Managing Staffing Challenges During Extended School Closures

School closures, whether due to pandemics, natural disasters, or other unforeseen events, present significant challenges to educational institutions. One of the most critical challenges is managing staffing to ensure the continuity of essential functions and the well-being of both staff and students. This report explores key strategies for addressing staffing challenges during extended school closures, with a focus on maintaining operational efficiency and supporting staff during disruptions. Evidence indicates that proactive planning and a comprehensive approach are essential for navigating these challenges effectively.

Essential Personnel Identification

Identifying essential personnel is the first step in ensuring that critical functions can continue during school closures. This requires a careful analysis of the school's operations and the roles necessary to maintain essential services¹. Factors to consider include:

• Continuation of critical services: Identify roles essential for delivering instruction, maintaining student support services, and ensuring the safety and well-being of students and staff².
• Maintaining infrastructure: Determine the personnel needed to ensure the integrity of facilities, systems, and technology infrastructure².
• Legal and regulatory compliance: Identify roles required to meet legal and regulatory obligations, such as payroll, record-keeping, and compliance with state and federal guidelines¹.

Schools should develop clear guidelines for designating essential personnel, considering factors such as the nature of the disruption, the duration of the closure, and the specific needs of the school community³. In addition, schools should coordinate with community partners, such as local emergency management and first responders, to align their essential personnel identification with broader community response plans⁴. It is also important to ensure that essential personnel receive appropriate training to prepare them for their roles and responsibilities during closures⁵.

The COVID-19 pandemic broadened the understanding of "essential personnel" in schools. While teachers and administrators have always been considered essential, the pandemic highlighted the critical role of support staff in maintaining school operations and meeting the needs of students and families⁶. This includes roles such as cafeteria workers, bus drivers, custodians, and administrative assistants, who provide vital support for daily operations and ensure a safe and functional learning environment⁸.

To provide a clear overview of essential personnel categories, the following table summarizes their roles and responsibilities:

Remote Work Policies and Procedures

With the rise of remote work in education, schools need comprehensive policies and procedures to manage staff working remotely during extended closures⁹. Key considerations include:

• Clear expectations: Define expectations for work hours, communication, availability, and performance while working remotely⁹.
• Technology and equipment: Ensure staff have the necessary technology, equipment, and support to work effectively from home¹¹.
• Data security and confidentiality: Implement measures to protect sensitive information and ensure compliance with privacy regulations¹¹.
• Communication and collaboration: Establish clear communication channels and protocols for remote teams, including virtual meetings, online platforms, and instant messaging⁹.
• Work-life balance: It is important to emphasize that remote work is not a substitute for childcare. Staff members working remotely should have adequate care arrangements in place for dependents to avoid disruptions to their work responsibilities⁹.

Effective communication is crucial for managing remote teams in education¹². Best practices include:

• Regular check-ins: Conduct regular check-ins with individual staff members to monitor progress, provide support, and address any challenges¹³.
• Clear communication channels: Utilize a variety of communication tools, such as email, instant messaging, and video conferencing, to facilitate clear and timely communication¹⁴.
• Team collaboration: Encourage collaboration among remote team members through online platforms, shared documents, and virtual meetings¹².
• Social interaction: Promote social interaction among staff to maintain morale and build team cohesion¹².

Schools should also provide resources and training to support staff in adapting to remote work, including guidance on technology use, online communication etiquette, and strategies for maintaining productivity and well-being¹⁵.

In remote learning environments, it is essential to focus on evaluating student learning based on their ability to complete tasks rather than simply retrieving information¹⁶. This approach emphasizes the application of knowledge and skills, providing a more accurate assessment of student progress in a remote setting.

Furthermore, remote work can provide opportunities for staff to develop valuable communication and collaboration skills¹⁷. By effectively utilizing online communication tools and collaborating with colleagues in a virtual environment, staff can enhance their digital literacy and teamwork skills, which are increasingly important in today's workplace.

Cross-Training and Succession Planning

Cross-training and succession planning are essential strategies for mitigating staffing challenges during extended closures. Cross-training involves training staff to perform multiple roles, increasing flexibility and ensuring coverage for critical positions¹⁸. Effective cross-training strategies include:

• Identifying critical roles: Determine the roles most crucial for maintaining essential functions during disruptions¹⁹.
• Selecting suitable candidates: Identify staff members with the aptitude and willingness to learn new skills and take on additional responsibilities¹⁹.
• Developing clear training plans: Create structured training programs with clear objectives, timelines, and assessment methods¹⁹.
• Providing ongoing support: Offer ongoing support and mentorship to cross-trained staff to ensure they can effectively perform new roles¹⁹.

Cross-training not only benefits the organization by ensuring coverage for critical roles but also provides individual employees with growth opportunities and increased job satisfaction²⁰. By learning new skills and taking on different responsibilities, staff members can broaden their skillset, enhance their value to the organization, and experience greater job satisfaction.

Succession planning focuses on identifying and developing potential replacements for key positions, ensuring a smooth transition in case of staff absences or departures²¹. Best practices for succession planning in schools include:

• Identifying critical positions: Determine the positions most crucial for the school's long-term success²¹.
• Developing talent pipelines: Identify and develop potential successors through mentoring, professional development, and leadership opportunities²².
• Creating clear succession plans: Document clear plans outlining the criteria for selection, the development process, and the transition timeline²¹.
• Regularly reviewing and updating plans: Ensure succession plans are up-to-date and reflect the changing needs of the school²¹.

When implementing succession plans, schools should also consider the financial resources required to support the process, such as the costs of training, mentoring, and potential recruitment²³.

By implementing cross-training and succession planning, schools can create a more resilient workforce that can adapt to unexpected disruptions and maintain essential services.

Staff Well-being and Support

Extended school closures can significantly impact the well-being of staff, particularly during crises. Schools must prioritize staff well-being and provide adequate support to address stress, burnout, and mental health concerns²⁴. Strategies for supporting staff well-being include:

• Open communication: Encourage open communication and provide opportunities for staff to share concerns and seek support²⁴.
• Mental health resources: Provide access to mental health resources, such as counseling services, employee assistance programs, and online support groups²⁴.
• Stress management: Offer resources and training on stress management techniques, such as mindfulness, relaxation exercises, and healthy coping mechanisms²⁵.
• Work-life balance: To promote work-life balance, encourage staff to set clear boundaries between work and personal time. This may include limiting email responses to work hours, scheduling dedicated time for personal activities, and establishing clear expectations for communication and availability outside of work hours²⁶.
• Peer support: Foster peer support networks and create opportunities for staff to connect and support each other²⁷.

Schools can also implement initiatives to promote staff well-being, such as:

• Wellness programs: Offer wellness programs that focus on physical, mental, and emotional health, such as yoga classes, meditation sessions, and health screenings²⁸.
• Flexible work arrangements: Provide flexible work arrangements, such as remote work options or adjusted hours, to accommodate staff needs and reduce stress²⁹.
• Recognition and appreciation: Regularly recognize and appreciate the efforts of staff to boost morale and foster a positive work environment²⁹.

Communication and Coordination

Effective communication and coordination are essential for managing staff during extended school closures. Schools need to establish clear communication channels and protocols to keep staff informed, engaged, and coordinated³⁰. Key strategies include:

• Consistent and comprehensive communication: Utilize a variety of communication channels, such as email, text messaging, phone calls, and online platforms, to reach all staff members and provide regular updates on the situation, school closures, remote work policies, and available support services³¹.
• Clear and concise messaging: Ensure all communication is clear, concise, and easy to understand³².
• Two-way communication: Encourage two-way communication and provide opportunities for staff to ask questions and share feedback³³.
• Technology tools: Utilize technology tools, such as emergency notification systems, video conferencing platforms, and online collaboration tools, to facilitate communication and coordination³³.

During emergencies, schools should prioritize clear and timely communication to keep staff informed and engaged³¹. This includes providing regular updates on the situation, safety procedures, and any changes to school operations. Schools can also use technology to facilitate communication and coordination during extended closures, such as:

• Online learning platforms: Utilize online learning platforms, such as Google Classroom or Microsoft Teams, to deliver instruction, share resources, and maintain communication with students and families³⁴.
• Video conferencing tools: Use video conferencing tools, such as Zoom or Google Meet, to conduct virtual meetings, provide professional development, and maintain social interaction among staff³⁴.
• Collaboration tools: Utilize online collaboration tools, such as Google Docs or Microsoft SharePoint, to facilitate teamwork and information sharing³⁴.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

When managing staff during extended closures, particularly in relation to online communication and data security, schools need to ensure compliance with relevant laws and ethical guidelines³⁵. This includes adhering to employer rules for online engagement, protecting student privacy, and ensuring the responsible use of technology. Schools should provide clear guidelines to staff on appropriate online conduct, data security protocols, and the ethical use of technology for remote work and communication.

Conclusion

Managing staffing challenges during extended school closures requires a proactive and comprehensive approach. By identifying essential personnel, implementing remote work policies, investing in cross-training and succession planning, prioritizing staff well-being, and ensuring effective communication and coordination, schools can navigate disruptions, maintain essential services, and support the well-being of their staff and students.

The shift to remote work and the increasing reliance on technology in education present both challenges and opportunities for schools. While extended closures can disrupt traditional operations, they also provide an opportunity to reimagine how schools function and leverage technology to enhance learning and staff development. Investing in staff well-being, professional development, and robust technology infrastructure will be crucial for navigating future disruptions and ensuring the long-term success of educational institutions.

Works cited

1. Essential Personnel | Tulane Policy, accessed January 12, 2025, https://policy.tulane.edu/policy/essential-personnel
2. Essential Employees – Regulation and Policy Hub, accessed January 12, 2025, https://policy.ufl.edu/policy/essential-employees/
3. Designating Essential Personnel Guidance, accessed January 12, 2025, https://prepare.miami.edu/_assets/pdf/essential-personnel-guidance---05-18-2016.pdf
4. SchoolSafety.gov Emergency Planning Strategies and Resources, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.schoolsafety.gov/sites/default/files/2023-09/Emergency%20Planning%20Strategies%20and%20Resources-508.pdf
5. Essential Personnel FAQ - University of South Florida, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.usf.edu/administrative-services/emergency-management/programs/essential-personnel-faq.aspx
6. Education Support Professionals Honored as Essential Workers of the Pandemic | NEA, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/education-support-professionals-honored-essential-workers-pandemic
7. A School Personnel “Crisis” Created by COVID-19 - National School Boards Association, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.nsba.org/Perspectives/2020/school-personnel-covid-19
8. Essential Work - SchoolCEO, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.schoolceo.com/a/essential-work/
9. In-State Remote Work Policy, accessed January 12, 2025, https://clemsonpub.cfmnetwork.com/B.aspx?BookId=12240
10. Remote Work and Remote Working Agreements 4-31.2 - Virginia Beach School Board, accessed January 12, 2025, https://schoolboard.vbschools.com/policies/section-4/4-31-2
11. Policy 460.Remote Work 2021-2022 FINAL - Northfield Public Schools, accessed January 12, 2025, https://northfieldschools.org/wp-content/uploads/Policy-460.Remote-Work-2021-2022-FINAL.pdf
12. Managing Remote Teams in Organisations: Best Practices for Effective Collaboration and Communication | Psychology and Education Journal, accessed January 12, 2025, http://psychologyandeducation.net/pae/index.php/pae/article/view/7747
13. 5 Tips for Managing Remote Teams | UCF Online, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.ucf.edu/online/leadership-management/news/5-tips-for-managing-remote-teams/
14. Managing Remote Teams: 28 Tips and Best Practices in 2023 | DigitalOcean, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.digitalocean.com/resources/articles/managing-remote-teams
15. 15 Challenges and Best Practices for Managing Remote Teams - ProofHub, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.proofhub.com/articles/managing-remote-teams
16. 25 Best Practices for Remote Teaching and Learning - Education Corner, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.educationcorner.com/remote-teaching-and-learning/
17. How to Better Manage Your Remote Team - Professional & Executive Development, accessed January 12, 2025, https://professional.dce.harvard.edu/blog/how-to-better-manage-your-remote-team/
18. Cross-Training Staff: A Guide To Effective Implementation - Insperity, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.insperity.com/blog/cross-training-staff/
19. Cross Training Tips, accessed January 12, 2025, https://endowment.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Cross-Training-Tip-Sheet.docx
20. 5 ways to maximize efficiency through employee cross-training - WalkMe, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.walkme.com/blog/employee-cross-training/
21. The Head of School Succession Plan: Ensuring a Smooth Leadership Transition, accessed January 12, 2025, https://indyschoolconsultancy.com/news-store/the-head-of-school-succession-plan-ensuring-a-smooth-leadership-transition
22. Succession Planning in Schools - Juniper Education, accessed January 12, 2025, https://junipereducation.org/blog/succession-planning-in-schools
23. Succession Planning: Getting it Right - NAIS, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.nais.org/magazine/independent-school/fall-2017/succession-planning-welcoming-a-new-head-of-school/
24. How HR Leaders Can Respond During Crises with Emotional Support | Spring Health, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.springhealth.com/blog/emotional-support-during-crises
25. Quick Safety Issue 54: Promoting psychosocial well-being of healthcare staff during crisis, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.jointcommission.org/resources/news-and-multimedia/newsletters/newsletters/quick-safety/quick-safety-issue-54/quick-safety-issue-54-promoting-psychosocial-well--being-of-healthcare-staff-during-crisis/
26. How to recognise and manage teacher burnout - ReachOut Schools, accessed January 12, 2025, https://schools.au.reachout.com/teacher-wellbeing/how-to-recognise-and-manage-teacher-burnout
27. Prioritizing Teachers' Mental Health - PAR, Inc., accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.parinc.com/learning-center/par-blog/detail/content-hub/2024/05/17/prioritizing-teachers'-mental-health
28. Employee Wellness Programs: 26+ Ideas & Examples in the Workplace - Poppulo, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.poppulo.com/blog/employee-wellness-programs-examples
29. Supporting Employee Wellbeing During Organizational Change | Corporate Wellness, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.corporatewellnessmagazine.com/article/supporting-employee-wellbeing-during-organizational-change
30. Communication Methods for School Safety: Best Practices and Strategies, accessed January 12, 2025, https://riskstrategygroup.com/communication-methods-for-school-safety-best-practices-and-strategies/
31. Seven Tips for Clear Communication During a School or District Emergency, accessed January 12, 2025, https://raptortech.com/resources/blog/seven-tips-for-clear-communication-during-a-school-or-district-emergency/
32. Effective Communication During Emergencies: School Alert Systems - insurica, accessed January 12, 2025, https://insurica.com/blog/effective-communication-during-emergencies/
33. How to Develop a Crisis Communication Plan for Schools | Verizon Business, accessed January 12, 2025, https://www.verizon.com/business/resources/articles/s/how-to-develop-a-crisis-communication-plan-for-schools/
34. School Closures ― Remote Learning helps students to stay on track | SKOOLER, accessed January 12, 2025, https://skooler.com/school-closures-%E2%80%95remote-learning-helps-students-to-stay-on-track/
35. Best Practices for Teaching with Technology during Coronavirus Closures - Maryland State Education Association, accessed January 12, 2025, https://marylandeducators.org/best-practices-for-teaching-with-technology-during-coronavirus-closures/