainability data, enabling investors and stakeholders to readily assess a company's ESG performance.

Official Text and Legal Framework

The CSRD is formally known as Directive (EU) 2022/2464. It was adopted by the EU co-legislators on December 14, 2022, and published in the Official Journal of the European Union¹². The directive amends existing legislation, including Directive 2013/34/EU (the Accounting Directive), to incorporate sustainability reporting requirements¹².

Key aspects of the directive include:

• Transition to a Sustainable Economy: The CSRD requires companies to disclose information on their plans and strategies to ensure their business model and strategy are compatible with the transition to a sustainable economy¹³. This includes aligning with the goals of the European Green Deal, such as achieving climate neutrality by 2050¹³.
• Climate Change Mitigation: The directive mandates disclosures related to climate change mitigation, including information on the company's exposure to coal, oil, and gas¹³.
• Sustainability Reporting Standards: The European Commission is empowered to adopt delegated acts that supplement the directive and provide detailed sustainability reporting standards, including the ESRS¹³. These standards are crucial for ensuring consistency and comparability in sustainability reporting.

Timeline for Implementation

The CSRD is being implemented in a phased approach to allow companies time to adapt to the new requirements:

In addition to these general timelines, the CSRD includes specific provisions for certain aspects of reporting:

• Value Chain Disclosures: Recognizing the complexity of gathering data across the value chain, the CSRD provides a three-year grace period for value chain disclosures¹⁵. This allows companies time to establish the necessary processes and controls for collecting and reporting this information.
• Sector-Specific ESRS and NESRS: The timeline for finalizing sector-specific ESRS and non-EU ESRS (NESRS) extends to June 2026¹⁶. This provides additional time for the development of tailored reporting standards for specific industries and non-EU companies.
• EU Limited Assurance Standards: The EU is set to adopt limited assurance standards by October 2026¹⁶. This further strengthens the assurance requirements and provides a clear framework for auditors.

Benefits and Challenges of the CSRD

The CSRD is expected to yield numerous benefits, including:

• Increased Transparency and Accountability: By mandating detailed ESG disclosures, the CSRD promotes greater transparency and accountability in the corporate world, fostering trust among investors, consumers, and other stakeholders¹⁷. This transparency can enhance a company's reputation and attract responsible investments.
• Improved Data Quality and Comparability: The standardized reporting framework of the ESRS enhances the quality and comparability of sustainability data, facilitating better benchmarking and analysis of corporate sustainability performance². This allows investors to make more informed decisions and encourages companies to improve their ESG performance.
• Enhanced Stakeholder Engagement: The CSRD encourages companies to actively engage with stakeholders on sustainability issues². This engagement helps companies understand and address stakeholder concerns, build stronger relationships, and identify potential risks and opportunities related to ESG factors.
• Greater Integration of Sustainability into Business Strategy: The comprehensive nature of CSRD reporting elevates sustainability considerations in corporate decision-making². This integration can lead to more sustainable business practices, improved long-term performance, and increased resilience in the face of environmental and social challenges.
• Driving Innovation and Ethical Sourcing: The CSRD can foster innovation in sustainable business practices and promote ethical sourcing and responsible supply chain management¹⁸. This can lead to the development of new products and services, improved efficiency, and reduced environmental and social impacts throughout the value chain.
• Uncovering Cost Savings: Early compliance with the CSRD can reveal opportunities for cost savings, such as energy reduction and waste minimization¹⁹. By analyzing their ESG performance, companies can identify areas for improvement and implement measures that reduce costs and enhance efficiency.

However, the implementation of the CSRD also presents challenges:

• Data Collection and Management: Gathering and managing the extensive data required for CSRD reporting can be a significant hurdle, especially for companies with complex value chains²⁰. This requires robust data management systems and processes, as well as collaboration across different departments.
• Assurance and Verification: Obtaining assurance for sustainability disclosures can be costly and time-consuming²¹. Companies need to establish strong internal controls and documentation processes to ensure the accuracy and reliability of their data. The estimated €4 billion in additional annual costs due to external audits highlights the financial implications of this requirement¹⁷.
• Digital Tagging and Technology Integration: Implementing digital tagging may require companies to invest in new technologies and develop new skills²¹. This can be a challenge for companies with limited resources or those that are not yet digitally mature.
• Resource Constraints: Many companies, particularly SMEs, may face resource constraints in meeting the requirements of the CSRD²². This includes financial resources, human resources, and technical expertise.
• Stakeholder Engagement Challenges: Identifying and engaging with stakeholders for materiality assessment can be complex²³. Companies need to develop effective strategies for stakeholder mapping, communication, and feedback gathering.
• Breaking Down Data Silos: CSRD reporting often requires breaking down data silos within organizations²¹. This necessitates cross-functional collaboration and data integration, which can be challenging in organizations with traditional departmental structures.
• Cultivating a Sustainability-Centered Ethos: The CSRD necessitates a cultural shift within organizations, requiring them to cultivate an organizational ethos centered on sustainability²¹. This involves integrating sustainability into the company's values, mission, and decision-making processes.
• Aligning Disclosures with Business Goals: Aligning sustainability disclosures with overall business goals can be a challenge²¹. Companies need to ensure that their sustainability reporting reflects their strategic priorities and contributes to their long-term success.
• Balancing Transparency and Risk: Companies need to carefully balance transparency with potential reputational risks²². Disclosing sensitive information about their ESG performance could expose them to criticism or legal challenges.

Comparison with Other Sustainability Reporting Frameworks

The CSRD aligns with and builds upon existing sustainability reporting frameworks, such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), and the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)²⁴.

CSRD vs. GRI

While both the CSRD and GRI aim to enhance sustainability reporting, they differ in scope and applicability. The GRI is a voluntary framework used globally by organizations of all sizes, while the CSRD is a mandatory directive for large or listed companies within the EU²⁵. The CSRD builds upon the foundation set by the GRI, incorporating many of its principles and concepts²⁵.

To ensure a smooth transition for companies already using GRI standards, the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG) has collaborated closely with GRI in developing the ESRS²⁵. They have also published a draft for a joint interoperability index to further support the transition from the GRI framework to CSRD reporting²⁵.

CSRD vs. SASB

The CSRD aims to build upon the SASB standards, which provide industry-specific sustainability disclosure guidelines. This alignment promotes consistency across industries and facilitates the integration of SASB guidelines into CSRD reporting²⁴.

CSRD vs. ISSB

The CSRD and ISSB share a common goal of enhancing the quality and comparability of sustainability reporting. However, they differ in their approach to materiality. The ISSB focuses on single materiality, primarily considering the impact of sustainability issues on the company's financial performance. In contrast, the CSRD mandates a double materiality approach, requiring companies to report on both the impact of sustainability matters on their business and the impact of their business on sustainability matters²⁶.

Conclusion

The CSRD represents a pivotal moment in the evolution of ESG reporting. By mandating detailed and standardized disclosures, the directive promotes greater transparency and accountability in the corporate world. This increased transparency empowers investors and stakeholders to make informed decisions, while also driving companies to integrate sustainability into their core business strategies.

The CSRD's impact extends beyond mere compliance. It has the potential to:

• Reshape the investment landscape: By providing investors with comprehensive ESG data, the CSRD can facilitate the flow of capital towards sustainable businesses and contribute to the growth of sustainable finance.
• Drive innovation: The focus on sustainability can incentivize companies to develop new technologies, processes, and business models that reduce their environmental impact and create social value.
• Enhance competitiveness: Companies that proactively embrace the CSRD and demonstrate strong ESG performance can gain a competitive advantage in the EU market and beyond.
• Foster a culture of sustainability: By requiring companies to embed sustainability in their decision-making processes, the CSRD can contribute to a cultural shift towards greater environmental and social responsibility within organizations.

While the implementation of the CSRD presents challenges, it also offers a unique opportunity for companies to enhance their sustainability performance, build trust with stakeholders, and contribute to a more sustainable future. By proactively embracing the CSRD and integrating sustainability into their core business strategies, companies can position themselves for long-term success in a rapidly changing world.

Works cited

1. The synergy between CSRD and GRI - D-Carbonize, accessed January 5, 2025, https://d-carbonize.eu/csrd/csrd-gri/
2. What Is The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)? - IMD Business School, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.imd.org/blog/governance/csrd/
3. New developments to the CSRD: What are the implications for non-financial disclosures?, accessed January 5, 2025, https://eco-act.com/blog/csrd-non-financial-disclosure-in-eu/
4. Understanding the Global Impact of the CSRD - Novata, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.novata.com/resources/blog/the-global-impact-of-the-csrd/
5. What does the EU's CSRD mean for US businesses? - Sweep, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.sweep.net/insights/what-does-the-eus-csrd-mean-for-us-businesses
6. Compliance with CSRD: the challenges and strategic benefits for business, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.savvirecruitment.com/blog/compliance-csrd-challenges-strategic-benefits-for-business
7. The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive — How Companies Need to Prepare - Latham & Watkins LLP, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.lw.com/en/insights/2023/01/The-EU-Corporate-Sustainability-Reporting-Directive-How-Companies-Need-to-Prepare
8. CSRD: Implications for businesses inside + outside the EU - Quantis, accessed January 5, 2025, https://quantis.com/news/business-implications-eu-corporate-sustainability-reporting-directive-csrd/
9. Ultimate Guide to the EU CSRD ESG Regulation for Businesses | Blog | OneTrust, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.onetrust.com/blog/ultimate-guide-to-eu-csrd-esg-regulation-for-businesses/
10. CSRD Data Points & Disclosure Requirements - Workiva, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.workiva.com/blog/csrd-disclosure-requirements
11. Understanding CSRD and How to Comply with ESRS Disclosure Requirements - Apiday, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.apiday.com/blog-posts/understanding-csrd-and-how-to-comply-with-esrs-disclosure-requirements
12. Directive (EU) 2022/2464 amending Regulation (EU) No 537/2014, Directive 2004/109/EC, Directive 2006/43/EC and Directive 2013/34/EU, as regards corporate sustainability reporting, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.europeansources.info/record/proposal-for-a-directive-amending-directive-2013-34-eu-directive-2004-109-ec-directive-2006-43-ec-and-regulation-eu-no-537-2014-as-regards-corporate-sustainability-reporting/
13. Directive (EU) 2022/2464 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 December 2022 amending Regulation (EU) No 537/2014, Directive 2004/109/EC, Directive 2006/43/EC and Directive 2013/34/EU, as regards corporate sustainability reporting (Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive or CSRD), accessed January 5, 2025, https://climate-laws.org/document/directive-eu-2022-2464-of-the-european-parliament-and-of-the-council-of-14-december-2022-amending-regulation-eu-no-537-2014-directive-2004-109-ec-directive-2006-43-ec-and-directive-2013-34-eu-as-regards-corporate-sustainability-reporting-corporate-sustainability-reporting-directive_3a34
14. Impact of EU sustainability reporting on US companies - KPMG International, accessed January 5, 2025, https://kpmg.com/us/en/frv/reference-library/2024/latest-impact-of-eu-sustainability-reporting-on-us-companies.html
15. Heads Up — #DeloitteESGNow — Frequently Asked Questions About the E.U. Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (August 17, 2023; Updated February 23, 2024) | DART – Deloitte Accounting Research Tool, accessed January 5, 2025, https://dart.deloitte.com/USDART/home/publications/deloitte/heads-up/2023/csrd-corporate-sustainability-reporting-directive-faqs
16. CSRD reporting: What you need to know | Grant Thornton, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.grantthornton.com/insights/articles/esg/2023/csrd-reporting-what-you-need-to-know
17. The Costs and Benefits of CSRD Reporting - Ecobio Manager, accessed January 5, 2025, https://ecobiomanager.com/the-costs-and-benefits-of-csrd-reporting/
18. The Hidden Benefits of CSRD Compliance - Novotek UK, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.novotek.com/co-uk/news/csrd/
19. kpmg.com, accessed January 5, 2025, https://kpmg.com/nl/en/home/topics/environmental-social-governance/corporate-sustainability-reporting-directive.html#:~:text=Early%20compliance%20with%20CSRD%20also,innovations%20in%20the%20production%20process.
20. The Rise of ESG Reporting and Challenges of CSRD Compliance - ECODRISIL, accessed January 5, 2025, https://ecodrisil.com/the-challenges-of-csrd-compliance/
21. Navigating the CSRD: key insights and challenges - Acuity Knowledge Partners, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.acuitykp.com/blog/navigating-csrd-insights-challenges/
22. CSRD challenges and how to overcome them - Institute of Sustainability Studies, accessed January 5, 2025, https://instituteofsustainabilitystudies.com/insights/lexicon/csrd-challenges-and-how-to-overcome-them/
23. Implementing CSRD: Challenges and Opportunities - Cority, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.cority.com/blog/implementing-csrd-challenges-and-opportunities/
24. Key Aspects of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive - Lingaro Group, accessed January 5, 2025, https://lingarogroup.com/blog/the-corporate-sustainability-reporting-directive-key-aspects-and-implications-for-businesses
25. GRI reporting initiative and EU ESG and CSRD reporting - Ecobio Manager, accessed January 5, 2025, https://ecobiomanager.com/the-gri-reporting-initiative-and-the-european-esg-reporting/
26. ISSB vs. CSRD: Strategies for Global ESG Reporting Compliance | Netherlands, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.rsm.global/netherlands/en/insights/issb-vs-csrd-strategies-global-esg-reporting-compliance