Skip to content
Contact us

Insurance, Restoration, and the Circular Economy: Creating a Closed-Loop System for Disaster Recovery

Picture of William Tygart

The increasing frequency and intensity of natural disasters worldwide underscore the urgent need for sustainable and resilient disaster recovery practices1. Traditional disaster recovery often follows a linear model, focusing on rapid replacement and disposal of damaged materials, leading to significant waste and environmental impact. However, by integrating the principles of the circular economy, the restoration industry can transition to a closed-loop system that minimizes waste, maximizes resource utilization, and promotes long-term sustainability. This report explores the intersection of insurance, restoration, and the circular economy, examining current practices, challenges, opportunities, and innovative solutions for creating a closed-loop system for disaster recovery. One key concept in this transition is "Building Back Better," an approach to post-disaster recovery that reduces vulnerability to future disasters and builds community resilience2. This means not just restoring functionality but also improving resilience to future events.

Current Practices in Disaster Restoration

The restoration industry adheres to standards and guidelines established by organizations like the Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC). These standards ensure quality and consistency in restoration work, covering various aspects such as fire and smoke damage restoration (BSR/IICRC S700), mold remediation (ANSI/IICRC S520), and water damage restoration (ANSI/IICRC S500)3.

Post-disaster restoration typically involves a series of steps aimed at stabilizing the affected area, mitigating further damage, and restoring functionality. These steps can be summarized as follows:

 

Step

Description

Citation

Disaster Mitigation

This crucial first step involves taking immediate actions to prevent further damage and ensure safety. This may include plugging holes, redirecting water, boarding up windows, cleaning and disinfecting to prevent mold, and reinforcing damaged structures.

6

Securing the Affected Area

Actions like erecting temporary fencing, placing warning signs, and restricting access to hazardous areas are taken to prevent further damage and ensure the safety of both workers and the public.

7

Assessment and Planning

A thorough evaluation of the damage is conducted to determine the scope of the restoration work, including identifying materials for repair or replacement and any special considerations.

8

Emergency Services

Stabilizing the property and ensuring safety are paramount. This may involve removing debris, shoring up damaged structures, and providing temporary repairs.

8

Removal of Debris and Hazardous Materials

This critical step involves clearing the site of debris, damaged materials, and any hazardous substances to facilitate further restoration work.

7

Restoration

This phase encompasses repairing or replacing damaged structural elements, fixtures, and contents, as well as cleaning and restoring salvageable items.

8

Cleaning and Sanitization

Thorough cleaning and disinfection are essential to ensure a safe and healthy environment for occupants.

7

Restoring Utilities and Essential Services

This involves repairing or replacing damaged infrastructure for electricity, water supply, sewage systems, and communication networks.

7

These practices, while essential for immediate recovery, often prioritize speed and efficiency over long-term sustainability. The focus on replacement and disposal generates substantial waste, contributing to environmental problems and depleting valuable resources.

Principles of the Circular Economy

The circular economy represents a fundamental shift from the traditional linear model of production and consumption. Instead of a "take, make, dispose" approach, the circular economy emphasizes keeping resources in use for as long as possible, extracting maximum value from them, then recovering and regenerating products and materials at the end of their service life9. This model aims to minimize waste and pollution, promote resource efficiency, and create a more sustainable and resilient system. The three core principles of the circular economy are:

  • Eliminate waste and pollution: This involves designing products and processes to prevent waste generation, minimize the use of harmful substances, and reduce emissions11.
  • Circulate products and materials: This principle focuses on extending the lifespan of products and materials through reuse, repair, refurbishment, remanufacturing, and recycling11.
  • Regenerate natural systems: This involves restoring and enhancing natural resources, such as forests and water systems, to support the long-term health of the environment11.

By adopting these principles, industries can move towards a more sustainable and resilient system that minimizes environmental impact and maximizes resource efficiency.

Circular Economy in Other Industries

The circular economy is gaining traction across various sectors, offering valuable lessons for disaster recovery. Here are some notable examples:

Fashion Industry:

  • Design for longevity: Garments are designed to be durable, timeless, and easily repairable, encouraging longer use and reducing the need for frequent replacements14.
  • Sustainable materials: Emphasis is placed on using eco-friendly and recycled fabrics, minimizing the environmental footprint of production14.
  • Extended use and reuse: Clothing rental, resale markets, and clothing swaps are encouraged to extend the life of garments14.
  • Recycling and upcycling: Initiatives focus on recycling old garments into new fabrics or upcycling them into new products15.

Construction Industry:

  • Material reuse and repurposing: Construction waste is minimized by reusing or repurposing materials whenever possible16.
  • Designing for deconstruction: Buildings are designed for easy disassembly and material recovery at the end of their life cycle17.
  • Recycled and bio-based materials: Utilizing recycled or bio-based materials reduces reliance on virgin resources17.
  • Building lifespan extension: Better maintenance and refurbishment practices prolong the lifespan of buildings17.

Electronics Industry:

  • Reuse, repair, and refurbishment: Extending the life of electronic devices through repair and refurbishment programs reduces e-waste18.
  • Recycling: E-waste is collected, sorted, and recycled to recover valuable materials and reduce environmental pollution20.
  • Modular design: Modular design allows for easier upgrades and repairs, extending product life and facilitating recycling19.
  • Sustainable materials: Using recycled and recyclable materials in electronics manufacturing reduces resource depletion20.

These examples from diverse industries illustrate how circular economy principles can be successfully implemented, providing valuable insights for the restoration industry in the context of disaster recovery.

Applying Circular Economy to Disaster Recovery

Integrating circular economy principles into disaster recovery can lead to more sustainable and resilient outcomes. A key aspect of this is shifting perspectives – viewing waste not as a problem to be disposed of, but as a valuable resource to be managed and utilized21. This shift in mindset is crucial for embracing circularity in disaster recovery. Key strategies include:

  • Waste reduction and management: Prioritizing waste prevention, reduction, and proper disposal of debris and damaged materials. This includes sorting and separating waste for recycling or reuse22.
  • Material reuse and repurposing: Salvaging and reusing building materials, such as wood, concrete, and metal, whenever possible. This can involve repurposing materials for different applications or using them in new construction projects. For example, after the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami in Japan, wood waste was used for fuel or in paper mills, and rubble was recycled for use in construction or road maintenance22.
  • Design for deconstruction: Promoting the use of building designs that allow for easy disassembly and material recovery after disasters. This facilitates the reuse and recycling of components and reduces waste23.
  • Prefabricated and modular construction: Utilizing prefabricated or modular building components can speed up reconstruction, allow for easier repair and replacement of damaged parts, and facilitate adaptation to changing needs over time24.
  • Local sourcing and production: Sourcing materials and labor locally can reduce transportation costs, support local economies, and enhance community resilience25.

By adopting these strategies, the restoration industry can contribute to a more sustainable and resilient disaster recovery process.

Role of Insurance in Disaster Recovery

Insurance companies play a crucial role in disaster recovery by providing financial support for rebuilding and replacing damaged property. They can further contribute to a circular economy approach by acting as catalysts for change, incentivizing the adoption of circular practices within the restoration industry26. This can be achieved through various means:

  • Incentivizing sustainable practices: Offering lower premiums or other financial incentives to policyholders who choose sustainable building materials and practices. For example, insurance companies can offer discounts on premiums for policyholders who opt for sustainable repair and replacement options27.
  • Promoting resilient construction: Encouraging the use of building codes and standards that promote disaster resilience and facilitate the use of circular economy principles. Many insurers already understand the benefits of resilient buildings and provide incentives, such as the National Flood Insurance Program, which offers discounts of up to 45% based on the building's resilience to flood damage29.
  • Supporting green rebuilding: Providing coverage and incentives for rebuilding with sustainable and resilient materials and technologies. Insurance can help drive climate-smart upgrades and support retrofits that lead to savings over time from lower future losses and reduced energy use30.
  • Collaborating with stakeholders: Partnering with restoration companies, waste management firms, and other stakeholders to create a closed-loop system for material recovery and reuse31.
  • Incentivizing pre-disaster mitigation: Insurance companies can play a proactive role by offering financial incentives for implementing hazard mitigation measures before a disaster occurs. This can encourage property owners to invest in resilience and reduce the overall impact of future events27.

By actively promoting and incentivizing circular economy practices, insurance companies can significantly influence the restoration industry and contribute to a more sustainable disaster recovery system.

Challenges and Opportunities

Implementing a closed-loop system for disaster recovery presents both challenges and opportunities:

Challenges:

  • Logistical complexities: Sorting, processing, and reusing disaster waste can be logistically challenging, requiring efficient systems for collection, transportation, and storage21.
  • Contamination and safety concerns: Disaster waste may contain hazardous materials or contaminants, requiring careful handling and disposal to ensure safety and environmental protection21.
  • Cost considerations: Implementing circular economy practices may involve upfront costs for new technologies, infrastructure, and training32.
  • Lack of awareness and expertise: Limited awareness and understanding of circular economy principles among stakeholders can hinder adoption32.

Opportunities:

  • Reduced waste and environmental impact: Minimizing waste and promoting resource efficiency can significantly reduce the environmental footprint of disaster recovery33.
  • Economic benefits: Creating local circular economy ecosystems can generate new jobs, stimulate innovation, and boost local economies. Research shows that the circular economy offers a $4.5 trillion economic opportunity by reducing waste, stimulating innovation, and creating employment34.
  • Consumer benefits: The circular economy can lead to cost savings for consumers by reducing resource consumption and waste, leading to more efficient and sustainable products36.
  • Increased resilience: Circular economy practices can enhance community resilience by promoting local sourcing, resource efficiency, and self-sufficiency. By reducing reliance on finite resources and diversifying supply chains, the circular economy mitigates risks associated with resource scarcity and price volatility25.
  • Improved sustainability: Transitioning to a closed-loop system contributes to long-term sustainability by reducing resource depletion and environmental pollution34.

Innovative Solutions and Technologies

Several innovative solutions and technologies can support a circular economy approach to disaster recovery:

  • Digital platforms: Online platforms can facilitate the exchange and reuse of salvaged materials, connecting suppliers and users. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, the City of Chicago launched a PPE Marketplace to address shortages by connecting organizations with surplus PPE to those in need25.
  • Smart recycling bins: Sensor-equipped bins can identify and sort different types of waste, improving recycling efficiency39.
  • Waste analytics software: Software can track and analyze waste streams, providing insights for optimizing waste management and resource recovery39.
  • Extended reality (XR) technology: XR technologies can assist in the assessment of damage, planning for deconstruction, and training workers in circular economy practices39.
  • 3D printing: 3D printing can be used to create building components from recycled materials, reducing waste and enabling customized solutions40.

These technologies can help overcome logistical challenges, improve efficiency, and promote the adoption of circular economy practices in disaster recovery.

Conclusion

The integration of circular economy principles into disaster recovery presents a significant opportunity to create a more sustainable and resilient system. By shifting from a linear to a closed-loop model, the restoration industry can minimize waste, maximize resource utilization, and contribute to long-term environmental and economic benefits. This transition offers a $4.5 trillion economic opportunity, reduces environmental impact, increases community resilience, and promotes long-term sustainability25.

Insurance companies have a crucial role to play in this transformation. By incentivizing sustainable practices, promoting resilient construction, supporting green rebuilding, and collaborating with stakeholders, they can act as catalysts for change within the restoration industry26. Offering lower premiums, providing financial incentives for pre-disaster mitigation, and supporting the use of sustainable building materials are just some of the ways insurance companies can drive the adoption of circular economy practices27.

Looking ahead, the intersection of insurance, restoration, and the circular economy is likely to see further innovation and development. Digital platforms, smart technologies, and advanced materials will continue to emerge, offering new solutions for closing the loop in disaster recovery. The industry must embrace these advancements and collaborate to create a more sustainable and resilient future for disaster recovery.

Works cited

  1. Optimising Disaster Recovery - AXA XL, accessed January 15, 2025, https://axaxl.com/-/media/axaxl/files/optimizing-disaster-recovery.pdf
  2. Building Back Better in Post-Disaster Recovery - GFDRR, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.gfdrr.org/sites/default/files/2017-09/Building%20Back%20Better%20Guidance%20Note_0.pdf
  3. IICRC Standards - LearnToRestore.com, accessed January 15, 2025, https://learntorestore.com/iicrc-standards/
  4. IICRC Standards, accessed January 15, 2025, https://iicrc.org/iicrcstandards/
  5. S500 - IICRC, accessed January 15, 2025, https://iicrc.org/s500/
  6. Disaster Mitigation and Disaster Restoration: Two Critical Processes - First Onsite, accessed January 15, 2025, https://firstonsite.com/resource/disaster-mitigation-and-disaster-restoration-two-critical-processes/
  7. The 6 Steps Involved in the Natural Disaster Restoration Process, accessed January 15, 2025, https://blackdiamondrestoration.com/6-steps-involved-in-the-natural-disaster-restoration-process/
  8. Disaster Restoration: Importance & Types | SafetyCulture, accessed January 15, 2025, https://safetyculture.com/topics/disaster-restoration/
  9. Circular economy - Wikipedia, accessed January 15, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_economy
  10. Circular Economy: Principles, Benefits, and Applications | Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung | Tel Aviv, accessed January 15, 2025, https://il.boell.org/en/2024/03/09/understanding-circular-economy-principles-benefits-and-applications
  11. Circular economy principles - Ellen MacArthur Foundation, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy-principles
  12. Three core principles of the circular economy, accessed January 15, 2025, https://acehub.org.au/news/three-core-principles-of-the-circular-economy
  13. What is a circular economy? | Ellen MacArthur Foundation, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/topics/circular-economy-introduction/overview
  14. What is Circular Fashion? - The Sustainable Fashion Forum, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.thesustainablefashionforum.com/pages/what-is-circular-fashion
  15. The Circular Economy and the Fashion Industry, accessed January 15, 2025, https://insights.grcglobalgroup.com/the-circular-economy-and-the-fashion-industry/
  16. The role of the circular economy in the construction industry, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.digitalconstructionweek.com/the-role-of-the-circular-economy-in-the-construction-industry/
  17. Circular construction and materials for a sustainable building sector - BUILD UP, accessed January 15, 2025, https://build-up.ec.europa.eu/en/resources-and-tools/articles/circular-construction-and-materials-sustainable-building-sector
  18. resources.altium.com, accessed January 15, 2025, https://resources.altium.com/p/circular-economy-for-electronics-benefits#:~:text=It%20emphasizes%20the%20reuse%2C%20repair,the%20use%20of%20finite%20resources.
  19. The Benefits of a Circular Economy for Electronics - Altium Resources, accessed January 15, 2025, https://resources.altium.com/p/circular-economy-for-electronics-benefits
  20. Electronics - Platform for Accelerating the Circular Economy, accessed January 15, 2025, https://pacecircular.org/action-agenda/electronics
  21. Disaster recovery: Can the loop be closed on calamity? | News | Eco-Business | Asia Pacific, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.eco-business.com/news/disaster-recovery-can-the-loop-be-closed-on-calamity/
  22. Future Center - The role of circular economy in natural disaster ..., accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.futureuae.com/en-US/Mainpage/Item/8730/the-japanese-experience-the-role-of-circular-economy-in-natural-disaster-response
  23. Revamping Sustainability Efforts Post-Disaster by Adopting Circular Economy Resilience Practices - MDPI, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/22/15870
  24. 21 circular economy solutions for a more sustainable world - The World Economic Forum, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/03/21-circular-economy-solutions/
  25. How a circular economy can build resilience for climate change and disaster recovery, accessed January 15, 2025, https://rheaply.com/blog/disaster-recovery/
  26. The Circular Economy & Building a More Sustainable Insurance Industry - Baloise, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.baloise.com/en/home/news-stories/news/all-news/2023/the-circular-economy-and-building-a-more-sustainable-insurance-industry.html
  27. The Role of Natural Disaster Insurance in Recovery and Risk Reduction, accessed January 15, 2025, https://esg.wharton.upenn.edu/climate-center/the-role-of-natural-disaster-insurance-in-recovery-and-risk-reduction/
  28. Advancing Sustainable Claims through Circular Economy Principles - NTT DATA Insurance, accessed January 15, 2025, https://insurance.nttdata.com/post/advancing-sustainable-claims-through-circular-economy-principles/
  29. A Roadmap to Resilience Incentivization - National Institute of Building Sciences, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.nibs.org/files/pdfs/NIBS_MMC_RoadmapResilience_082020.pdf
  30. Unlocking Insurance to Rebuild Stronger and Greener after Disasters - News and stories, accessed January 15, 2025, https://blogs.edf.org/markets/2024/12/16/unlocking-insurance-to-rebuild-stronger-and-greener-after-disasters/
  31. What's the role of insurance in the circular economy?, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.globalinsurancesolutions.com.au/whats-the-role-of-insurance-in-the-circular-economy/
  32. Disaster Recovery Plan Challenges: Avoiding Pitfalls | Seagate US, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.seagate.com/blog/disaster-recovery-plan-challenges-avoiding-pitfalls/
  33. Closed-Loop Controlled Fluid Administration Systems: A Comprehensive Scoping Review - PMC, accessed January 15, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9315597/
  34. An integrated System Dynamics model for Closed Loop Supply Chains under disaster effects: The case of COVID-19 - PubMed Central, accessed January 15, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9375857/
  35. 5 Opportunities of a Circular Economy | World Resources Institute, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.wri.org/insights/5-opportunities-circular-economy
  36. Circular economy: definition, importance and benefits | Topics - European Parliament, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/topics/en/article/20151201STO05603/circular-economy-definition-importance-and-benefits
  37. A Closed-Loop Distribution System Restoration Tool for Natural Disaster Recovery. Final CRADA report - OSTI.GOV, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.osti.gov/biblio/1770294
  38. 11 Advantages and Disadvantages of Circular Economy - Henley Naturals, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.henleynaturals.com/blog/11-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-circular-economy
  39. Tech Roadmap: Circular Economy Digital Solutions - Verdantix, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.verdantix.com/report/tech-roadmap-circular-economy-digital-solutions
  40. Role of Technology in Circular Economy: By Raktim Singh - Finextra Research, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.finextra.com/blogposting/25642/role-of-technology-in-circular-economy
,