Skip to content
Contact us

Supply Chain Disruptions & CRE

Picture of William Tygart

Introduction

The commercial real estate (CRE) industry faces unprecedented challenges due to disruptions in the global supply chain. These disruptions stem from events like the COVID-19 pandemic, geopolitical instability 1, and climate change, impacting various aspects of CRE, including construction, leasing, and property management. Effective supply chain management has become crucial for CRE businesses to mitigate risks, maintain business continuity, and ensure long-term success. This article explores the significance of supply chain management in CRE, examines the impact of disruptions, and provides best practices for mitigating risks and optimizing supply chain operations.

Impact of Supply Chain Disruptions on CRE

Supply chain disruptions can significantly impact CRE businesses in several ways. To better understand these impacts, let's examine them through categorized subheadings:

Construction and Development Impacts

  • Construction Delays: Delays in the delivery of construction materials can lead to project delays and cost overruns. This can affect developers, contractors, and investors, potentially impacting project feasibility and profitability. For example, a study by Moody's Analytics found that apartment projects completed in 2021 needed approximately three additional months for completion compared to historical data due to construction delays2.
  • Increased Costs: Rising transportation and material costs due to supply chain bottlenecks can increase construction and operating expenses for CRE businesses. This can affect project budgets, rental rates, and property values. The rising cost of transportation is a significant factor, as highlighted in a report by Industrial Property Loan, which states that "transportation costs are rising while timelines get longer." 3
  • Shift from "Just-in-Time" to "Just-in-Case" Inventory Management: Supply chain disruptions have forced many businesses to shift from a "just-in-time" to a "just-in-case" inventory management approach. This means that companies are now stockpiling more inventory to avoid potential shortages, leading to increased demand for warehouse space and driving up industrial property values3.

Operational Impacts

  • Labor Shortages: Shortages of skilled labor in the construction and logistics sectors can further exacerbate supply chain challenges. This can lead to project delays, increased labor costs, and difficulties in maintaining properties. The Industrial Property Loan report highlights this issue, stating that there is a "widespread shortage of truck drivers and warehouse personnel." 3

Financial Impacts

  • Reduced Occupancy Rates: Supply chain disruptions can affect tenant businesses, potentially leading to reduced occupancy rates in commercial properties. This can impact rental income and property values for landlords. For example, Finance Lobby reports that "the ability to scale up to meet demand is proving difficult" for businesses due to supply chain issues, potentially affecting their ability to lease space4.
  • Increased Tenant Turnover: Difficulties in obtaining necessary goods and services due to supply chain issues can affect tenant satisfaction and lead to increased tenant turnover. This can result in higher leasing costs 4 and lost revenue for landlords.
  • Impact on Multi-Family Residential Sector: Supply chain disruptions also affect the multi-family residential sector, as delays and increased costs in construction can impact the availability and affordability of housing units4.
  • Retailers Acquiring Industrial Space: An emerging trend is the increasing acquisition of industrial space by retailers to gain more control over their supply chains and offset disruptions. This trend is highlighted by Finance Lobby, which reports that "retailers are now major players in industrial real estate." 4 This further contributes to the rise in industrial property values.

These impacts are interconnected and affect various stakeholders in the CRE industry. For instance, labor shortages can exacerbate construction delays, leading to increased costs and potentially affecting property values and investment decisions. This highlights the need for a holistic approach to supply chain management in CRE.

Mitigating Supply Chain Risks in CRE

CRE businesses can take proactive steps to mitigate supply chain risks and ensure business continuity:

  • Identifying Alternative Suppliers: Having backup suppliers in case of disruptions with primary suppliers is crucial. This can involve diversifying sourcing strategies, conducting thorough due diligence on potential suppliers, and establishing strong relationships with multiple vendors5.
  • Inventory Management: Maintaining adequate inventory levels of essential materials and supplies can help minimize the impact of supply chain disruptions. This requires accurate demand forecasting, efficient stock management, and regular inventory audits6.
  • Logistics Planning: Developing robust logistics plans that ensure the timely delivery of goods and services is essential. This involves optimizing transportation routes, selecting reliable carriers, and implementing efficient warehouse and inventory management strategies7.
  • Near-shoring and Reshoring: To mitigate supply chain risks, many businesses are considering "near-shoring" or "reshoring" their manufacturing operations, bringing them closer to their target markets. This trend, mentioned in Global Trade Magazine 8, can significantly impact industrial real estate demand, as companies seek locations closer to home.

Best Practices for Supply Chain Management in CRE

In addition to risk mitigation strategies, CRE businesses can adopt best practices to optimize their supply chain operations:

Identifying Alternative Suppliers

  • Conduct Thorough Due Diligence: Evaluate potential suppliers based on their financial stability, track record, capacity, and commitment to quality and timely delivery. This includes assessing their financial health, analyzing their past performance, and understanding their ability to meet your specific needs5.
  • Diversify Sourcing Strategies: Explore different sourcing options, including domestic and international suppliers, to reduce reliance on single sources. This can involve identifying suppliers in different regions or countries, or considering alternative materials or products9.
  • Build Strong Supplier Relationships: Establish clear communication channels, negotiate favorable terms, and foster collaborative partnerships with suppliers. This can involve regular communication, joint problem-solving, and shared risk mitigation strategies5.
  • Utilize Technology: Leverage procurement platforms and data analytics to identify and evaluate potential suppliers, track their performance, and manage contracts efficiently. This can involve using online platforms to find suppliers, analyzing data to compare pricing and performance, and automating contract management processes10.

Inventory Management

  • Accurate Forecasting: Utilize historical data, market trends, and predictive analytics to forecast demand and optimize inventory levels. This can involve analyzing past sales data, monitoring market trends, and using AI-powered forecasting tools11.
  • Real-time Inventory Tracking: Implement inventory management systems that provide real-time visibility into stock levels, location, and movement. This can involve using barcoding, RFID tags, and GPS tracking to monitor inventory throughout the supply chain11.
  • Automated Ordering: Utilize automated ordering systems to streamline procurement processes and ensure timely replenishment of inventory. This can involve setting up automatic reordering points based on demand forecasts and inventory levels11.
  • Efficient Stock Management: Implement efficient warehouse management practices, including proper storage, handling, and organization of inventory. This can involve optimizing warehouse layout, implementing efficient picking and packing processes, and using technology to track inventory movement11.
  • Regular Inventory Audits: Conduct regular inventory audits to ensure accuracy, identify discrepancies, and minimize losses due to theft, damage, or obsolescence. This can involve physical counts, cycle counting, and reconciliation with inventory records11.

Logistics Planning

  • Optimize Transportation Routes: Utilize route optimization software and transportation management systems to identify the most efficient routes and minimize transportation costs. This can involve considering factors such as distance, traffic, and delivery time windows7.
  • Select Reliable Carriers: Partner with reliable carriers that have a proven track record of on-time delivery and excellent service. This can involve evaluating carrier performance based on metrics such as on-time delivery rate, damage rate, and customer satisfaction7.
  • Implement Efficient Warehouse Management: Utilize warehouse management systems to optimize storage space, streamline picking and packing processes, and improve overall warehouse efficiency. This can involve using technology to track inventory location, manage warehouse layout, and automate picking and packing processes7.
  • Establish a Reverse Logistics Workflow: Develop a clear process for handling returns, repairs, and disposal of goods to minimize waste and optimize resource utilization. This can involve establishing clear procedures for receiving returns, inspecting goods, and processing repairs or replacements7.
  • Public Infrastructure Improvements: Investing in and advocating for public infrastructure improvements, such as roads, bridges, and ports, can significantly enhance logistics efficiency and reduce transportation costs for CRE businesses3.

Leveraging Technology for Supply Chain Optimization

  • Data Analytics: Analyze supply chain data to identify trends, predict potential disruptions, and optimize inventory and logistics operations. This can involve using data analytics tools to track key performance indicators (KPIs), identify bottlenecks, and optimize inventory levels12.
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI): Utilize AI-powered solutions for demand forecasting, inventory optimization, and risk management. This can involve using AI algorithms to predict demand, optimize inventory levels, and identify potential supply chain disruptions12.
  • Internet of Things (IoT): Implement IoT sensors to track inventory in real-time, monitor environmental conditions in warehouses, and optimize energy consumption. This can involve using sensors to track inventory movement, monitor temperature and humidity levels in warehouses, and control lighting and HVAC systems13.
  • Blockchain: Utilize blockchain technology to enhance transparency and traceability in the supply chain, improve security, and reduce fraud. This can involve using blockchain to track the origin and movement of goods, verify authenticity, and prevent counterfeiting13.
  • Optimizing the Leasing Process: Technology can streamline the leasing process by automating document processing, creating tenant portals for communication and service requests, and using data analytics to identify and attract potential tenants14.

Technology and Sustainability in CRE Supply Chain Management

Technology plays a crucial role in enhancing supply chain management in CRE. In addition to the technologies mentioned above, technology can also be used to improve tenant experience. Tenant portals and smart building technologies can provide tenants with greater control over their environment, access to building services, and improved communication with property managers15.

Sustainability is also an important consideration in CRE supply chain management. By incorporating sustainable practices, CRE businesses can reduce their environmental impact, enhance their reputation, and attract environmentally conscious tenants. Some key initiatives include:

  • Green Building Materials: Utilize sustainable building materials with low environmental impact and high energy efficiency. This can involve using recycled or renewable materials, and selecting materials with low embodied carbon16.
  • Waste Reduction: Implement waste reduction programs, including recycling and composting, to minimize waste generation and promote resource conservation. This can involve setting up recycling programs for construction waste, implementing composting programs for organic waste, and reducing packaging waste17.
  • Energy Efficiency: Optimize energy consumption in buildings and transportation through energy-efficient design, renewable energy sources, and smart building technologies. This can involve using energy-efficient lighting and HVAC systems, installing solar panels, and implementing building management systems to optimize energy use16.
  • Green Transportation: Promote the use of green transportation options, such as electric vehicles and public transportation, to reduce carbon emissions. This can involve providing charging stations for electric vehicles, encouraging the use of public transportation, and implementing transportation demand management programs17.

Sustainable supply chains offer numerous benefits, including reduced costs, improved brand image, and increased customer loyalty18. They also contribute to a healthier environment and a more resilient society19.

Conclusion

Supply chain management is critical for success in the CRE industry, especially in the face of ongoing disruptions. By implementing effective risk mitigation strategies, adopting best practices, and leveraging technology and sustainability initiatives, CRE businesses can optimize their supply chain operations, ensure business continuity, and achieve long-term success.

The trends discussed in this article, such as the shift towards near-shoring, the increasing use of technology, and the growing importance of sustainability, will likely reshape the future of CRE. We can expect to see increased demand for industrial properties in strategic locations, greater adoption of technology for supply chain optimization, and a growing emphasis on sustainable building practices and green transportation. These trends will create both challenges and opportunities for CRE businesses, and those who adapt and innovate will be best positioned for success in the long term.

Works cited

  1. Supply Chain Disruption - Counselors of Real Estate, accessed December 17, 2024, https://cre.org/real-estate-issues/supply-chain-disruption/
  2. Potential Impacts of the Supply Chain Disruptions on Commercial ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.moodyscre.com/insights/cre-news/supply-chain-disruptions-commercial-real-estate/
  3. How Do Supply Chain Issues Impact Industrial CRE? | Industrial ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://industrialproperty.loan/blog/how-do-supply-chain-issues-impact-industrial-cre/
  4. Is the Supply Chain Disruption a CRE Problem? - Finance Lobby, accessed December 17, 2024, https://financelobby.com/cre-insights/is-the-supply-chain-disruption-a-cre-problem/
  5. Sourcing Strategies for High Performing CRE and FM Supplier ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://trascent.com/insights/perspectives/next-generation-sourcing-strategies-that-deliver-high-performing-cre-fm-supplier-relationships/
  6. 8 Best Practices for Effective Inventory Management - Clue Insights, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.getclue.com/blog/best-practices-for-inventory-management
  7. Logistics Planning: Benefits & Best Practices Guide, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.unleashedsoftware.com/blog/logistics-planning/
  8. How New Supply Chain Disruptors Affect Retail CRE: Part II - Colliers - Knowledge Leader, accessed December 17, 2024, https://knowledge-leader.colliers.com/editor/future-supply-chain-disruptors-and-the-affect-retail-cre-part-ii/
  9. Finding Alternative Suppliers For Your Business | Cogent Analytics, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.cogentanalytics.com/knowledge-center/exit-succession-planning-blogs/finding-alternative-suppliers-for-your-business/
  10. The best bidding method for your CRE sourcing initiative : A comparative analysis of popular competitive methods - EY, accessed December 17, 2024, https://assets.ey.com/content/dam/ey-sites/ey-com/sv_se/topics/consulting/ey-vested-the-best-bidding-method-for-your-cre-sourcing-initiative.pdf
  11. 5 best practices for retail inventory management | RM Magazine, accessed December 17, 2024, https://retail-merchandiser.com/news/5-best-practices-for-retail-inventory-management/
  12. Navigating the Digital Age: The Role of Technology in Supply Chain ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.ucumberlands.edu/blog/the-role-of-technology-in-supply-chain-management
  13. 5 Ways Technology Can Improve Your Supply Chain Management ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.cnb.com/business-banking/insights/technology-to-improve-supply-chain.html
  14. Areas Where Digital Transformation Adds the Most Value to CRE - Ascendix Tech, accessed December 17, 2024, https://ascendixtech.com/digital-transformation-in-commercial-real-estate/
  15. How CRE Technology Transforms Commercial Real Estate | MRI ..., accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.mrisoftware.com/au/blog/how-is-cre-technology-transforming-commercial-real-estate/
  16. Sustainability in CRE - Matthews Real Estate Investment Services, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.matthews.com/thought-leadership-sustainability-in-cre/
  17. CRE Sustainability and the Future of ESG - AtlasX, accessed December 17, 2024, https://atlasx.co/blog/cre-sustainability-and-the-future-of-esg
  18. Supply Chain Sustainability: Importance, Roles & Best Practices | GEP, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.gep.com/supply-chain-sustainability
  19. Sustainability in CRE Development, Building, Operations - Biscred, accessed December 17, 2024, https://www.biscred.com/guides/sustainability