Inequitable Outcomes in the Transition to Net Zero

The transition to a net-zero emissions economy is critical to mitigating the effects of climate change. However, this transition has the potential to exacerbate existing inequalities, both within the United States and globally ¹. This report examines the potential for inequitable outcomes in the transition to net zero, focusing on the communities most at risk in the United States and globally. It also explores the challenges and criticisms of the net-zero approach and proposes strategies and solutions to ensure a just and equitable transition.

The Interconnection of Climate Change and Inequality

While the need to transition to a net-zero economy is driven by the urgency of the climate crisis, it is essential to recognize that climate change and inequality are deeply interconnected ². Climate change disproportionately impacts vulnerable populations, exacerbating existing inequalities and creating new ones. Conversely, addressing inequality is crucial for effective climate action. By acknowledging this interconnection, we can develop strategies that simultaneously address both challenges and create a more sustainable and equitable future for all.

Environmental Justice in the Net-Zero Transition

The concept of environmental justice is central to achieving a just transition to a net-zero economy ³. Environmental justice emphasizes the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people, regardless of their race, income, or geographic location, in environmental decision-making. This includes ensuring that the benefits and burdens of the net-zero transition are distributed equitably and that vulnerable communities are not disproportionately impacted by climate policies or the deployment of new technologies.

A key challenge in achieving environmental justice is overcoming the lack of understanding and trust between communities and policymakers ³. Building trust requires transparent communication, meaningful engagement, and a genuine commitment to addressing the concerns of vulnerable communities.

Inequitable Outcomes in the United States

Communities Most at Risk

Several communities in the United States are particularly vulnerable to the negative impacts of the net-zero transition. These include:

• Low-income communities: Low-income households often face a higher energy burden, meaning they spend a larger proportion of their income on energy costs ¹. This burden is further exacerbated by the fact that a disproportionate number of Hispanic, Black, and Native American households face high energy burdens compared to their share of households nationally ¹. The transition to net zero could involve increased costs for energy and transportation, potentially worsening the financial strain on these households ⁴. For example, they may struggle to afford electric vehicles or energy-efficient home upgrades like heat pumps ⁴.
• Communities of color: Communities of color in the United States are disproportionately exposed to environmental hazards and pollution ⁶. The transition to net zero could exacerbate these inequalities if not carefully managed. For instance, the shift to renewable energy sources may involve siting new infrastructure in or near these communities, potentially leading to further environmental burdens ⁷. Additionally, communities of color are more likely to be employed in high-emissions sectors, making them vulnerable to job losses during the transition ⁸. The transition also has the potential to bring significant health benefits to these communities by reducing air pollution from fossil fuels, which disproportionately impacts communities of color and low-income households ⁹.
• Rural communities: Rural communities often rely heavily on fossil fuel industries for employment and economic activity ¹⁰. The transition away from fossil fuels could lead to job losses and economic decline in these areas if not accompanied by adequate support and alternative economic opportunities ¹⁰. Furthermore, rural communities may face challenges in accessing new clean energy technologies and infrastructure due to their remote locations and dispersed populations ¹¹. Existing efforts to support communities at risk from the energy transition often exclude regions with high employment vulnerability, highlighting the need for more comprehensive and inclusive strategies ¹².

Policies and Initiatives with Disproportionate Impacts

Certain net-zero policies and initiatives in the United States have the potential to disproportionately impact vulnerable communities. For example:

Energy Policies:

• Carbon pricing: While carbon pricing can be an effective tool for reducing emissions, it can also lead to higher energy prices, potentially burdening low-income households ⁴.
• Renewable energy standards: Policies promoting renewable energy can inadvertently lead to the displacement of communities or the disruption of traditional land uses, particularly for Indigenous communities ¹³. It is important to address concerns and fears related to renewable energy projects, including the "not in my backyard" (NIMBY) phenomenon, through community engagement and transparent communication ¹⁴.

Transportation Policies:

• Transportation policies: Policies aimed at promoting electric vehicles or reducing transportation emissions may not be accessible to low-income communities who cannot afford electric vehicles or rely on public transportation ⁴.

Inequitable Outcomes Globally

Communities Most at Risk

Globally, the transition to net zero poses significant challenges for developing countries and vulnerable communities, including:

• Low-income countries: Developing countries often lack the financial resources and technological capacity to transition to a net-zero economy ¹⁵. They may also be more reliant on fossil fuel industries for economic development, making the transition more challenging ¹⁶. To decarbonize and support economic development, these countries would need to spend more on physical assets relative to their GDP compared to advanced economies ¹⁷. It is also important to recognize that it's impractical and unfair to expect all countries to reach net-zero emissions simultaneously, especially for poor countries with low per capita emissions that need to grow their energy consumption for development ¹⁸.
• Indigenous communities: Indigenous communities globally are often highly dependent on natural resources and traditional land uses, which can be threatened by the transition to net zero ¹⁹. For example, the development of renewable energy infrastructure can lead to land dispossession or the disruption of cultural practices ¹³. However, the net-zero transition also presents a unique opportunity to address the challenges faced by Indigenous communities through self-determination and economic reconciliation, particularly through equity ownership of energy and climate solutions infrastructure ²⁰.
• Fossil fuel-dependent communities: Communities whose economies are heavily reliant on fossil fuel extraction and production are at risk of economic decline and job losses during the transition ¹⁷. This is particularly relevant for developing countries where fossil fuel industries play a significant role in national economies ¹⁷.

Policies and Initiatives with Disproportionate Impacts

Several net-zero policies and initiatives globally can have disproportionate impacts on vulnerable communities:

Financial Policies:

• International climate finance: While international climate finance is intended to support developing countries in their transition to net zero, it can sometimes be inaccessible or insufficient to meet the needs of the most vulnerable communities ¹⁶.

Trade and Technology Policies:

• Trade policies: Trade policies related to carbon emissions or climate action can have unintended consequences for developing countries, potentially hindering their economic development or limiting their access to essential technologies ²¹.
• Technology transfer: The transfer of clean energy technologies to developing countries is crucial for a just transition, but it can be hindered by intellectual property rights, high costs, or lack of capacity ¹⁶.

Challenges and Criticisms of Net Zero

While the net-zero approach has gained widespread support, it is important to acknowledge the challenges and criticisms associated with it. One concern is the potential over-reliance on carbon capture technologies, which are still under development and may not be able to deliver the necessary emissions reductions at scale ²².

Furthermore, some argue that net zero is not ambitious enough and that we should aim for a world of net-negative emissions, where we actively remove more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere than we emit ²². This would require a more transformative approach that goes beyond simply reducing emissions and focuses on restoring and enhancing natural carbon sinks.

Strategies and Solutions

Addressing the potential for inequitable outcomes in the transition to net zero requires a comprehensive approach that considers the needs of vulnerable communities. Some strategies and solutions include:

• Equity-focused policies: Governments should implement policies that explicitly address equity concerns in the net-zero transition. This includes targeted support for low-income communities, communities of color, and rural communities ⁵.
• Community engagement: Meaningful engagement with vulnerable communities is crucial to ensure that their voices are heard and their needs are considered in the transition process ⁵.
• Just transition frameworks: Developing and implementing just transition frameworks can help ensure that the shift to a net-zero economy is fair and inclusive for all communities ²³. These frameworks should consider the social and economic impacts of the transition and provide support for workers and communities affected by the shift away from fossil fuels.
• Financial support: Providing financial support to vulnerable communities can help them access clean energy technologies, adapt to the changing economy, and participate in the net-zero transition ²⁴. This includes direct financial assistance, such as grants and subsidies, as well as access to affordable financing options. For developing countries, concessional finance and lower interest rates can play a crucial role in making investments in renewable energy more affordable and supporting a just transition ¹⁶.
• Capacity building: Investing in capacity building for developing countries and vulnerable communities can help them develop the skills and knowledge needed to participate in the net-zero economy ¹⁶. This includes training programs, educational initiatives, and technology transfer.

It is crucial to recognize that a singular pursuit of net-zero emissions by 2050 could exacerbate inequality if not accompanied by broader support for economic development and energy transformation ²⁵. A holistic approach that considers economic development, social equity, and environmental sustainability is essential for a just and successful transition.

Summary of Communities at Risk

The table below summarizes the communities most at risk in the United States and globally, highlighting the factors contributing to their vulnerability and the potential impacts of the net-zero transition.

Synthesis

The transition to a net-zero emissions economy is essential for mitigating climate change and creating a more sustainable future. However, this transition presents significant challenges for equity and social justice. This report has highlighted the potential for inequitable outcomes in the net-zero transition, both in the United States and globally.

Several communities are particularly vulnerable to the negative impacts of this transition, including low-income communities, communities of color, rural communities, Indigenous communities, and those whose livelihoods depend on fossil fuel industries. These communities face a range of challenges, from increased energy costs and job losses to land dispossession and the disruption of cultural practices.

Addressing these challenges requires a comprehensive and proactive approach that prioritizes equity and justice. This includes implementing equity-focused policies, engaging meaningfully with vulnerable communities, developing just transition frameworks, providing financial support, and investing in capacity building.

Furthermore, it is crucial to recognize the interconnection between climate change and inequality and to address both challenges simultaneously. By promoting environmental justice and ensuring a just and equitable transition, we can create a more sustainable and inclusive future for all.

Works cited

1. Achieving An Equitable US Clean Energy Transition - World Resources Institute, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.wri.org/insights/achieving-equitable-us-clean-energy-transition
2. Raising ambition around an equitable and inclusive net-zero transition | WBCSD, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.wbcsd.org/news/raising-ambition-around-an-equitable-and-inclusive-net-zero-transition/
3. Elevating Community Voices and Environmental Justice in the Transition to Net Zero, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nationalacademies.org/news/2024/05/elevating-community-voices-in-the-transition-to-net-zero
4. FAMILY AND COMMUNITY VULNERABILITIES IN THE TRANSITION TO NET ZERO | Nuffield Foundation, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Family-and-community-vulnerabilities-in-the-transition-to-net-zero-Morrison.pdf
5. Net zero policy risks making the poor poorer, according to new study - University of York, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.york.ac.uk/news-and-events/news/2024/research/net-zero-transition/
6. Environmental Justice in the Race to Net Zero - The Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.aashe.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/RESJ-Anthology-2022-Essay-1.pdf
7. Creating Equity in Energy for People of Color, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.energy.gov/articles/creating-equity-energy-people-color
8. Where Black Communities Fit into America's Energy Transition - RMI, accessed January 19, 2025, https://rmi.org/where-black-communities-fit-into-americas-energy-transition/
9. New Report Provides Comprehensive Plan to Meet U.S. Net-Zero Goals and Ensure Fair and Equitable Energy Transition | National Academies, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nationalacademies.org/news/2023/10/new-report-provides-comprehensive-plan-to-meet-u-s-net-zero-goals-and-ensure-fair-and-equitable-energy-transition
10. Quitting Fossil Fuels and Reviving Rural America - Center for American Progress, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/quitting-fossil-fuels-and-reviving-rural-america/
11. Winning The Rural Vote: Achieving Net Zero in Rural Communities - Rural Services Network, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.rsnonline.org.uk/winning-the-rural-vote-achieving-net-zero-in-rural-communities
12. Which US counties are most vulnerable in the energy transition? - MIT Sloan, accessed January 19, 2025, https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/which-us-counties-are-most-vulnerable-energy-transition
13. Brief on a Rights based approach towards Net Zero in the context of Indigenous Peoples - The Indegenous, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.theindegenous.org/post/brief-on-a-rights-based-approach-towards-net-zero-in-the-context-of-indigenous-peoples
14. Communities must be empowered to drive the energy transition | World Economic Forum, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/01/communities-must-be-empowered-to-drive-energy-transition/
15. Affordable clean energy transition in developing countries: Pathways and technologies - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed January 19, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9019260/
16. How to finance net zero in developing economies: Beyond the existing investment framework - Atlantic Council, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/energysource/how-to-finance-net-zero-in-developing-economies-beyond-the-existing-investment-framework/
17. The net-zero transition: What it would cost, what it could bring - McKinsey & Company, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/sustainability/our-insights/the-net-zero-transition-what-it-would-cost-what-it-could-bring
18. The poor should control carbon emissions, but the rich must eliminate them, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-poor-should-control-carbon-emissions-but-the-rich-must-eliminate-them/
19. Reconciling the green energy transition with the rights of Indigenous Peoples - Rural 21, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.rural21.com/english/a-closer-look-at/detail/article/reconciling-the-green-energy-transition-with-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples.html
20. “ The Only Road to Net Zero Runs Through Indigenous Lands”: - FNMPC, accessed January 19, 2025, https://fnmpc.ca/wp-content/uploads/FNMPC_Post-Conf_11022022_web.pdf
21. Taskforce: Early and widespread progress on net zero – but policy gap persists - PRI, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.unpri.org/news-and-press/taskforce-early-and-widespread-progress-on-net-zero-but-policy-gap-persists/12858.article
22. “Net zero” may need a rethink to keep climate targets within reach - PMC, accessed January 19, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11066980/
23. How a just transition can strengthen corporate net zero strategy - EDF+Business, accessed January 19, 2025, https://business.edf.org/insights/how-a-just-transition-can-strengthen-corporate-net-zero-strategy/
24. Net zero policy risks making the poor poorer - The Young Foundation, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.youngfoundation.org/insights/news/research-warns-net-zero-policy-risks-making-the-poor-poorer/
25. Companies Must Put Equality at the Heart of the Race to Zero - INSEAD Knowledge, accessed January 19, 2025, https://knowledge.insead.edu/responsibility/companies-must-put-equality-heart-race-zero