Business Continuity ESG Blog

ESG in Banking and Investment

Written by William Tygart | 1/5/25 5:00 PM

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations are rapidly changing how the banking and investment industry operates. Investors and consumers are increasingly demanding that companies act responsibly toward the environment, society, and corporate governance. In response, many banks and investment firms are incorporating ESG factors into their investment decisions, lending practices, and overall business strategies. This report provides a comprehensive overview of ESG in the banking and investment industry, covering its adoption, policies, costs, and leading companies.

ESG Adoption in Banking and Investment

ESG adoption in the banking and investment industry has significantly increased in recent years. In 2020, nearly $1.5 trillion flowed into ESG funds, bringing the total assets under management to over $3 trillion 1. This growth is driven by several factors, including:

  • Investor demand: Investors are increasingly incorporating ESG factors into their investment decisions, seeking companies with strong ESG performance2.
  • Regulatory pressure: Governments worldwide are implementing ESG regulations and disclosure requirements, pushing companies to adopt ESG practices3. For example, the California Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act requires large companies doing business in California to report their carbon emissions, including those from their supply chains 4.
  • Consumer preferences: Consumers are gravitating toward brands that align with their values, including those that address ESG issues5.
  • Reputational risk: Companies with poor ESG performance face reputational damage, which can impact their profitability and long-term sustainability6.

ESG initiatives have gained significant momentum over the past decade, with the financial services industry seeing capital allocated based on ESG information and ratings 5. To understand the core components of ESG, it's essential to examine its three pillars:

  • Environmental: This pillar focuses on a company's position on environmental issues such as climate change, greenhouse gas emissions, waste, pollution, and other environmental considerations 5.
  • Social: This pillar examines a company's relationships with its employees, suppliers, customers, and the communities it operates in. It also considers human rights, workplace health and safety, diversity, equity and inclusion, and political ties 5.
  • Governance: This pillar focuses on the overall ethical conduct of a company and its board of directors. It considers business ethics, the interests of various stakeholders (employees, suppliers, shareholders, customers), and financial transparency 5.

While ESG adoption is increasing across various sectors, the utilities industry appears to be moving more aggressively in this direction 7. This difference might be attributed to the utilities sector facing stricter environmental regulations and having a longer history of incorporating environmental considerations into their operations 9.

Despite the growing adoption of ESG, some challenges remain:

  • Lack of standardized metrics: The ESG landscape lacks a consistent set of metrics and standards, making it difficult to compare ESG performance across companies and industries10.
  • Data availability and quality: Accessing reliable and high-quality ESG data can be challenging, hindering the effective integration of ESG into investment and lending decisions11.
  • Greenwashing concerns: Some companies exaggerate or misrepresent their ESG practices, making it difficult for investors to discern genuine ESG commitment10.

ESG Regulations and Reporting

ESG and non-financial reporting regulations in the United States are evolving as stakeholders increasingly demand transparency and accountability from companies regarding their impact on the environment, society, and corporate governance 12. While the US still needs a unified federal framework for ESG reporting akin to the European Union's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), various regulatory bodies and initiatives guide companies in disclosing their ESG practices and metrics.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) plays a pivotal role in ESG and non-financial reporting by requiring publicly traded companies to disclose specific ESG-related information material to investment decisions 12. Although historically focused on financial risks, the SEC has been moving towards more comprehensive ESG disclosures, including climate risks and human capital management, reflecting their impact on a company's performance and long-term value.

The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) provides industry-specific standards that help companies disclose material, financially relevant sustainability information to investors 12. While not mandatory, SASB's guidelines are increasingly recognized and adopted by US corporations aiming to meet investor demands for ESG data that can inform investment decisions.

Companies Leading the ESG Focus

Several banks and investment firms are leading the way in ESG adoption and integration:

  • BBVA: This Spanish bank offers sustainable alternatives for all its products, including sustainable investment funds, socially responsible pension plans, efficient home mortgages, and environmentally friendly car loans 13. They have also taken steps to eliminate the financing of coal projects by 2030 in developed countries and by 2040 globally 13.
  • USAA: This US-based financial services company has been tracking its ESG performance since 2000 13. They have an energy analytics program to monitor energy consumption in their office buildings and finance energy-efficient technology with the resultant energy savings 13.
  • Bank of America: This bank prioritizes local impacts in the communities it serves, champions racial equality and economic opportunity initiatives, and drives environmental sustainability 14. They were also the global leader in ESG-themed bonds and loans in 2022 15.
  • Citigroup: This bank centralizes ESG as a core part of its business and uses its resources to address societal challenges, particularly championing pay equity, addressing racial wealth gaps, increasing economic mobility, and confronting the climate crisis 14. They have pledged to commit US$1 trillion to sustainable finance by 2030, helping to finance climate solutions, including renewable and clean energy 14.

Many major banks and investing firms — including JP Morgan, Wells Fargo, and Blackrock — have incorporated ESG investing criteria into their processes and products 2.

Steps Taken by the Banking and Investment Industry to Adopt ESG

The banking and investment industry has taken several steps to adopt ESG, including:

  • Sustainable lending: Prioritizing loans to projects that promote renewable energy, reduce carbon footprints, and support environmental conservation 16.
  • Green bonds: Issuing bonds specifically to finance projects with positive environmental impacts 16.
  • Diversity and inclusion initiatives: Promoting a diverse workforce and inclusive culture within the organization 16.
  • Transparent reporting: Regularly disclosing ESG performance and initiatives to stakeholders 16.
  • ESG data management: Developing comprehensive approaches to ESG data collection, reporting, and integration into investment and risk management strategies 17. Banks are establishing dedicated leadership roles, increasing investments in ESG disclosures, and implementing new processes and tools to enhance ESG data management 18.
  • Energy efficiency: Implementing energy-efficient practices in banking operations and encouraging clients to do the same 16.
  • Setting ESG targets: Establishing ambitious ESG goals and aligning business strategies with sustainability objectives 19.
  • Developing integrated strategies: Embedding ESG opportunities into overall business strategies and operating models 19.
  • Engaging with stakeholders: Communicating ESG requirements and progress to investors, customers, employees, and other stakeholders 20.

ESG Policies in Banking and Investment

ESG policies in banking and investment cover a wide range of issues, including:

  • Environmental: Climate change mitigation, greenhouse gas emissions reduction, renewable energy financing, waste management, pollution prevention, and natural resource conservation 21.
  • Social: Labor standards, human rights, product safety, community engagement, diversity and inclusion, and data privacy 21.
  • Governance: Board diversity, executive compensation, anti-corruption measures, risk management, and shareholder rights 21.

These policies are implemented through various strategies, such as sustainable lending, green bonds, impact investing, and shareholder engagement 22.

Cost of ESG Adoption in Banking and Investment

The cost of ESG adoption in banking and investment can vary significantly depending on the scope and complexity of the initiatives. Some studies suggest that implementing ESG strategies can have a negligible impact on portfolio performance 23, while others indicate that ESG investments can generate positive financial returns and reduce operational costs 24.

Factors that can influence the cost of ESG adoption include:

  • Data collection and analysis: Gathering and analyzing ESG data can be expensive, especially for companies with complex supply chains or limited access to reliable data sources 25.
  • Technology investments: Implementing new technologies to support ESG data management and reporting can require significant upfront investments 17.
  • Training and development: Educating employees on ESG principles and integrating ESG considerations into business processes can involve training costs 20.
  • Compliance and reporting: Meeting regulatory requirements and disclosing ESG performance can involve compliance and reporting costs 25.

Despite these costs, many companies view ESG adoption as a long-term investment that can enhance their reputation, attract investors, and improve their overall financial performance 24.

When Did the Banking and Investment Industry Start Adopting ESG?

The roots of ESG considerations in investment can be traced back centuries to religious and ethical exclusions from investment practices, such as the Quakers and Methodists in the 1700s who excluded slave labor from their investment practices 26. In the 1970s, socially responsible investing (SRI) emerged as a way for investors to align their portfolios with their values 27. This movement gained momentum in the 1980s with the divestment campaigns against companies doing business in South Africa during apartheid. Over time, SRI evolved to look much like today's corporate social responsibility (CSR) and was focused primarily on social issues such as human rights and supply chain ethics.

The formal representation of ESG began in 2004 with the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative report "Who Cares Wins" 28. This report highlighted the importance of integrating ESG factors into investment decisions.

In 2006, the UN launched its Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI), a framework for incorporating ESG issues into investment 28. The PRI has gained significant traction, with over 3,000 signatories representing more than $100 trillion in assets by 2020 28.

The banking and investment industry's adoption of ESG has accelerated in recent years, driven by increasing investor demand, regulatory pressure, and consumer awareness 26.

Companies That Haven't Adopted ESG and Reasons Why

While ESG adoption is growing, some companies have yet to fully embrace ESG principles. Reasons for not adopting ESG include:

  • Focus on short-term profits: Some companies prioritize short-term financial gains over long-term sustainability and ESG considerations 10. However, studies indicate that firms with strong ESG practices often show better financial performance and can gain a competitive edge 29.
  • Lack of awareness or understanding: Some companies may not fully understand the importance of ESG or the potential benefits it can offer 30.
  • Concerns about costs: Some companies may be hesitant to adopt ESG due to concerns about the costs associated with data collection, technology investments, and compliance 10.
  • Lack of standardized metrics: The absence of standardized ESG metrics can make it difficult for companies to measure and report their ESG performance, potentially hindering their adoption 10.
  • Greenwashing concerns: Some companies may avoid ESG adoption due to concerns about being accused of greenwashing if they cannot meet the high standards expected by investors and consumers 31.

Conclusion

ESG is transforming the banking and investment industry, driving changes in investment decisions, lending practices, and overall business strategies. The increasing adoption of ESG is driven by investor demand, regulatory pressure, and consumer preferences, demonstrating a shift toward greater corporate responsibility and sustainability. However, challenges such as the lack of standardized metrics, data availability and quality concerns, and greenwashing concerns still need to be addressed.

The industry has taken significant steps to integrate ESG, including sustainable lending, green bonds, and ESG data management. Leading companies are setting ambitious targets and embedding ESG considerations into their core operations. As the ESG landscape continues to evolve, with regulations like the California Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act and initiatives from the SEC and SASB, the banking and investment industry will play a crucial role in promoting sustainable finance and responsible business practices. The future of ESG in banking and investment appears promising, with continued growth and increasing importance for long-term sustainability and financial performance.

Works cited

  1. ESG investing: Momentum moves mainstream - J.P. Morgan, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.jpmorgan.com/insights/global-research/esg/build-back-better-esg-investing
  2. 25 ESG Statistics You Need to Know in 2023 - Lisam, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.lisam.com/news/esg-statistics/
  3. Environmental, Social & Governance Laws and Regulations Report 2025 USA - ICLG.com, accessed January 5, 2025, https://iclg.com/practice-areas/environmental-social-and-governance-law/usa
  4. What US Companies Need to Know About Shifting Global ESG Landscape (and, Yes, That New SEC Rule), accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.corporatecomplianceinsights.com/shifting-esg-landscape-global/
  5. ESG In The USA: An Overview - Capco, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.capco.com/intelligence/capco-intelligence/esg-in-the-usa-an-overview
  6. What challenges do central banks face to implement environmental, social, and governance investing?, accessed January 5, 2025, https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/allaboutfinance/what-challenges-do-central-banks-face-implement-environmental-social-and-governance
  7. ESG utilities survey - PwC, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.pwc.com/us/en/industries/energy-utilities-resources/library/esg-utilities-survey.html
  8. ESG Risk: How Energy and Utilities Companies Can Stay Ahead ..., accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.auditboard.com/blog/esg-risk-how-energy-and-utility-companies-can-stay-ahead/
  9. How do ESG scores vary across industries? | by Rebecca Hayes - Medium, accessed January 5, 2025, https://medium.com/@The_Rebeckoning/how-do-esg-scores-vary-across-industries-f64103c5d56a
  10. The Reluctance To Embrace ESG: Why Some Wealth Managers Lag Behind, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.blacktowerfm.com/united-states/news/reluctance-to-embrace-esg/
  11. Challenges in Adapting ESG Practices in Banking: Overcoming Barriers to Sustainable Finance - Martlenz, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.martlenz.com/post/challenges-in-adapting-esg-practices-in-banking-overcoming-barriers-to-sustainable-finance
  12. All ESG and non-financial reporting regulations in the US - PlanA.Earth, accessed January 5, 2025, https://plana.earth/academy/us-esg-regulations
  13. Leading retail banking companies in the ESG theme - Retail Banker International, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.retailbankerinternational.com/data-insights/top-ranked-retail-banking-companies-in-esg/
  14. 2023's Top 10 Ethical Banks Leading the ESG Revolution - FinTech Magazine, accessed January 5, 2025, https://fintechmagazine.com/articles/top-10-banks-for-esg-in-2023
  15. Sustainable Finance Awards 2023: North America, accessed January 5, 2025, https://gfmag.com/award/sustainable-finance-awards-2023-north-america/
  16. ESG Banking: Integrating Sustainability into Finance - ThisRock, accessed January 5, 2025, https://thisrockesg.com/esg/esg-banking/
  17. Transforming finance: How ESG is redefining bank's business strategies, accessed January 5, 2025, https://insights.samsung.com/2024/07/29/transforming-finance-how-esg-is-redefining-banks-business-strategies/
  18. Banking and capital markets sector leans into ESG, bolstering leadership, investment and data management - KPMG International, accessed January 5, 2025, https://kpmg.com/us/en/media/news/banking-leans-into-esg-2023.html
  19. Banks must act now to capture ESG opportunities - PwC Strategy, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.strategyand.pwc.com/m1/en/strategic-foresight/sector-strategies/financial-sector-consulting/esg-opportunities.html
  20. ESG data governance: A growing imperative for banks - McKinsey, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/tech-forward/esg-data-governance-a-growing-imperative-for-banks
  21. What Is ESG Investing? - Investopedia, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/environmental-social-and-governance-esg-criteria.asp
  22. Why adopting ESG is a winning strategy for banks - Coforge, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.coforge.com/what-we-know/blog/why-adopting-esg-is-a-winning-strategy-for-banks
  23. The Cost of ESG Investing, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.ou.edu/content/dam/price/Finance/energyfinanceconference/2022/Session3-Paper2-oklahoma-ssrn.pdf
  24. The rising significance of ESG adoption - Acuity Knowledge Partners, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.acuitykp.com/blog/the-rising-significance-of-esg-adoption/
  25. The cost of ESG data is 'an elephant in the room' - Infrastructure Investor, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.infrastructureinvestor.com/the-cost-of-esg-data-is-an-elephant-in-the-room/
  26. Lesson 5.2: History of ESG | Preqin Academy, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.preqin.com/academy/lesson-5-esg/history-of-esg
  27. The History of Environmental Social And Governance (ESG) - IBM, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/environmental-social-and-governance-history
  28. What is ESG investing? - Deutsche Bank Wealth Management, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.deutschewealth.com/en/our-capabilities/esg/what-is-esg-investing-wealth-management.html
  29. Understanding ESG Regulations Across U.S. States: Key Insights for Businesses, accessed January 5, 2025, https://esgthereport.com/understanding-esg-regulations-across-u-s-states-key-insights-for-businesses/
  30. ESG Not Making Waves With American Public - Gallup News, accessed January 5, 2025, https://news.gallup.com/poll/506171/esg-not-making-waves-american-public.aspx
  31. The criticism of ESG: why is it becoming controversial?, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.ucem.ac.uk/whats-happening/articles/criticism-of-esg/
View full post