Skip to content
Contact us

ESG in the US: Navigating the Political and Regulatory Landscape

Picture of William Tygart

The adoption of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles has become a defining trend in the commercial real estate (CRE) industry. However, the evolving political and regulatory landscape in the US presents both challenges and opportunities for stakeholders seeking to integrate ESG into their investment strategies and operations. This report delves into the complex interplay of state-level legislation, SEC regulations, and investor sentiment, analyzing their impact on the future of ESG in CRE.

Political Polarization and State-Level Legislation

The US political landscape is increasingly polarized on ESG issues, with Republican-led states often opposing and Democrat-led states generally supporting ESG integration. This divide has manifested in a wave of state-level legislation aimed at either promoting or restricting ESG considerations1. This polarization is deeply rooted in the political economy of the US, where the oil and gas industry holds significant influence, particularly among Republican politicians4.

It's important to note that despite the ongoing political battles, there has been a reported decline in global ESG fund flows in 2022 and 20235. This suggests that the perceived urgency for anti-ESG legislation may have decreased, although concerns about ESG in certain states remain strong5.

Anti-ESG Legislation

Several states have enacted laws that discourage or prohibit the consideration of ESG factors in investment decisions by state entities, including public pension funds. These laws often cite concerns about fiduciary duty and potential economic harm to certain industries, such as fossil fuels1. A key argument against ESG investing from these states is that it prioritizes political agendas over financial returns1. This has led to actions like Republican-led states pulling billions of dollars of investments from firms like BlackRock due to their ESG focus7.

Examples of anti-ESG legislation include:

  • Idaho: Prohibits public entities from considering ESG characteristics in investment decisions if it could override the prudent investor rule3.
  • North Dakota: Prohibits the investment of state funds for "social investment" purposes3.
  • Texas: Bars government entities from contracting with companies that "boycott" fossil fuel companies6.

Furthermore, six states have adopted ESG Discrimination Legislation, which prohibits discrimination against certain parties based on ESG factors, scores, or criteria unrelated to the specific business at hand8. This type of legislation can apply to both governmental entities and financial institutions8.

It's crucial to recognize that anti-ESG legislation can have detrimental effects, potentially hindering efforts to address climate change and discouraging companies from adopting sustainable practices1.

Pro-ESG Legislation

Conversely, some states have taken steps to encourage ESG adoption. These states generally view ESG as a means to promote sustainability, address social issues, and enhance long-term economic growth2.

Examples of pro-ESG initiatives include:

  • California: Passed legislation mandating climate change disclosures for large companies9.
  • Massachusetts and Washington: Democratic governors in these states have pushed for ESG-focused investing and sustainable practices2.

This divergence in state-level legislation creates a complex landscape for CRE investors and developers operating across multiple jurisdictions. It also introduces uncertainty about the long-term viability of ESG-focused strategies in certain regions5.

SEC Regulations: Enhancing Transparency and Standardization

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken a more proactive stance on ESG, introducing regulations aimed at enhancing transparency and standardization in climate-related disclosures10. This increased regulatory focus is driven in part by growing pressure from investors, consumers, employees, and activists who expect companies to demonstrate good corporate citizenship and meet ESG expectations13.

Key SEC Regulations:

  • Climate-Related Disclosures: In March 2024, the SEC issued final rules requiring public companies to disclose climate-related data, including risks, mitigation efforts, and scenario analysis results11. This move aims to provide investors with consistent and comparable information to make informed investment decisions12.
  • Names Rule Update: In September 2023, the SEC updated its Names Rule to ensure that funds with ESG-related names accurately reflect their investment strategies, combating "greenwashing." 14 This update clarifies that if a fund's name suggests a specific focus on ESG, at least 80% of its assets must be invested accordingly14.
  • Human Capital Resources: In 2020, the SEC revised its rules to require companies to disclose information on "human capital resources," though some stakeholders argue that these requirements remain too broad11.

Impact on CRE:

These SEC regulations are likely to have a significant impact on CRE, increasing pressure on companies to improve data collection, reporting, and transparency around ESG performance15. This could lead to greater scrutiny from investors and potentially influence property valuations16. The increasing importance of ESG data for investors is evident in the rapid adoption of ESG in the commercial real estate industry, where it has become a central consideration in assessing statutory risk and suitability for purpose17.

Investor Sentiment: A Shifting Tide

Investor interest in ESG remains a significant driver of its adoption in CRE18. However, recent surveys suggest a potential shift in sentiment, driven by concerns about performance and the increasing politicization of ESG19.

Key Trends:

  • Declining Enthusiasm: Some studies indicate a decline in investor enthusiasm for ESG, with fewer investors prioritizing ESG factors in their decision-making. This decline is attributed to factors such as performance concerns, market volatility, and a perceived lack of clear returns on ESG investments19.
  • Focus on "G": While overall interest in ESG may be waning, the "G" (governance) component is gaining prominence, reflecting a growing emphasis on corporate transparency and accountability19. This shift suggests that investors are increasingly prioritizing good governance practices as a key indicator of long-term value and stability.
  • Demand for Quality Reporting: Investors are increasingly demanding high-quality, assured ESG reporting, with greater trust placed in independently verified information22. This highlights the need for CRE companies to invest in robust ESG data management and reporting systems to meet investor expectations and build trust.

Impact on CRE:

This evolving investor sentiment could influence capital flows and investment strategies in CRE. Properties with strong ESG performance and transparent reporting are likely to be more attractive to investors, while those lagging in ESG adoption may face challenges in securing funding or achieving optimal valuations18. Investors increasingly believe that companies with strong ESG performance are less risky, better positioned for the long term, and better prepared for uncertainty24.

ESG in Commercial Real Estate: Risks and Opportunities

The confluence of political, regulatory, and investor sentiment creates a dynamic landscape for ESG in CRE. Understanding the associated risks and opportunities is crucial for stakeholders to navigate this evolving terrain.

Risks:

  • Environmental Risks: Climate change poses significant physical risks to CRE assets, including increased exposure to extreme weather events, rising sea levels, and resource scarcity25. Buildings that lack sustainable features and have a heavy carbon footprint will be more susceptible to these risks and may face higher operating costs and potential devaluation25.
  • Social Risks: Properties that fail to address social considerations, such as tenant well-being, community engagement, accessibility, affordability, and health and safety standards, may face reputational damage and devaluation25. As social awareness grows, tenants and investors are increasingly seeking properties that align with their values and contribute to a positive social impact.
  • Governance Risks: Lack of transparency, ethical concerns, and poor operational management can lead to financial and reputational risks25. Strong governance practices are essential for ensuring accountability, mitigating risks, and building trust with stakeholders.

Opportunities:

  • Enhanced Financial Performance: Studies suggest a correlation between strong ESG practices and improved financial performance in CRE, including higher rental income, occupancy rates, and property values28. ESG-focused properties often attract higher-quality tenants and command premium rents, contributing to increased profitability28.
  • Competitive Advantage: ESG-focused properties are becoming increasingly attractive to tenants and investors, providing a competitive edge in the market28. As sustainability becomes a key differentiator, CRE companies that prioritize ESG can attract and retain tenants, secure financing, and enhance their brand reputation.
  • Resilience and Risk Mitigation: Proactive ESG adoption can enhance the resilience of CRE assets against climate-related risks and regulatory changes18. By implementing sustainable practices and adhering to evolving regulations, CRE companies can reduce their exposure to environmental and regulatory risks, ensuring long-term viability.

It's important to note the significant financial scale of the ESG trend in CRE. The USGBC estimates that commercial building owners and managers will invest an estimated $960 billion globally between now and 2023 on greening their existing built infrastructure29.

Furthermore, for commercial real estate companies, managing greenhouse gas emissions is a crucial part of any ESG strategy. Setting verifiable third-party targets, such as Science Based Targets, can help effectively reduce emissions while remaining transparent about progress31.

ESG Disclosure Frameworks and Standards

While a universal standard for ESG reporting in CRE is still evolving, several frameworks and standards provide guidance for companies seeking to disclose their ESG performance17.

 

Framework/Standard

Description

Examples in CRE

GRESB (Global Real Estate Sustainability Benchmark)

A widely recognized standard for assessing the ESG performance of real estate assets and portfolios32.

Used by investors to benchmark and compare the ESG performance of real estate funds and companies.

SASB (Sustainability Accounting Standards Board)

Provides industry-specific standards for disclosing material sustainability information to investors34.

Helps CRE companies identify and report on the ESG factors most relevant to their industry and investors.

CDP (Carbon Disclosure Project)

A voluntary framework for reporting greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related information34.

Enables CRE companies to disclose their environmental impact and track their progress towards emissions reduction targets.

SFDR (Sustainable Financial Disclosure Regulations)

Applies to EU and those marketing financial products to EU investors, guiding sustainability metrics and reporting17.

Influences CRE investment and disclosure practices for companies operating in or targeting European markets.

SDR (Sustainable Disclosure Regulations)

The UK equivalent of SFDR17.

Similar to SFDR, but specifically applicable to the UK market.

EU Taxonomy

A classification system for environmentally sustainable economic activities35.

Provides a framework for identifying and classifying sustainable investments in CRE.

GRI Standards

A widely used framework for sustainability reporting35.

Offers a comprehensive set of reporting guidelines for CRE companies to disclose their ESG performance.

TCFD (Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures)

Provides recommendations for climate-related financial risk disclosures35.

Helps CRE companies assess and disclose their climate-related risks and opportunities.

These frameworks and standards help CRE companies measure, manage, and report their ESG performance, enhancing transparency and comparability for investors and other stakeholders.

Case Studies of Successful ESG Implementation

Several case studies demonstrate the successful implementation of ESG in CRE, showcasing the potential benefits and challenges associated with these initiatives.

  • Invesco Real Estate: This firm has committed to ESG+R principles, focusing on enhancing building performance and promoting best practices to adapt to market changes. Their initiatives demonstrate the tangible benefits of integrating ESG into real estate operations35.
  • 321 Exhibition Street, Melbourne: This building achieved net-zero status through retrofitting, receiving top ratings for energy, water, and indoor environment performance. This showcases the potential for sustainable development and the value of green building certifications35.
  • Measurabl: This ESG platform, with nearly 11 billion square feet of real estate subscribed, has established itself as the industry standard for measuring, managing, and disclosing real estate ESG performance. It offers a wide range of features, including automated utility data collection, physical climate risk assessment, and cohort insights36.

These examples highlight the growing trend of ESG integration in CRE and the importance of data-driven solutions for tracking and reporting progress.

Conclusion: Embracing ESG in a Dynamic Environment

The future of ESG in the US CRE industry is undeniably intertwined with the evolving political, regulatory, and investor landscape. While challenges exist, the opportunities associated with ESG adoption are significant. By proactively addressing ESG risks and embracing sustainable practices, CRE stakeholders can enhance their financial performance, attract investors, and contribute to a more resilient and sustainable built environment.

Key Takeaways:

  • The political polarization surrounding ESG requires careful consideration and strategic planning for CRE investors and developers. Companies need to be aware of the varying legislation in different states and adapt their strategies accordingly.
  • SEC regulations are driving greater transparency and standardization in ESG reporting, increasing pressure on companies to improve data management and disclosure. This requires investment in robust data collection and reporting systems to ensure compliance and meet investor expectations.
  • Investor sentiment, while potentially shifting, continues to favor companies with strong ESG performance and credible reporting. CRE companies need to demonstrate their commitment to ESG through transparent and verifiable data.
  • ESG adoption in CRE presents both risks and opportunities, requiring a comprehensive approach to risk mitigation and value creation. Companies need to assess their ESG risks and opportunities and develop strategies that align with their business objectives and stakeholder expectations.
  • Utilizing established ESG disclosure frameworks and standards can enhance transparency and comparability for stakeholders. This can help CRE companies attract investors, secure financing, and improve their reputation.

Impact on Different Stakeholders:

  • Investors: Investors can use ESG data to identify and assess risks and opportunities in CRE investments. They can also use ESG factors to benchmark and compare the performance of different properties and portfolios.
  • Developers: Developers can incorporate ESG principles into the design and construction of new buildings, creating more sustainable and resilient assets. This can enhance the value of their properties and attract tenants and investors.
  • Property Managers: Property managers can implement ESG practices to improve the operational efficiency of buildings, reduce costs, and enhance tenant satisfaction. This can lead to increased rental income and property values.
  • Tenants: Tenants are increasingly seeking properties that align with their values and provide a healthy and sustainable work environment. ESG-focused buildings can attract and retain high-quality tenants, contributing to higher occupancy rates and rental income.

By staying informed about the latest developments and embracing a proactive approach to ESG integration, CRE stakeholders can navigate this dynamic environment and position themselves for long-term success.

Works cited

  1. Why ESG Is a Political Battleground in America - Impakter, accessed December 15, 2024, https://impakter.com/why-esg-is-a-political-battleground-in-the-us/
  2. The Impact of the U.S. Presidential Election on Corporate ESG Programs - Stratfor, accessed December 15, 2024, https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/impact-us-presidential-election-corporate-esg-programs
  3. ​ESG Battlegrounds: How the States Are Shaping the Regulatory Landscape in the U.S., accessed December 15, 2024, https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2023/03/11/esg-battlegrounds-how-the-states-are-shaping-the-regulatory-landscape-in-the-u-s/
  4. Climate change and the politicization of ESG in the US - Frontiers, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/political-science/articles/10.3389/fpos.2024.1332399/full
  5. The State of State ESG Activity as an Election Looms—a 2024 Mid-Year Review | Insights, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.ropesgray.com/en/insights/alerts/2024/06/the-state-of-state-esg-activity-as-an-election-looms-a-mid-year-review
  6. ESG Investing Regulations Across the 50 States - Morgan Lewis, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.morganlewis.com/pubs/2023/07/esg-investing-regulations-across-the-50-states
  7. Anti-ESG Legislation Proliferated in the States in 2023, but Traditional ESG Still Had Some Wins | MultiState, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.multistate.us/insider/2023/10/31/anti-esg-legislation-proliferated-in-the-states-in-2023-but-traditional-esg-still-had-some-wins
  8. 2023 ESG State Legislation Wrap Up | HUB - K&L Gates, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.klgates.com/2023-ESG-State-Legislation-Wrap-Up-7-19-2023
  9. ESG Reporting and SEC Disclosure | Deloitte US, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/audit/articles/esg-reporting-and-sec-disclosure.html
  10. Understanding New SEC ESG Disclosure Requirements | Blog - OneTrust, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.onetrust.com/blog/understanding-new-sec-esg-disclosure-requirements/
  11. SEC ESG-Related Disclosure - PRI, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.unpri.org/policy/us-policy/sec-esg-related-disclosure
  12. Addressing the New SEC Climate Disclosure Rule | S&P Global, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.spglobal.com/esg/solutions/addressing-the-new-sec-climate-disclosure-rule
  13. ESG: regulatory trends in the United States - Forensic Risk Alliance, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.forensicrisk.com/news-and-insights/esg-regulatory-trends-in-the-united-states
  14. Enhanced Regulatory Oversight in ESG Investing, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.theregreview.org/2024/08/24/enhanced-regulatory-oversight-in-esg-investing/
  15. Guidance on SEC climate disclosures, ESG regulations - PwC, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.pwc.com/us/en/services/esg/library/sec-climate-disclosures.html
  16. ESG Requirements Forcing Change - Counselors of Real Estate, accessed December 15, 2024, https://cre.org/real-estate-issues/esg-requirements-forcing-change/
  17. ESG In Commercial Real Estate - Smarter Technologies, accessed December 15, 2024, https://smartertechnologies.com/blog/esg-in-commercial-real-estate/
  18. How ESG Drives Value in Commercial Real Estate Investments - CBIZ, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.cbiz.com/insights/articles/article-details/a-sustainable-edge-how-esg-drives-value-in-commercial-real-estate-investments
  19. AIC Asks: Do ESG Credentials Matter to Investors Anymore? | Sustainability Magazine, accessed December 15, 2024, https://sustainabilitymag.com/articles/do-esg-credentials-matter-to-investors-anymore
  20. ESG Backlash in the U.S. and Europe: Shifting Sentiments and Regulations, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.bradley.com/insights/publications/2024/03/esg-backlash-in-the-us-and-europe-shifting-sentiments-and-regulations
  21. New Survey Of US Investors By Hoover And Stanford Scholars Finds Falling Support For ESG Investing, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.hoover.org/news/new-survey-us-investors-hoover-and-stanford-scholars-finds-falling-support-esg-investing
  22. Companies failing to act on ESG issues risk losing investors, finds new PwC survey, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.pwc.com/lt/en/about/press-room/pwc-global-investor-esg-survey.html
  23. ESG Trends Impacting Real Estate Valuation - EisnerAmper, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.eisneramper.com/insights/blogs/real-estate-blog/esg-real-estate-effects-on-valuation-re-blog-0823/
  24. Why ESG performance is growing in importance for investors | EY - Global, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.ey.com/en_gl/insights/assurance/why-esg-performance-is-growing-in-importance-for-investors
  25. ESG in Commercial Real Estate: What You Need to Know - VTS, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.vts.com/blog/esg-in-commercial-real-estate-what-you-need-to-know
  26. Commercial Real Estate Environmental Social Governance, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.keteres.com/esg/commercial-real-estate
  27. The Effect of ESG Factors on Real Estate Investment Decision-making Process, accessed December 15, 2024, https://blog.mipimworld.com/guide-green-real-estate/green-real-estate-impact-esg-factors-investment-decisions/
  28. The Strategic Advantage of ESG in commercial real estate - Equiem, accessed December 15, 2024, https://getequiem.com/blog/the-strategic-advantage-of-esg-in-commercial-real-estate
  29. ESG Value in Commercial Real Estate Investments, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.verdani.com/single-post/esg-value-in-commercial-real-estate-investments
  30. The Impact of ESG on Real Estate Management (Part 2) - Datakwip, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.datakwip.com/post/the-impact-of-esg-on-real-estate-management-part-2
  31. How is ESG Impacting Your Real Estate Risk? - ADEC Innovations, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.adec-innovations.com/blogs/how-esg-impacts-real-estate-risk/
  32. ESG frameworks for real estate: A 2023 guide - Chainels, accessed December 15, 2024, https://getchainels.com/en/blog/esg-frameworks
  33. What Are ESG Frameworks? Choose the Right One for Your Business - Quantive, accessed December 15, 2024, https://quantive.com/resources/articles/esg-frameworks
  34. The US approach to ESG compliance in real estate - Deepki, accessed December 15, 2024, https://www.deepki.com/blog/the-us-approach-to-esg-compliance-in-real-estate/
  35. Top Trends in ESG Reporting for the Real Estate Industry - Plan Be Eco, accessed December 15, 2024, https://planbe.eco/en/blog/top-trends-in-esg-reporting-for-the-real-estate-industry/
  36. CASE STUDIES OF SUSTAINABILITY IN COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE - Center for Buildings, Infrastructure, and Public Spaces, accessed December 15, 2024, https://cbips.engineering.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/covid%20lectures/CBIPS_4.20.22_Case%20Studies%20in%20Commercial%20Real%20Estate.pdf