Skip to content
Contact us

Integrating Doughnut Economics into ESG Frameworks

Picture of William Tygart

Introduction to Doughnut Economics and ESG

Doughnut Economics, developed by economist Kate Raworth, is a conceptual framework that reimagines traditional economic models to address 21st-century challenges. The model is visually represented as a doughnut, with the inner ring symbolizing the social foundation necessary for human well-being, and the outer ring representing the ecological ceiling that must not be exceeded to maintain Earth's life-supporting systems 

. The space between these two rings is the "safe and just space for humanity," where social needs are met without breaching ecological limits [[2]](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doughnut_(economic_model).Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks, on the other hand, are designed to help organizations manage their environmental, social, and governance commitments. These frameworks provide guidelines and principles for assessing and reporting on sustainability performance 

. Common ESG frameworks include the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), and the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) 

.

Key Principles of Doughnut Economics

Kate Raworth outlines seven key principles in her book "Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist," which guide the implementation of this model:

  1. Change the Goal: Shift the focus from GDP growth to achieving a balance within the doughnut's safe and just space.
  2. See the Big Picture: Recognize that economies are embedded within societies and the natural environment.
  3. Nurture Human Nature: Acknowledge the importance of human values and needs.
  4. Get Savvy with Systems: Understand and engage with complex systems.
  5. Design to Distribute: Address inequality by designing economies that distribute value more equitably.
  6. Create to Regenerate: Focus on regenerative design to transform harmful economic practices.
  7. Be Agnostic About Growth: Move away from the obsession with economic growth as a measure of success        .

Limitations of Current ESG Frameworks

Current ESG frameworks have several limitations in addressing planetary boundaries and social foundations:

  1. Narrow Focus on Carbon Emissions: Many ESG frameworks primarily focus on carbon emissions and climate change, often neglecting other critical environmental issues.
  2. Lack of Integration with Planetary Boundaries: The Planetary Boundaries Framework is not fully integrated into most ESG frameworks.
  3. Oversimplification of Environmental Metrics: ESG frameworks often simplify complex environmental metrics.
  4. Insufficient Focus on Social Equity: ESG frameworks tend to prioritize environmental metrics over social equity and justice.
  5. Lack of Comprehensive Social Metrics: Social metrics in ESG frameworks are often limited to basic indicators.
  6. Challenges in Measuring Social Impact: Measuring social impact is inherently complex, and current ESG frameworks struggle to provide clear, actionable metrics    .

Integrating Doughnut Economics into ESG Frameworks

Integrating Doughnut Economics into ESG frameworks offers a promising pathway to achieving sustainable development goals by balancing social and environmental priorities. Here are some existing attempts and proposals:

  1. Mapping SDGs to the Doughnut Model: Efforts have been made to map the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to the Doughnut Model, highlighting the alignment of social and environmental targets within the doughnut's framework  .
  2. Sector-Specific Applications: The Doughnut model has been applied in various sectors, such as fisheries, to assess sustainability. This approach provides valuable insights into ecological overshooting and social needs  .
  3. City-Level Implementations: Cities like Amsterdam have adopted the Doughnut model to guide urban development, demonstrating its applicability in local governance and planning  .
  4. Visual and Conceptual Integration: The Doughnut model's visual simplicity makes it an attractive tool for integrating with ESG frameworks, providing a clear representation of the balance needed between environmental and social factors  .

Potential Benefits of Integration

  1. Holistic Sustainability: By incorporating Doughnut Economics, companies can ensure that their operations do not exceed ecological limits while meeting social needs  .
  2. Enhanced Corporate Reputation: Companies adopting Doughnut Economics principles may improve their reputation among consumers and investors who prioritize sustainability.
  3. Risk Mitigation: By adhering to the ecological and social boundaries defined by the Doughnut model, companies can better anticipate and mitigate risks associated with environmental degradation and social inequality.
  4. Innovation and Efficiency: The model encourages businesses to innovate within the "safe and just space," potentially leading to more efficient use of resources and new business opportunities that are both profitable and sustainable.
  5. Long-term Resilience: By focusing on sustainability and social equity, businesses can enhance their long-term resilience, aligning with the growing consumer and investor demand for sustainable business practices  .

Challenges and Potential Solutions

  1. Complexity of Integration: Integrating Doughnut Economics into existing ESG frameworks can be complex due to the need for a comprehensive understanding of both social and ecological dimensions. Developing clear guidelines and tools, such as the Doughnut Design for Business tool, can help businesses navigate this integration  .
  2. Lack of Standardization: There is no standardized method for applying Doughnut Economics principles within ESG practices. Encouraging collaboration between businesses, policymakers, and academic institutions can foster the development of standardized practices and metrics  .
  3. Resistance to Change: Businesses may resist adopting Doughnut Economics due to perceived risks or costs associated with transforming their existing models. Education and awareness initiatives can help demystify the framework and highlight its benefits  .
  4. Measurement and Reporting: Measuring success in terms of Doughnut Economics requires new metrics that go beyond traditional financial indicators. Developing robust metrics and reporting standards that capture social and environmental impacts is crucial.
  5. Data Availability and Quality: Effective implementation requires robust data on social and environmental indicators, which may not always be available or reliable at the local or corporate level.
  6. Balancing Short-Term and Long-Term Goals: Companies may struggle to balance short-term financial performance with long-term sustainability goals. Incentivizing transformation through government policies and regulatory frameworks can help address this challenge.

Implications for Business Sustainability Strategies

  1. Strategic Redesign: Businesses are encouraged to transform their strategic and operational frameworks to align with the Doughnut Economics model. This involves redesigning business models to focus on regenerative and distributive dynamics rather than mere growth  .
  2. Regenerative Practices: Businesses adopting Doughnut Economics are expected to implement regenerative practices, including transitioning to circular economy models, reducing waste, and using sustainable materials.
  3. Distributive Outcomes: The model calls for businesses to ensure that value and opportunities are shared more equitably. This can involve adopting new governance models that include diverse stakeholders in decision-making processes  .
  4. Innovation and Collaboration: The Doughnut Economics framework encourages innovation in business design and collaboration across sectors. Companies are prompted to explore new partnerships and networks that support sustainable and equitable business practices  .
  5. Cultural Shift: Implementing Doughnut Economics requires a significant cultural shift within organizations, moving away from traditional growth metrics to more holistic measures of success.

Conclusion

Integrating the Doughnut Economics model into ESG frameworks offers a transformative approach to business sustainability strategies. By providing a clear visual representation of the balance needed between economic activities and ecological and social limits, the Doughnut model addresses many of the limitations of current ESG frameworks.While challenges exist, particularly in measurement, standardization, and corporate adoption, the potential benefits in terms of holistic sustainability, risk mitigation, innovation, and enhanced corporate reputation make it a compelling approach for forward-thinking businesses. As more companies and cities adopt these principles, they can contribute to a more sustainable and equitable global economy.The successful integration of Doughnut Economics into ESG practices requires ongoing collaboration between businesses, policymakers, and academic institutions. By developing standardized metrics, sharing best practices, and creating supportive regulatory environments, we can accelerate the transition towards a more sustainable and just economic model that respects both planetary boundaries and social foundations.As we face unprecedented environmental and social challenges, the integration of Doughnut Economics into ESG frameworks provides a roadmap for businesses to not only mitigate risks but also to actively contribute to a thriving, sustainable future for all.