Behavioral Science Applications in Crisis Management

Behavioral science offers valuable insights into how people think, behave, and make decisions, especially in high-pressure situations like crises. By understanding these behavioral patterns, organizations can develop more effective communication strategies and crisis response protocols. This report explores the field of behavioral science and its application in crisis management, with a focus on how companies like American Airlines and Marriott International have successfully leveraged these principles to navigate challenging situations.

What is Behavioral Science?

Behavioral science is a multidisciplinary field that investigates human behavior through observation and experimentation. It draws on principles from psychology, economics, sociology, and neuroscience to understand the factors that influence decision-making, motivation, and social interactions¹. Behavioral science examines how individuals make choices, often in ways that deviate from traditional economic models of rationality². It explores the impact of emotions, social influences, and environmental factors on human actions². By understanding these influences, organizations can design interventions and strategies that promote desired behaviors¹.

Key Principles of Behavioral Science

Several key principles underpin the field of behavioral science:

• Cognitive biases: These are systematic errors in thinking that can affect judgment and decision-making. For example, confirmation bias is the tendency to favor information that confirms existing beliefs, like a person who believes that left-handed people are more creative might only notice instances where this is true and ignore examples that contradict this belief³. Anchoring bias is the tendency to over-rely on the first piece of information received, even if it's not the most relevant. For instance, if a car salesperson starts negotiations at a very high price, the buyer might be anchored to that number and end up paying more than they intended.
• Framing effects: The way information is presented or framed can significantly influence choices. For example, people are more likely to choose an option presented as a gain rather than a loss, even if the outcomes are identical. This is why marketers often emphasize the positive aspects of a product or service rather than the potential drawbacks.
• Social norms: People's behavior is often influenced by what they perceive as acceptable or expected within their social group. For instance, individuals are more likely to litter in a place where there is already a lot of litter because they perceive it as the norm.
• Loss aversion: Individuals tend to feel the pain of a loss more strongly than the pleasure of an equivalent gain. This explains why people are often reluctant to take risks, even when the potential rewards outweigh the potential losses.
• Default bias: People are more likely to stick with the default option, even if it's not the best choice for them⁴. This is why many organizations automatically enroll employees in retirement savings plans unless they explicitly opt out.

Behavioral Science in Crisis Management

Crisis management is the process by which an organization deals with a disruptive and unexpected event that threatens to harm the organization or its stakeholders. The study of crisis management originated with the large-scale industrial and environmental disasters in the 1980s. It is considered to be the most important process in public relations.

Crisis situations often involve high stress, uncertainty, and time pressure, which can impair decision-making and communication. Behavioral science can help organizations address these challenges by:

• Improving communication: Understanding how people process information during crises can help tailor messages for clarity, empathy, and effectiveness.
• Enhancing decision-making: Behavioral science frameworks can guide decision-makers in evaluating options, managing risk, and avoiding cognitive biases.
• Promoting trust and cooperation: By considering social norms and behavioral influences, organizations can foster trust and encourage cooperation among stakeholders.
• Building resilience: Behavioral science can inform strategies for coping with stress, managing emotions, and promoting psychological well-being during and after a crisis.

Applying behavioral science principles can lead to more effective crisis management by improving communication, decision-making, and resilience. For example, research by King's College London found that most people are resilient to crises and that mental health resilience can be supported within the community⁵. This highlights the importance of community support in crisis management and the potential for behavioral science to inform interventions that promote resilience.

Social and behavioral sciences (SBS) play a crucial role in emergencies and crises. They help contextualize the impact within specific cultural, economic, and social contexts, allowing for tailored and culturally sensitive response strategies⁶. By incorporating perspectives from political economy, SBS enables a comprehensive analysis of how power dynamics and resource allocation influence crisis dynamics⁶. This understanding guides policymakers in developing responses that address both immediate needs and systemic issues. SBS also captures the lived experiences of individuals and communities, providing a nuanced understanding of their needs and challenges during a crisis⁶. This is vital for empathetic and effective response initiatives.

Furthermore, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) plays a significant role in community behavioral health response during disasters. The VA provides support to communities following regional disasters, offering behavioral health services to both veterans and non-veterans⁷. This highlights the VA's commitment to community well-being and its capacity to provide essential support during crises.

Case Studies: American Airlines and Marriott International

American Airlines

American Airlines has demonstrated the effective application of behavioral science in crisis communication, particularly during disruptions like flight delays or cancellations. The company uses its app and digital platforms to provide passengers with immediate updates and rebooking options⁸. This proactive communication helps reduce passenger frustration by empowering them with information and control over their situation⁸. Additionally, American Airlines offers compensation to affected passengers, such as travel vouchers and meal credits⁸. This gesture acknowledges the inconvenience caused and helps maintain customer satisfaction.

In the aftermath of the September 11th attacks, American Airlines utilized its website to provide timely updates and condolences to the public⁹. The website became a central hub for information, offering instructing communication with facts and action steps, as well as adjusting communication with condolence messages and links to relief organizations⁹. This approach demonstrated a commitment to transparency and support for those affected by the tragedy. Moreover, American Airlines recognizes the importance of pre-crisis communication. By providing information and building positive relationships with the public before a crisis occurs, the company can pre-condition public perception and create a foundation of trust that can be invaluable during challenging times⁹.

Proactive communication and compensation can significantly improve customer experience during crises, as demonstrated by American Airlines.

Marriott International

Marriott International has also embraced behavioral science principles in its crisis management approach. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the company faced unprecedented challenges with hotel closures and travel restrictions. CEO Arne Sorenson addressed associates directly through a video message, acknowledging the severity of the situation and demonstrating empathy for their concerns¹⁰. This transparent and authentic communication fostered trust and a sense of unity during a difficult time¹⁰.

Marriott also launched the "Rooms for Responders" initiative, providing free hotel stays to healthcare professionals fighting the pandemic¹⁰. This act of social responsibility not only supported frontline workers but also enhanced the company's reputation and demonstrated its commitment to community well-being.

Furthermore, Marriott International is committed to pay equity and diversity within its workforce¹¹. The company conducts regular pay equity reviews and makes adjustments to ensure fair compensation practices¹¹. This commitment to social responsibility aligns with the principles of behavioral science, recognizing the importance of fairness and equity in organizational behavior.

Authentic leadership and social responsibility are crucial for building trust and maintaining a positive reputation during crises, as exemplified by Marriott International.

Behavioral Science Techniques and Frameworks

Several specific techniques and frameworks from behavioral science can be applied to crisis communication and decision-making:

• The Krebs method: This framework provides a structured approach to crisis communication, emphasizing clarity, transparency, and actionability. It involves informing the public about what is known, what is unknown, what the organization is doing, what the public should do, and when they will hear more¹². For instance, during a product recall, a company using the Krebs method would clearly communicate the nature of the defect, which products are affected, what actions the company is taking to address the issue, what consumers should do with the recalled product, and when they can expect further updates.
• The EAST framework: This framework focuses on making desired behaviors easy, attractive, social, and timely. It can be used to encourage preparedness, evacuation, and other actions during crises¹³. For example, to encourage people to prepare for a hurricane, authorities could provide easy-to-access information kits, highlight the benefits of preparedness, promote community preparedness events, and issue timely warnings and reminders.
• Choice architecture: This involves designing the environment in which choices are made to influence behavior¹⁴. For example, presenting options in a specific order or using defaults can nudge people towards desired outcomes. In a crisis situation, this could involve making evacuation routes easily accessible and clearly marked, or providing pre-selected emergency kits with essential supplies.
• Crisis intervention techniques: These include active listening, empathetic communication, and non-verbal strategies to de-escalate crisis situations and provide support to individuals in distress¹⁵. Crisis intervention techniques emphasize respecting the person and normalizing their response, recognizing that individuals in crisis may be experiencing heightened emotions and may need support to regain a sense of control¹⁶. For example, a trained crisis counselor might use active listening to understand the individual's concerns, use empathetic language to validate their feelings, and maintain calm body language to create a safe and supportive environment.
• Psychological reactance: This concept explains that people tend to resist messages that threaten their freedom of choice or autonomy¹⁷. In crisis communication, it's important to frame messages in a way that empowers individuals and avoids language that might trigger reactance. For example, instead of saying "You must evacuate immediately," a more effective message might be "For your safety, we strongly recommend evacuating as soon as possible."
• Stress Model of Crisis Behavior Support: This model emphasizes the importance of understanding the individual's stress level and providing support to help them regulate their emotions and behavior¹⁸. Key components of this model include self-awareness, active listening, and validating responses¹⁸. For instance, a teacher working with a student experiencing a meltdown might use the Stress Model to identify triggers, provide a calming environment, and offer support to help the student manage their emotions.

Challenges and Limitations

While behavioral science offers valuable tools for crisis management, it's essential to acknowledge potential challenges and limitations:

• Ethical considerations: Applying behavioral science techniques requires careful consideration of ethical implications, ensuring that interventions respect individual autonomy and avoid manipulation¹⁹. For example, using behavioral nudges to influence people's choices during a crisis should be done in a way that respects their freedom of choice and avoids coercion.
• Contextual factors: Behavioral patterns can vary depending on cultural, social, and individual differences. It's crucial to tailor interventions to specific contexts and avoid generalizations. For instance, a crisis communication strategy that is effective in one culture might not be appropriate in another.
• Data limitations: Behavioral science research often relies on experimental studies or observational data, which may not always be generalizable to real-world crisis situations²⁰. For example, findings from a study conducted in a controlled laboratory setting might not accurately reflect how people behave in a real-world disaster.
• Complexity of human behavior: Predicting and influencing human behavior in crisis situations can be challenging due to the interplay of various factors, including emotions, social dynamics, and individual differences²¹. This complexity makes it difficult to develop one-size-fits-all solutions for crisis management.

Some of the major challenges associated with crisis management include information mismanagement, resource allocation issues, and ineffective communication²². These challenges can hinder coordination and collaboration among response teams, leading to delays and inefficiencies in crisis response.

Overreaction and groupthink are psychological traps that can hinder effective crisis management²³. Overreaction involves taking extreme measures that may not be necessary or proportionate to the threat, while groupthink occurs when a group's desire for harmony or conformity results in an irrational or dysfunctional decision-making outcome.

During a crisis, there is often a temptation to wait out a situation or blame others²⁴. These tendencies can delay action and hinder accountability, potentially exacerbating the crisis.

Behavioral science research also faces limitations related to narrow stimuli, generalizability, and measurement validity²⁰. Some studies may use a limited range of stimuli or rely on measures that are not fully validated, which can affect the reliability and generalizability of their findings.

Furthermore, behavioral science in the 21st century faces broader technological challenges²⁵. The increasing use of artificial intelligence and other technologies raises ethical considerations and requires careful navigation to ensure responsible application of behavioral science principles.

Conclusion

Behavioral science provides a valuable framework for understanding and managing human behavior in crisis situations. By applying these principles, organizations can improve communication, enhance decision-making, and build resilience. Companies like American Airlines and Marriott International have successfully leveraged behavioral science to navigate challenging events, demonstrating the practical value of this approach. While challenges and limitations exist, the insights from behavioral science offer significant potential for improving crisis management strategies and fostering more effective responses to unexpected events.

The future of behavioral science in crisis management holds immense promise. As research continues to advance and our understanding of human behavior deepens, organizations will be better equipped to anticipate and respond to crises in a way that minimizes harm and promotes well-being. By integrating behavioral science principles into crisis management plans and training programs, organizations can create a more resilient and adaptable workforce, capable of navigating the complexities of unexpected events and emerging challenges.

Works cited

1. What is Behavioral Science – Mindworks | Chicago Booth, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.chicagobooth.edu/mindworks/what-is-behavioral-science-research
2. What is behavioral science? - Optimizely, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.optimizely.com/optimization-glossary/behavioral-science/
3. 5 Behavioral Science Principles Every Beginner Should Know - YouTube, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ_bC8WhOWM
4. Behavioral Science Concepts - BehavioralEconomics.com | The BE Hub, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.behavioraleconomics.com/resources/mini-encyclopedia-of-be/
5. Understanding behaviour during crises | King's College London, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/spotlight/understanding-behaviour-during-crises
6. The Role of Social and Behavioural Sciences in Emergencies and Crises - K4DD, accessed January 19, 2025, https://k4d.ids.ac.uk/resource/the-role-of-social-and-behavioural-sciences-in-emergencies-and-crises/
7. Three case studies of community behavioral health support from the US Department of Veterans Affairs after disasters - PubMed Central, accessed January 19, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8015747/
8. How American Airlines Optimizes Customer Experience (CX) with Technology-Driven Services - Renascence, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.renascence.io/journal/how-american-airlines-optimizes-customer-experience-cx-with-technology-driven-services
9. United Airlines' and American Airlines' online crisis communication following the September 11 terrorist attacks, accessed January 19, 2025, https://is.muni.cz/el/1456/podzim2006/PHMA2/um/2691073/United_Airlines_and_AA.pdf
10. How Marriott International's Response to COVID-19 Set An Example For The Travel Industry | by Mariana Pinedo | Marketing in the Age of Digital | Medium, accessed January 19, 2025, https://medium.com/marketing-in-the-age-of-digital/how-marriott-internationals-response-to-covid-19-set-an-example-for-the-travel-industry-2c2a70aba228
11. SERVE 360 REPORT - Marriott: Serve360, accessed January 19, 2025, https://serve360.marriott.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/2021_Serve_360_Report.pdf
12. Crisis communication: A behavioural approach, accessed January 19, 2025, https://gcs.civilservice.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Behavioural_science_guide_to_Crisis_Communications_PDF_Official.pdf
13. EAST Framework - The Decision Lab, accessed January 19, 2025, https://thedecisionlab.com/reference-guide/management/east-framework
14. A Management framework to Apply Behavioral Sciences for decision making - Medium, accessed January 19, 2025, https://medium.com/bummary/a-management-framework-to-apply-behavioral-sciences-for-decision-making-4994135186a5
15. Effective Crisis Intervention Techniques: A Comprehensive Guide, accessed January 19, 2025, https://crisisconsultantgroup.com/california/effective-crisis-intervention-techniques-a-comprehensive-guide/
16. Behavioral Crisis and First Response: Qualitative Interviews with Chicago Stakeholders, accessed January 19, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9243918/
17. Crisis communication: A behavioural approach - GCS, accessed January 19, 2025, https://gcs.civilservice.gov.uk/publications/crisis-communication-a-behavioural-approach/
18. The Stress Model of Crisis and Behavior Support Techniques - Green Chimneys, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.greenchimneys.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Stress-Model-of-Crisis-Behavior-Support-Tech-11.24.20.pptx.pdf
19. Behavioral Science in the 21st Century: 5 Challenges | Psychology Today, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/consumed/202307/behavioral-science-in-the-21st-century-5-challenges
20. Pitfalls of Behavioral Science: Avoiding untrustworthy data | TDL - The Decision Lab, accessed January 19, 2025, https://thedecisionlab.com/insights/innovation/the-pitfalls-of-behavioral-science-how-to-avoid-untrustworthy-data
21. (PDF) Key Challenges in Crisis Management - ResearchGate, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329144549_Key_Challenges_in_Crisis_Management
22. Challenges to effective crisis management - Joanna Abraham, accessed January 19, 2025, https://abrahamj.people.uic.edu/pubs/j6.pdf
23. The Psychology of Crisis Management: Understanding Human Behaviour to Enhance Business Continuity - Nordic Cyber Group, accessed January 19, 2025, https://ncgrp.se/post/the-psychology-of-crisis-management-understanding-human-behaviour-to-enhance-business-continuity/
24. Human Behavior and Its Impact on Crisis - The Institute of Strategic Risk Management, accessed January 19, 2025, https://theisrm.org/en/human-behavior-and-its-impact-on-crisis
25. Behavioral Science in the 21st Century: 5 Challenges | Psychology Today, accessed January 19, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/consumed/202307/behavioral-science-in-the-21st-century-5-challenges