International ESG Standards: A Comparative Analysis

Written by William Tygart | 12/18/24 5:10 PM

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations are rapidly transforming the commercial real estate (CRE) landscape. Investors, developers, and tenants are increasingly recognizing the importance of incorporating ESG factors into decision-making processes ¹. This shift is driven by various factors, including growing awareness of climate change risks, increasing stakeholder pressure, and the potential for ESG to enhance long-term value creation. As the CRE industry navigates this evolving landscape, understanding the different international ESG frameworks and standards becomes crucial. This report provides a comparative analysis of prominent ESG frameworks and standards and explores their implications for CRE investment and development.

Major International ESG Frameworks and Standards

Several international ESG frameworks and standards provide guidance for organizations seeking to integrate ESG factors into their operations and reporting. Some of the most influential and widely adopted frameworks include:

Global Reporting Initiative (GRI): The GRI Standards represent a comprehensive and widely used framework for sustainability reporting. It covers a broad range of ESG topics, providing a structured approach for organizations to disclose their performance across economic, environmental, and social dimensions ². The GRI framework has seen significant growth in voluntary reporting, with the number of organizations using GRI for sustainability reporting increasing from 11 in 1999 to 9,980 in 2021 ⁵.
Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB): The SASB Standards offer industry-specific guidance for identifying and reporting on financially material ESG issues. They are designed to help companies disclose information that is relevant to investors and other stakeholders in assessing enterprise value and risk ³.
Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD): The TCFD recommendations focus on climate-related financial risks and opportunities. They provide a framework for companies to assess and disclose the potential impacts of climate change on their business, strategy, and financial planning ³.
European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS): The ESRS are a set of standards used for mandatory sustainability reporting by companies within the scope of the European Union's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) ⁸. These standards define specific requirements for how companies report on their sustainability performance, focusing on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) aspects of a company's operations.

Comparing and Contrasting ESG Frameworks and Standards

While these frameworks and standards share a common goal of promoting ESG transparency and accountability, they differ in scope, focus, and application. The GRI Standards provide a holistic view of sustainability performance, while SASB Standards delve into industry-specific materiality. TCFD recommendations, on the other hand, focus specifically on climate-related financial disclosures ⁷.

To understand the difference between ESG frameworks and standards, it's important to note that a framework is a set of guidelines for preparing ESG reports and disclosures, while a standard is a prescribed methodology for preparing ESG reports and disclosures. Frameworks allow for some flexibility in defining the direction of the report, whereas standards contain specific and detailed criteria or metrics that should be included in any report or disclosure ⁴.

Although distinct, these frameworks and standards are not mutually exclusive. Organizations can use them in combination to meet different reporting needs and stakeholder expectations. For example, a company might use the GRI Standards as a foundation for its sustainability reporting while also incorporating SASB Standards to provide more detailed information on industry-specific ESG issues ¹⁰.

Furthermore, there is intentional alignment between some frameworks, such as SASB and TCFD. Both frameworks primarily focus on the financial impact of sustainability and climate-related issues, allowing organizations to uncover non-financial risks and opportunities ¹⁰.

In addition to frameworks and standards, ESG raters and rankers play a role in the ESG landscape. These entities confer quantitative scores on organizations based on proprietary methodologies, providing an independent assessment of ESG performance ¹¹.

The following table summarizes the key differences between GRI, SASB, and TCFD:

Framework/Standard	Scope	Focus	Application
GRI	Broad range of ESG topics	Comprehensive sustainability reporting	Applicable to all organizations
SASB	Industry-specific ESG issues	Financially material ESG information	Tailored to different sectors
TCFD	Climate-related risks and opportunities	Financial impacts of climate change	Relevant for companies in all sectors

ESG and the Commercial Real Estate Sector

The CRE sector faces unique ESG considerations due to its significant environmental footprint and social impact. Buildings consume a substantial amount of energy and resources, generate waste, and contribute to greenhouse gas emissions ¹². Moreover, CRE developments can have profound effects on local communities, influencing transportation patterns, access to amenities, and social equity ¹³. The COVID-19 pandemic has further emphasized the importance of ESG in CRE, particularly in areas such as risk management, resiliency, transparency, and social engagement ¹⁴.

Increasingly, commercial real estate companies are under pressure to not only develop environmental and social governance (ESG) policies but also to disclose accurate information surrounding their ESG performance...source to integrate sustainability principles into their projects. They offer guidance on:

Environmental Performance: Measuring and reducing energy consumption, water usage, and waste generation. Implementing green building practices and certifications, such as LEED and BREEAM. Properties with green building certifications can demand higher rental premiums compared to non-certified properties ¹⁵.
Social Impact: Promoting occupant health and well-being, fostering community engagement, and ensuring accessibility and inclusivity in building design and operations ¹⁶.
Governance: Implementing ethical business practices, ensuring transparency in reporting, and promoting diversity and inclusion in leadership and decision-making ¹³.

Case Studies of ESG Implementation in CRE

Several CRE investment and development projects have successfully implemented ESG principles, demonstrating the potential for sustainability to enhance value and achieve positive impacts.

Empire State Building: The Empire State Building underwent a comprehensive energy retrofit project, resulting in significant energy savings and a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. The project involved upgrading windows, insulation, and HVAC systems, leading to a 38% reduction in energy use and annual cost savings of approximately $4.4 million ¹⁵.
103 Colmore Row: This office building in Birmingham, UK, incorporated various ESG strategies into its development plan, including energy-efficient systems, water conservation measures, and extensive recycling initiatives. The building achieved a BREEAM Excellent rating, demonstrating its commitment to sustainability ¹⁵.

These case studies highlight the tangible benefits of integrating ESG principles into CRE projects. They demonstrate how sustainability can lead to improved financial performance, reduced environmental impact, and enhanced occupant well-being.

Benefits and Challenges of Adopting ESG Standards in CRE

Adopting ESG standards in CRE investment and development offers several potential benefits:

Benefit	Description
Enhanced Risk Management	ESG frameworks help identify and mitigate potential risks associated with climate change, resource scarcity, social unrest, and regulatory changes ¹⁸.
Improved Financial Performance	Studies have shown a correlation between strong ESG performance and improved financial outcomes in CRE. Green buildings, for example, often command higher rents and experience lower vacancy rates ¹⁵.
Increased Access to Capital	Investors are increasingly incorporating ESG factors into their investment decisions, favoring companies with strong sustainability credentials ¹⁸.
Enhanced Brand Reputation	ESG initiatives can enhance a company's brand reputation and attract tenants and investors who value sustainability ²⁰.
Reduced Regulatory Risk	ESG compliance can help companies mitigate regulatory risks in areas such as reporting, ordinance compliance, and incentives ²¹.

However, challenges also exist in adopting ESG standards in CRE:

Challenge	Description
Data Availability and Quality	Obtaining accurate and reliable ESG data can be challenging, particularly for older buildings or those with limited data collection systems ²².
Lack of Standardization	The lack of standardized ESG reporting frameworks can make it difficult to compare performance across different properties and portfolios ²².
Cost Considerations	Implementing ESG initiatives may require upfront investments in new technologies, building upgrades, and staff training ²².
Stakeholder Engagement	Effectively engaging with various stakeholders, such as investors, tenants, and local communities, can be challenging in ESG implementation ²².
Balancing Profitability with Long-Term Gains	Balancing the pressure to remain profitable with the need to dedicate capital for long-term environmental gains is a major challenge, especially during economic difficulties ²³.

Emerging Trends and Best Practices in ESG for CRE

Several emerging trends are shaping the future of ESG in CRE:

Increased Focus on Climate Risk: Assessing and mitigating climate-related risks, such as extreme weather events and rising sea levels, is becoming increasingly important for CRE investors and developers ²⁴. This includes implementing measures like installing green infrastructure to reduce runoff and improve resilience to extreme weather events ²⁴.
Technology Integration: Technology plays a crucial role in collecting, analyzing, and reporting ESG data. Building management systems, smart sensors, and data analytics platforms are helping CRE companies optimize energy efficiency, monitor environmental performance, and track progress toward sustainability goals ²⁵. This trend presents an opportunity for businesses to become leaders in sustainable innovation by developing and implementing new technologies that address environmental challenges ²⁶.
Emphasis on Health and Well-being: CRE developers are increasingly prioritizing occupant health and well-being by incorporating features such as improved indoor air quality, access to natural light, and biophilic design elements ²⁴.
Growing Emphasis on Social and Community Impact: Beyond environmental considerations, there is a growing focus on the social impact of CRE development, including promoting social equity, community engagement, and affordable housing initiatives ²⁵.

Best practices for integrating ESG in CRE include:

Conducting Materiality Assessments: Identifying the ESG issues that are most relevant to a company's business and stakeholders ¹³.
Setting Measurable Goals: Establishing specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals for ESG performance ¹³.
Engaging with Stakeholders: Communicating transparently with investors, tenants, and local communities about ESG initiatives and performance ²⁷.
Using Technology for Data Management: Leveraging technology to collect, analyze, and report ESG data efficiently and effectively ²⁷.

Conclusion

ESG is no longer a niche consideration but a core element of responsible CRE investment and development. By understanding the different international ESG frameworks and standards, CRE companies can effectively integrate sustainability principles into their operations, mitigate risks, enhance value, and contribute to a more sustainable built environment.

CRE companies can strategically apply these frameworks and standards to achieve specific objectives. For instance, adopting GRI standards can provide a comprehensive overview of sustainability performance for attracting investors who value transparency and holistic reporting. Implementing SASB standards can help companies in specific sectors demonstrate their understanding of financially material ESG issues, potentially leading to improved access to capital from investors focused on long-term value creation. Adhering to TCFD recommendations can enhance a company's risk management strategies and attract tenants seeking climate-resilient spaces.

As the ESG landscape continues to evolve, staying informed about emerging trends and best practices will be crucial for success in the CRE sector. By embracing ESG principles, CRE companies can position themselves as leaders in sustainability, creating value for their investors, tenants, and the communities they serve.

Works cited

The Financial Case for ESG in Commercial Real Estate - Measurabl, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.measurabl.com/the-financial-case-for-esg-in-commercial-real-estate/
Top 10: ESG Frameworks - Sustainability Magazine, accessed December 16, 2024, https://sustainabilitymag.com/top10/top-10-esg-frameworks
Navigating ESG Frameworks: Understanding GRI, SASB, and TCFD - Blog, accessed December 16, 2024, https://blog.falcony.io/en/navigating-esg-frameworks
The ABCs of ESG Frameworks & Standards - FigBytes, accessed December 16, 2024, https://figbytes.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/ALPHABET-SOUP_FINAL_JAN30.pdf
Top 7 Sustainability Reporting Standards - Comparing Disclosure Frameworks - Brightest, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.brightest.io/sustainability-reporting-standards
Which ESG Reporting Frameworks Exist in 2024? - FigBytes, accessed December 16, 2024, https://figbytes.com/blog/which-esg-reporting-frameworks-exist-in-2024/
ESG Reporting Frameworks – Comparing the GRI and the SASB, accessed December 16, 2024, https://esgpro.co.uk/esg-reporting-frameworks-comparing-the-gri-and-the-sasb/
The Top 10 Sustainability Reporting Frameworks You Should Know - Measurabl, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.measurabl.com/sustainability-reporting-frameworks-you-should-know/
Introduction to Popular ESG Reporting Frameworks Like GRI, SASB, and TCFD, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.esystems.fi/en/blog/introduction-to-popular-esg-reporting-frameworks-like-gri-sasb-and-tcfd
ESG reporting matrix: Understanding the alphabet soup of ESG - Conservice ESG, accessed December 16, 2024, https://esg.conservice.com/esg-solutions/the-esg-reporting-matrix/
How to Choose the Right ESG Reporting Frameworks and Standards - Aquicore, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.aquicore.com/blog/choosing-esg-reporting-frameworks-and-standards
CRE Sustainability and the Future of ESG - AtlasX, accessed December 16, 2024, https://atlasx.co/blog/cre-sustainability-and-the-future-of-esg
Commercial Real Estate Environmental Social Governance, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.keteres.com/esg/commercial-real-estate
The New Norm: ESG as a Material Risk and Opportunity for Real Estate, accessed December 16, 2024, https://cre.org/real-estate-issues/the-new-norm-esg-as-a-material-risk-and-opportunity-for-real-estate/
ESG in CRE: Driving Sustainable Investments - Blooma AI, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.blooma.ai/blooma-blog/esg-commercial-real-estate
ESG as a value driver for real estate - Deloitte, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www2.deloitte.com/cz/en/pages/real-estate/articles/the-impact-of-social-good-on-real-estate.html
Elevating ESG in Commercial Real Estate: The Role of Custom Software Solutions, accessed December 16, 2024, https://apiko.com/blog/esg-in-commercial-real-estate/
ESG frameworks for real estate: A 2023 guide - Chainels, accessed December 16, 2024, https://getchainels.com/en/blog/esg-frameworks
Using ESG to Improve Your Investment Outcomes - Counselors of Real Estate, accessed December 16, 2024, https://cre.org/real-estate-issues/using-esg-to-improve-your-investment-outcomes/
How & Why You Should Integrate ESG in Your Commercial Real Estate - iOptimize Realty, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.ioptimizerealty.com/blog/integrate-esg-in-commercial-real-estate-cre
How ESG Drives Value in Commercial Real Estate Investments - CBIZ, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.cbiz.com/insights/articles/article-details/a-sustainable-edge-how-esg-drives-value-in-commercial-real-estate-investments
Challenges faced in implementing and maintaining ESG standards - Knight Frank Blog, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.knightfrank.co.uk/blog/2023/12/04/challenges-faced-in-implementing-and-maintaining-esg-standards
Deep Dive: ESG moves down private real estate's priority list - PERE, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.perenews.com/deep-dive-esg-moves-down-private-real-estates-priority-list/
ESG Latest Trends: Navigating ESG Due Diligence In CRE - AEI Consultants, accessed December 16, 2024, https://aeiconsultants.com/esg-latest-trends-navigating-esg-due-diligence-in-cre/
Verdani's 10 ESG, Climate, and Reporting Trends Shaping 2024, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.verdani.com/single-post/verdani-s-10-esg-climate-and-reporting-trends-shaping-2024
The Future of ESG: Emerging Trends and Opportunities | by Anandv | Medium, accessed December 16, 2024, https://medium.com/@anandv_62921/the-future-of-esg-emerging-trends-and-opportunities-fa5cc98d6e67
Sustainable real estate – challenges and best practices in integrating ESG principles in US CRE - Acuity Knowledge Partners, accessed December 16, 2024, https://www.acuitykp.com/blog/real-estate-challenges/

View full post