Business Continuity ESG Blog

Fire Risk Assessments for Business Continuity in Commercial Real Estate

Written by William Tygart | 1/19/25 4:13 PM

Commercial real estate (CRE) properties represent significant investments, and ensuring their operational continuity is crucial for business success. Among the various risks that can disrupt CRE operations, fire stands out as a major threat with potentially devastating consequences. Fire incidents can lead to property damage, business interruption, financial losses, and even loss of life. Therefore, implementing robust fire safety measures is paramount for all CRE stakeholders.

A key element of fire safety in CRE is conducting comprehensive Fire Risk Assessments. These assessments play a vital role in identifying potential fire hazards, evaluating the likelihood and impact of fire incidents, and implementing appropriate mitigation measures to minimize risks. This article delves into the critical aspects of Fire Risk Assessments for business continuity in CRE properties, drawing upon industry best practices and relevant research.

Comprehensive Fire Risk Assessments

A comprehensive Fire Risk Assessment for CRE properties involves a systematic evaluation of various factors that contribute to fire risk. As detailed in fire safety guidelines, there are five key components of a fire risk assessment: 1

  • Identifying Fire Hazards: This involves a thorough examination of the premises to pinpoint potential sources of ignition, fuel sources, and conditions that could contribute to the start or spread of a fire.
  • Identifying People at Risk: This step focuses on identifying all individuals who might be present in the building, including employees, visitors, and any vulnerable populations with specific needs in case of a fire emergency.
  • Evaluating, Removing, or Reducing Risks: Once hazards and at-risk individuals are identified, the next step is to assess the likelihood and potential impact of each hazard. This involves analyzing existing fire safety measures, identifying areas for improvement, and implementing strategies to eliminate or mitigate risks.
  • Preparing an Emergency Plan and Providing Training: This component involves developing a comprehensive fire emergency plan, including evacuation procedures, communication protocols, and designated assembly points. It also includes providing fire safety training to all occupants on how to respond to a fire emergency, use fire extinguishers, and evacuate safely.
  • Reviewing and Updating the Fire Risk Assessment Regularly: Fire risk assessments are not static documents. They need to be reviewed periodically and updated whenever there are changes to the building, occupancy, or fire safety regulations. This ensures that the assessment remains relevant and effective in mitigating fire risks.

In addition to these five key components, a comprehensive Fire Risk Assessment for CRE properties should include a detailed evaluation of the following aspects:

Fire Safety Systems Evaluation

This involves a thorough inspection and testing of all fire safety systems within the property, including:

  • Sprinkler Systems: Assessing the adequacy and functionality of sprinkler systems, including water supply, coverage, and compliance with relevant standards (e.g., NFPA 13)2.
  • Fire Alarm Systems: Evaluating the effectiveness of fire alarm systems, including smoke detectors, heat detectors, manual pull stations, and notification systems, ensuring compliance with NFPA 722.
  • Fire Extinguishers: Inspecting the availability, type, and condition of fire extinguishers, ensuring they are appropriately located, regularly maintained, and compliant with NFPA 102.
  • Emergency Lighting: Assessing the adequacy and functionality of emergency lighting systems to ensure safe evacuation during a fire incident3.
  • Exit Signage: Verifying the presence and clarity of exit signage to guide occupants towards safe evacuation routes3.

Building Construction Analysis

This involves analyzing the building's construction features to identify potential fire hazards, including:

  • Construction Materials: Assessing the fire resistance ratings of building materials used in walls, floors, and roofs1.
  • Compartmentalization: Evaluating the effectiveness of fire-resistant compartmentalization to prevent fire spread.
  • Firestopping: Inspecting firestopping measures in walls and floors to prevent fire and smoke from spreading through concealed spaces.

Occupancy Types and Fire Risks

Different occupancy types in CRE properties present unique fire risks. For example:

  • Assembly Occupancies: Properties hosting public gatherings (e.g., theaters, restaurants) pose higher risks due to potential overcrowding and the presence of ignition sources like cooking equipment and electrical systems. Fire safety measures in these occupancies should focus on ensuring adequate means of egress, proper ventilation to remove smoke and heat, and strategically placed fire extinguishers and suppression systems4.
  • Mercantile Occupancies: Retail stores and shops may have significant fire loads due to the presence of combustible goods and display materials. Fire risk assessments should consider the types of materials stored and displayed, the arrangement of merchandise to prevent fire spread, and the availability of fire suppression systems like sprinklers5.
  • Industrial Occupancies: Manufacturing facilities and warehouses may involve hazardous materials and processes that increase fire risk. Assessments should focus on identifying and mitigating hazards associated with specific industrial processes, ensuring proper storage and handling of flammable materials, and implementing appropriate fire suppression systems5.
  • Office Occupancies: While generally considered lower risk, offices can still have fire hazards related to electrical equipment, heating systems, and combustible office materials. Fire safety measures should include regular inspections of electrical systems, proper maintenance of heating equipment, and minimizing the accumulation of combustible materials6.

Potential Ignition Sources

Identifying potential sources of ignition within the property is crucial. These can include:

  • Electrical Equipment: Faulty wiring, overloaded circuits, and malfunctioning electrical equipment can ignite fires7.
  • Heating Systems: Furnaces, boilers, and space heaters can pose fire hazards if not properly maintained7.
  • Cooking Equipment: In occupancies with cooking facilities, such as restaurants, kitchens can be significant sources of fire ignition4.
  • Smoking Materials: Carelessly discarded cigarettes and other smoking materials can ignite fires.
  • Hot Work: Activities like welding, cutting, and grinding can generate sparks and heat that can ignite combustible materials.

Common Fire Hazards in CRE Properties

In addition to the potential ignition sources mentioned above, some common fire hazards specific to CRE properties include: 8

  • Lack of Automatic Fire Sprinkler Systems: Buildings without automatic fire sprinkler systems are more vulnerable to rapid fire spread and extensive damage.
  • Lack of Approved Rag Cans: Oil-soaked rags, if not properly contained in approved rag cans, can spontaneously combust, posing a significant fire hazard.
  • Unprotected Gas Meters: Gas meters located near combustible materials or without proper protection can be vulnerable to fire damage and potential gas leaks.

Vulnerability Identification

Identifying potential fire hazards and vulnerabilities in CRE properties requires a systematic approach. While specific methodologies may vary, some common approaches include:

  • Physical Inspections: Conducting thorough on-site inspections to identify potential fire hazards, assess the condition of fire safety systems, and evaluate building construction features. For example, an inspector might identify a blocked fire escape during a physical inspection.
  • Document Review: Reviewing building plans, fire safety system records, and maintenance logs to identify potential vulnerabilities. This could involve analyzing past inspection reports to identify recurring issues or reviewing fire alarm system records to ensure proper testing and maintenance.
  • Occupancy Analysis: Analyzing the occupancy types within the property to understand specific fire risks associated with each type. For instance, a high-rise building with a mix of residential, office, and retail spaces would require a different fire risk assessment approach compared to a single-tenant warehouse.
  • Hazard and Operability (HAZOP) Studies: Conducting HAZOP studies to identify potential fire hazards associated with specific processes or operations within the property. This is particularly relevant for industrial properties where complex processes and hazardous materials are involved.
  • Scenario Analysis: Developing fire scenarios to assess the potential consequences of fire incidents and identify vulnerabilities in evacuation routes and fire protection systems. This could involve simulating a fire in a specific location and analyzing how smoke and fire would spread, how occupants would evacuate, and how fire safety systems would respond.

In addition to these approaches, it's important to understand the different methods for estimating the potential impact of fire: 9

  • Risk-Based Methods: These methods analyze both the likelihood of fire scenarios occurring and their potential consequences. They involve assessing the probability of different fire events and their potential impact on the property and occupants.
  • Hazard-Based Methods: These methods focus solely on the potential consequences of fire scenarios without considering their likelihood. They aim to determine the worst-case scenario and the maximum potential damage that could occur.

Both risk-based and hazard-based methods are valuable in CRE fire risk assessments. Risk-based methods help prioritize mitigation efforts by focusing on the most likely and impactful scenarios, while hazard-based methods ensure that the property is prepared for even the most severe fire events.

Property Resilience Assessment

Another valuable methodology for identifying fire hazards and vulnerabilities in CRE properties is the Property Resilience Assessment (PRA). This approach, often used to assess climate-related risks, can also be applied to fire risk assessment. The PRA consists of three stages: 10

  1. Identify the property's hazard exposure: This involves identifying the specific fire hazards that the property is exposed to, considering factors such as the building's location, construction type, surrounding environment, and occupancy type.
  2. Assess the building's sensitivity and preparedness for the hazards: This stage evaluates the building's vulnerability to fire hazards by considering its construction materials, fire safety systems, and existing fire prevention measures.
  3. Determine resilience measures that can reduce the impacts of relevant hazards: This involves identifying and implementing measures that can enhance the building's resilience to fire, such as upgrading fire safety systems, improving compartmentalization, and implementing fire prevention strategies.

By applying the PRA methodology, CRE stakeholders can gain a comprehensive understanding of their property's fire risk profile and develop effective strategies to enhance its resilience to fire incidents.

Expertise of Fire Solutions Companies

Fire solutions companies play a crucial role in conducting Fire Risk Assessments and providing expert recommendations for mitigating fire risks. These companies typically offer a range of services, including: 11

  • Fire Risk Assessments: Conducting comprehensive Fire Risk Assessments in compliance with relevant regulations and standards.
  • Fire Protection System Design and Installation: Designing and installing fire safety systems, such as sprinkler systems, fire alarms, and suppression systems.
  • Fire Safety Training: Providing fire safety training to building occupants and staff on evacuation procedures, fire extinguisher use, and fire prevention practices.
  • Emergency Planning: Developing emergency plans and procedures to ensure a coordinated response in the event of a fire incident.
  • Loss Control Consulting: Providing expert advice on loss control measures to minimize fire risks and potential damage11.

Fire solutions companies often employ qualified fire protection engineers and consultants with expertise in fire safety codes, standards, and best practices. They utilize specialized tools and technologies, such as fire modeling software, to assess fire risks and develop effective mitigation strategies12.

Furthermore, these companies leverage technology to enhance fire safety management. Fire department software, with features like scheduling, incident tracking, mobile access, equipment tracking, training management, and real-time data access, plays a crucial role in improving incident response and reporting16. This technology enables fire departments and fire safety professionals to:

  • Reduce the time required to complete reports.
  • Provide accurate and detailed data for analysis and decision-making.
  • Track and manage fire safety equipment effectively.
  • Improve training and preparedness for fire emergencies.

Proactive risk management is essential for minimizing fire risks and ensuring business continuity in CRE properties. Fire solutions companies play a vital role in this by offering services like regular inspections, employee training, and collaboration with fire safety experts11. By partnering with these companies, CRE stakeholders can benefit from expert knowledge, advanced technologies, and a proactive approach to fire safety management.

Case Studies

Examining case studies of successful Fire Risk Assessments can provide valuable insights into the practical application and impact of these assessments. While specific case studies related to CRE properties were not found in the provided research material, some examples from other contexts illustrate the importance of Fire Risk Assessments:

  • Workplace Fire Safety: A case study highlighted the use of risk assessment for fire safety prevention in a workplace facility, emphasizing the importance of raising awareness about fire safety culture and training employees on fire response procedures17.
  • Heritage Village Fire Risk Management: A study focused on developing a fire risk assessment system for a heritage village, considering factors such as cultural relic value sensitivity, village fire hazard, and evacuation accessibility18.

These case studies, although not directly related to CRE, demonstrate the value of Fire Risk Assessments in identifying vulnerabilities, implementing mitigation measures, and improving fire safety outcomes. They highlight the importance of tailoring fire risk assessments to specific contexts and considering factors beyond just the physical building, such as occupant behavior and cultural heritage.

Industry Standards and Regulations

CRE properties are subject to various fire safety regulations and standards, which may vary depending on the jurisdiction and occupancy type. Some key standards and regulations include:

  • National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Standards: NFPA provides a wide range of fire safety standards, including NFPA 101 (Life Safety Code), NFPA 13 (Sprinkler Systems), NFPA 72 (Fire Alarm and Signaling Systems), and NFPA 25 (Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance of Water-Based Fire Protection Systems)2.
  • International Building Code (IBC): The IBC sets minimum requirements for the design and construction of buildings, including fire safety provisions19.
  • Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Standards: OSHA regulations address fire safety in the workplace, including requirements for exit routes, emergency action plans, and fire prevention plans20.

Compliance with these standards and regulations is essential for ensuring fire safety in CRE properties and maintaining business continuity. Failure to comply can result in legal penalties, increased insurance premiums, and reputational damage.

Financial Implications of Fire Risk in CRE

Fire incidents in CRE properties can have significant financial implications, extending beyond just the immediate costs of property damage. These implications include:

  • Property Damage: Fire can cause extensive damage to the building structure, interior finishes, and equipment, leading to substantial repair or replacement costs.
  • Business Interruption: Fire incidents can disrupt business operations, leading to loss of revenue, productivity, and market share.
  • Increased Insurance Premiums: A history of fire incidents or inadequate fire safety measures can result in higher insurance premiums for CRE properties.
  • Potential Legal Liabilities: Property owners and managers can face legal liabilities for injuries or fatalities resulting from fire incidents if fire safety regulations are not met.

Furthermore, the involvement of investment funds in CRE can have implications for financial stability in relation to fire risk21. Investment funds often hold significant CRE assets, and a major fire incident affecting one of these assets can trigger financial losses for the fund and potentially impact the broader financial system. This highlights the importance of fire risk assessments and mitigation measures not only for individual properties but also for the stability of the CRE investment landscape.

However, it's important to recognize that investing in robust fire safety measures can have positive financial benefits. Proactive fire safety can lead to: 22

  • Reduced Insurance Premiums: Implementing comprehensive fire safety measures and demonstrating a commitment to fire prevention can result in lower insurance premiums.
  • Minimized Business Interruption Losses: Effective fire safety systems and emergency plans can help minimize business interruption and associated financial losses in the event of a fire.
  • Enhanced Property Value: A well-maintained property with robust fire safety features can have a higher market value and attract tenants seeking a safe and secure environment.

Synthesis and Conclusion

Fire Risk Assessments are essential for business continuity in CRE properties. They provide a systematic approach to identify fire hazards, evaluate risks, and implement mitigation measures to minimize the likelihood and impact of fire incidents. Comprehensive assessments involve evaluating fire safety systems, analyzing building construction, considering occupancy types, and identifying potential ignition sources. They also require a thorough understanding of the different methodologies for assessing fire risk, such as risk-based and hazard-based approaches, as well as the Property Resilience Assessment (PRA) framework.

Fire solutions companies play a vital role in conducting these assessments, providing expert recommendations, and leveraging technology to enhance fire safety management. By partnering with these companies and adhering to industry standards and regulations, CRE stakeholders can create a safer environment for occupants, protect their assets, and ensure business continuity in the face of potential fire hazards.

The financial implications of fire risk in CRE are significant, ranging from property damage and business interruption to increased insurance premiums and potential legal liabilities. However, proactive fire safety measures can mitigate these risks and even provide financial benefits, such as reduced insurance premiums, minimized business interruption losses, and enhanced property value.

A holistic approach to fire safety management in CRE properties is crucial. This involves recognizing the interconnectedness of various aspects of fire risk assessment, such as the relationship between building construction, occupancy type, and fire safety systems. By prioritizing fire safety and investing in comprehensive Fire Risk Assessments, CRE owners and managers can demonstrate their commitment to protecting lives, preserving assets, and maintaining uninterrupted business operations.

Regularly reviewing and updating Fire Risk Assessments is crucial to adapt to changing conditions, new technologies, and evolving fire safety practices. This ongoing commitment to fire safety will ensure that CRE properties remain resilient to fire hazards and contribute to a safe and secure environment for all stakeholders.

Works cited

  1. What are the 5 main components of a Fire Risk Assessment?, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.pyrofire.co.uk/what-are-the-5-main-components-of-a-fire-risk-assessment/
  2. Fire Safety Tips for Commercial Property Owners - VFS Fire & Security Services, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.vfsfire.com/fire-safety-tips-for-commercial-property-owners/
  3. Property Condition Assessment of Fire Protection and Life Safety Systems, accessed January 19, 2025, https://blog.qrfs.com/229-property-condition-assessment-of-fire-protection-and-life-safety-systems/
  4. Report sparks conversation about fires by occupancy or property type | Verisk, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.verisk.com/blog/report-sparks-conversation-about-fires-by-occupancy-or-property-type/
  5. Occupancy Classifications in Codes - NFPA, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nfpa.org/news-blogs-and-articles/blogs/2021/05/07/occupancy-classifications-and-model-codes
  6. NFPA report - Fires by occupancy or Property Type, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.nfpa.org/education-and-research/research/nfpa-research/fire-statistical-reports/fires-by-occupancy-or-property-type
  7. Fire Risk Assessments for Commercial Property | PropCert, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.propcert.co.uk/blog/fire-risk-assessments-for-commercial-property/
  8. Guide to Commercial Property Risk Assessment | WSRB, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www1.wsrb.com/resources/risk-assessment-guide
  9. Fire Hazard Analysis Techniques - TSAPPS at NIST, accessed January 19, 2025, https://tsapps.nist.gov/publication/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=900092
  10. New ASTM Guide on Property Resilience Assessment Will Help ..., accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.moodyscre.com/insights/cre-trends/resilience-in-cre-investing-lending/
  11. Fire Risk Assessments + Feasibility Studies - Jensen Hughes, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.jensenhughes.com/europe/services/fire-risk-assessments
  12. Fire Hazard Analysis and Emergency Response Planning - BakerRisk, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.bakerrisk.com/services/fire-and-emergency-response/
  13. Fire Hazard Assessments - PLC Fire Safety Engineering, accessed January 19, 2025, https://plcfire.com/services/fire-assessments/
  14. FIRE & RISK ALLIANCE – ENGINEERING A SAFER FUTURE, accessed January 19, 2025, https://fireriskalliance.com/
  15. Fire Risk Consulting Services | AXA XL Insurance, accessed January 19, 2025, https://axaxl.com/insurance/products/fire-risk-consulting
  16. 20 Best Fire Department Software in 2025 | Research.com, accessed January 19, 2025, https://research.com/software/best-fire-department-software
  17. Fire Safety Risk Assessment of Workplace Facilities: A Case Study - Frontiers, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/built-environment/articles/10.3389/fbuil.2022.861662/full
  18. Fire Risk Assessment of Heritage Villages: A Case Study on Chengkan Village in China, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2571-6255/6/2/47
  19. Code Requirements for Commercial Fire Protection - Blog - Koorsen Fire & Security, accessed January 19, 2025, https://blog.koorsen.com/code-requirements-for-commercial-fire-protection
  20. Fire Safety - Standards | OSHA.gov | Occupational Safety and Health Administration, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.osha.gov/fire-safety/standards
  21. Vulnerabilities in the EEA commercial real estate sector - European Systemic Risk Board, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.esrb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/reports/esrb.report.vulnerabilitiesEEAcommercialrealestatesector202301~e028a13cd9.en.pdf
  22. Assessing Commercial Real Estate Portfolio Risk | FDIC.gov, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.fdic.gov/bank-examinations/assessing-commercial-real-estate-portfolio-risk
View full post